Film prompts cathedral to remove 'blood libel' leaflet

Nanette AldousNorfolk
News imageShaun Whitmore/BBC An aerial view of Norwich Cathedral and its grounds.Shaun Whitmore/BBC
Norwich's Christian and Jewish communities are coming together to retell the story of William of Norwich

A cathedral has removed a leaflet recounting an antisemitic medieval myth in a move prompted by a new film.

Norwich Cathedral took the action after taking part in the short documentary The Innocents, made for the UK Jewish Film Festival 2025.

The leaflet contained the Norwich blood libel - a false accusation made in the 12th Century stating Jews had ritually murdered a local boy called William - a story that spread across the globe.

In the film, the Norwich Jewish community expressed discomfort about the leaflet being placed in the cathedral's Holy Innocents chapel, named after the biblical story about the massacre of infants by King Herod.

In response to the removal of the leaflet, Dr Marian Prinsley, president of Norwich Hebrew Congregation, said: "Symbolically it's very important for all Jewish people in this country and wider.

"You can't have the story of King Herod and the story of William of Norwich being conflated and the Jews being blamed for the killing of babies."

News imageShaun Whitmore/BBC A head and shoulders photo of Dr Marian Prinsley inside Norwich Synagogue. She is wearing a teal blue jacket, has mid-length grey/blonde hair and dark rimmed glasses. Shaun Whitmore/BBC
The president of Norwich Synagogue, Dr Marian Prinsley, says the city's Jewish community still carries the weight of medieval antisemitism

In the film, Dr Prinsley said presenting the two stories together was "an issue that has been festering within the Jewish community".

"Saint William was the boy that was supposed to have been killed in Norwich and there's certainly no evidence that the Jews killed him," she said.

She believed the lie was fabricated in order to bring pilgrims to the cathedral which helped it to raise money, but that the widespread ramifications of that were very serious for Jewish people.

News imageShaun Whitmore/BBC A head and shoulders photo of the Dean of Norwich Cathedral, the Very Revd Dr Andrew Braddock. He is wearing a grey coat, grey and black scarf and clerical collar. He has short grey hair and wears thin rimmed glasses.Shaun Whitmore/BBC
Dean of Norwich Cathedral, the Very Revd Dr Andrew Braddock, will work with Norwich Synagogue to reassess the presentation of the story of William of Norwich

Dean of Norwich Cathedral, the Very Revd Dr Andrew Braddock, said: "We've got to be honest about our history as a cathedral.

"This is one of the places where that blood libel myth starts to be propagated and shared, and the terrible, terrible damage and suffering that's caused."

He added that the Norwich blood libel "has played a tragic part in the long and dark history of antisemitism".

News imageShaun Whitmore/BBC A small, dimly lit chapel interior with a simple design. At the center is a wooden altar featuring a carved cross symbol on its front panel. Two tall white candles in black holders stand on either side of the altar, and above it hangs a framed religious painting depicting several figures. Shaun Whitmore/BBC
Norwich Cathedral's Chapel of the Holy Innocents is close to what is thought to be the place of William's medieval shrine

The Jewish Small Communities Network commissioned director Jonathan Weinberg to make the short documentary.

He said the way the story was presented in the chapel would not necessarily lead people to believe the blood libel myth.

But, Mr Weinberg added, "the way that it was presented was definitely, I think, still a bit offensive to the Jewish community".

"The making of the film, it gave the Jewish community the confidence to speak to the cathedral community about how they felt and about how they would like to see this presented in different way, in a more honest way," he said.

In the closing scenes, Dr Braddock tells Dr Prinsley the leaflet has been removed from the cathedral after admitting "we need to do this better".

Representatives from Norwich synagogue and the cathedral will meet next month to start a process to decide how best to tell the story of William, in a more "meaningful" way.

The Innocents is being shown in cinemas as part of the UK Jewish Film Festival 2025.

Follow Norfolk news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.


More from the BBC