'A disgrace' - patient reacts to neurology report

Chris CraddockBBC Jersey communities reporter
News imageBBC Sophie sits inside a modern hair salon, with styling stations, mirrors, and hair products visible behind them. The salon has grey décor and bright lighting.BBC
Sophie Reid said she had experienced failings within the health department during her brain tumour diagnosis

A patient has said problems at Jersey's neurology department highlighted in an external report are a "disgrace".

The report from the Royal College of Physicians (RCP) said "many of the neurology team were working beyond their job plans" and had been reliant on a single consultant who had recently retired.

Sophie Reid, 37, who was diagnosed with a brain tumour in 2024, said: "It's another department that's been left to go to pieces".

But Simon West, the medical director for Health and Care Jersey, described the report as "very positive", adding: "It's clear there's still more work to be done and lots for us to cover over the next year or so."

News imageSophie Reid Sophie lies on an operating table in a brightly lit surgical theatre, covered in blue drapes with their feet visible at the end. Several medical staff in scrubs and masks stand around the patient, with plastic drapes and equipment surrounding the operating area. Overhead surgical lights and monitoring machines are visible.Sophie Reid
Reid had an operation which revealed she had a grade three malignant tumour

Reid said "processes weren't followed" when she experienced a delay in her diagnosis because she was not offered a CT scan after suffering a seizure at work.

She said: "It's not fair that we have to keep fighting to improve services. I'm actually starting to wonder whether it will actually happened in my lifetime."

She added: "I put a post on my Facebook and I tagged all of the people that I know who have brain tumours here and all of them basically reiterated exactly what I am saying".

RCP has issued a series of recommendations for improvements which include devising a plan to assess workforce requirements and evaluating the administrative support provided to the team.

News imageSimon sits in an office beside a desk with two computer monitors, a keyboard, and various desk items. A fan and other equipment are in the background, giving the space a clinical or administrative feel.
Simon West said there was a lot to be positive about in the report

West said an action plan was in place in response to the report and the department had already acted on two recommendations from RCP.

West said: "We've been ambitious and we're trying to deliver as much as we possibly can in the shortest period of time so that we can improve services for islanders."

"It really highlights the amount of work that has been absorbed by the department in the face of an ever-growing demand," he added.

"I would continue to review departments in the hospital because that's just normal so it's not so much that patients should be worried about the department being reviewed - I'd be worried if the department wasn't reviewed."

News imageKaren sits in an office with light‑coloured walls. Behind them is a large circular decorative wall piece featuring patterns and symbols. A wooden desk is partially visible to one side.
Deputy Karen Wilson said she was concerned change in the department was not happening quick enough

But Deputy Karen Wilson, a registered nurse, said she was concerned by issues raised in the review.

She said: "Clearly patients have been let down. The pace of the response is not what you would normally expect to see."

Wilson added: "It quite upsets me to see you know that staff are under pressure constantly and there is no response from an operational point of view to actually improve that in a timely way."

The government has said the recommendations are being incorporated into a medicine recovery plan which would be monitored monthly.

It said a recruitment process to hire a new consultant neurologist had started with interviews for the role scheduled to take place in March.

Follow BBC Jersey on X and Facebook. Send your story ideas to channel.islands@bbc.co.uk.

Related internet links