Reform deputy's AI photo condemned as 'fake news'

Jason Arunn MurugesuNorth East and Cumbria
News imageDarren Grimes/AI A screenshot of an AI-generated image showing a group of South Asian men in black tracksuits next to a white coach in a suburban housing estate as part of a Facebook post. Underneath there is a headline from Darren Grimes' blog saying Durham is Not a Dumping Ground: Fix the Great Housing Betrayal. Under that are icons and numbers to show 5,500 people have reacted to it and there are 760 comments and 665 shares.Darren Grimes/AI
Darren Grimes later acknowledged the photo used in his post about housing was AI-generated

The use of an AI-generated image by a council deputy leader has been described as "fake news" and "inflammatory" by local councillors and an MP.

Durham County Council's Reform deputy leader, Darren Grimes, admitted a photograph depicting a group of South Asian men in a housing estate, which he used in a blog about other councils "shipping" families to the region, was created using AI.

The authority's Liberal Democrat opposition leader, Amanda Hopgood, said it was "nothing short of disgusting". Green Party councillors claimed it had been aimed at sowing "racial hatred".

Grimes said those criticising should focus on the county's problems rather than "the use of AI to illustrate" them.

The deputy leader previously told the BBC the AI image of South Asian men was "obviously for illustrative purposes".

His article linked the issue of southern councils moving families to County Durham, which the BBC reported on last month, to the region's lengthy social housing waiting list.

Hopgood said the relocation of people to County Durham by other councils needed to be taken seriously but this issue did not affect social housing waiting lists as the families were being put into private accommodation.

"It comes as no surprise that councillor Grimes is once again promoting fake news but to do that with an AI-created photo is nothing short of disgusting," she said.

News imageLDRS Darren Grimes is smiling and wearing a navy suit with a light blue tie and a Reform rosette in the same colour. His short brown hair is swept to the side. LDRS
Grimes said he used the AI image for "illustrative purposes"

A Durham resident, who wished to remain anonymous, told the BBC he had complained to the council about an AI image used by Grimes in previous online posts about immigration.

In a blog, published in November, the deputy leader said County Durham was being used as a "migrant dumping ground" and he did not want the region to be the country's "sponge".

The post included an AI-generated image of two white girls playing in a tidy front garden with a group of Asian men outside a dilapidated house next door, overlaid with a picture of Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood.

The resident said the image made it look like someone had taken a picture of a real situation.

News imageDarren Grimes/AI A screenshot of an AI-generated photo of terraced houses. On the left there is a dilapidated house with a group of Asian men standing outside. On the right there is a well-kept house with two white girls playing on the grass outdoors. Darren Grimes/AI
This AI-generated image was a section of a larger composite image used in a blog by Darren Grimes

The two Green Party members on the council said the image showing a group of men on a road in a housing estate was "the latest in a series of social media posts from the deputy leader of Durham County Council intended to misinform, divide and sow racial hatred within Durham's communities".

North Durham Labour MP Luke Akehurst criticised the use of AI-generated images, saying: "It's inflammatory and fake news to use AI-generated images to illustrate a policy argument like this."

Labour councillor Rob Crute said Grimes was "using fake images to score political points".

"It's cheap and it's easy but it'll be seen by our residents as just another attempt to grab the headlines," he said.

Grimes dismissed the councillors' criticism, saying Labour, the Liberal Democrats and the Greens did not care "one iota" about the people of County Durham.

What he had published was not "racial hatred", he said.

"It isn't. It is the opposite. It is standing up for every Durham family, of every background, who played by the rules and is being told to wait longer because the system has been rigged against them."

News imageDarren Grimes/AI A composite image with an AI-generated photo of terraced houses on the left hand side. This image features a dilapidated house with a group of Asian men standing outside. On the right there is a well-kept house with two white girls playing on the grass outdoors. In the middle is Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood in a dark blue head scarf putting a finger to her mouth. There is a white van on the right hand side. There is also the logo of the Home Office and a red Labour party logo with a white flower.Darren Grimes/AI
Grimes said opposition politicians did not care about people in County Durham

Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.

Related internet links