This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.
Skip to main contentAccess keys helpA-Z index
 
You are in:Home >Community
Special Announcement:
On 1st March we moved to a new blogging system.

The archives of all the student, teacher and staff blogs are still available here to read but commenting has closed.

Here is the link to the new system:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/learningenglish

We still have student, staff and teacher blogs for you to comment on, however in the new system you do need to register to leave comments.
  
Monday, 07 May 2007

English Teachers in Taiwan

Hello there,

Today, after 2 days off, I would like to talk about English Teachers in Taiwan. And it concerns about English Learning in Taiwan.

Knowing is one thing, and teaching is totally a different thing from various angles.
I didn’t know the true meaning of it until I taught math to a junior high student when I was a college sophomore boy. It was a one by one class, somebody call it is a one to one class or a private class. I was very surprised that at that time why I can’t tell or explain all I know to the student well? I want to, but I just can’t! I am very impressed on it even till now.

When I was 13 years old, I learnt English with 2 westerners who are priests. It’s my first time to meet foreigners, one is German, other is American, as I recall. In Taiwan, in 1960’s, we learnt English since 12 years old, that the year we enter into junior high, it’s 13th grade of western system. Nowadays, people here learnt English since 5 years old when they are in the kindergarten. It is critical here, and somebody said:’ It is still older than westerner.’ And it is just a saying.

As my two daughters, elder one learnt English from 9, and the younger learnt English from 5, and who learnt better, all I can say is ’ Learning is one thing, knowing could be something other’.

In the old time of Taiwan, like my school ages, a few westerners came to Taiwan to teach English, that is about 1960s’, There were some westerners taught English in urban city like Taipei city with two and half million people, At that time, if you speak English, and you are a foreigner, then you can taught English, no matter your mother language is English, no matter your education is high or low, no matter your major is English teacher or other fields, it’s all right, as you are a foreigner and you can speak English that even say ‘good morning ’’hello’ only, thus, you can be a qualified English teacher in Taiwan, furthermore, you would got a high paycheck. And there were no foreigner except priests taught English in my hometown Yilan County with four hundred and fifty thousand populations.

There are many Cram Schools in Taiwan, what is cram school, we call it ‘bu xi ban” (bu3 xi2 ban1). It is a after school courses that train students to master important courses, like English. They are popular in East Asia like Taiwan, Japan, South Korea, Hong Kong, and Mainland China. Cram is derived from the slang term “cramming’ which means to study a large of material in a short period of time. Cram schools are usually privately owned.

Since about 1989, Taiwanese was allowed to travel abroad, and more westerner came to Taiwan to teach English, more English cram School was set also. And more qualified westerner teachers have been coming to Taiwan nowadays.

Tell you a scenario in Taiwan :
A westerner English Teacher came into the class of the cram school in Taiwan. It is the first class.
(In cram school, the students don’t need to do the procedure ‘Rise, Attention, Bow, sit’),

Then, teacher opened his/her mouth and said:” Hello, victims, I will torture you.”
(All students opened their mouth up widely, and could not close it for a while)

Oops, Teacher thought that students might misunderstand his/her meaning, oops…..

Fortunately, after a moment, the teacher reminded of something, then said to the students:” victim is v-i-c-t-i-m” “ torture is t-o-r-t-u-r-e

Then, all students closed their mouth and picked their dictionary up to check those two words, and murmured to each other:’ Why didn’t teacher say ‘hello student’ or ‘good morning student’ instead of telling us those two vocabularies that we didn’t understand? Why the first class has been so tough that the students needed to check the dictionary just at the first two words.”

After that first class, all the students rushed to the service center of cram school, asking the clerks to protect them from the teacher’s torture. The clerks all explained at once:’ The teacher’s meaning is that he/she wants to be strict with he/her student, so he/she said “torture”, and the student who was tortured is the victim. It is good for you to have a strict teacher. In other words, the teacher would teach you seriously.’

What did those victims who had being tortured say after listening to the clerks’ explanation?
Oops, I forgot it. I am too old to remember something. but I’ll tell you guys only I recall it some other day,

My blog tomorrow will be a record of my blog. Let's wait and see.

Love always,
Knowing is one thing, teaching is something else.
James Zhih-Cheng Wu

(Correction by James,on 2007/5/8):
Joey is right,quot her/his comment as follow:
Hello, James. As you mentioned, "the year we enter into junior high , it’s 13th grade of western system. " I think it should be 7th grade of the western system, not 13th. Just a reminding, not trying to challenge you. ^_^
posted by Joey from Taiwan

Comments

Dear James, I like your blogs very much and I am impressed by the daily amount of information you give us. Learning these things about your country's history and culture is very interesting. Please tell us more. Best wishes, Andrea

Hi,James It is an another bank holiday called May day in England.We took our son to Donnington park where there are lots of Grand Prix cars at a motor musuem. It was good to watch my son excited about the cars.Anyway I must apologize for the typing mistake which I should have typed "Lincoln" not "nincoln".I am orginally from Korea but I live in Lincoln which is located in the centre of England.I am sorry again if I confused you.Have a great day!hyoshil

Hello James, Differently from you, I didn´t learn English at school. In fact, I only could learn English properly when I got a job and I enrolled in an English private school eight years ago. Unfortunately, until now, the teaching of a second language in Brazil public schools has been very poor. When we learn something, it is just the to be verb, and in the present form! Can you imagine that? However, I think the problem has deeper roots. How can we teach a second language, when we don´t have even teachers to teach the basic subjects such as Portuguese, Maths and so on? Yes, it´s really hard to imagine that. Terefore, some winds of changing are blowing around and I think that the government is planning an education reform. Well, it´s just like the saying: "better late than never", and I wish that one day my country could provide a good education for all the citizens. Best wishes, Ana Paula.

Hello, James. As you mentioned, "the year we enter into junior high , it’s 13th grade of western system. " I think it should be 7th grade of the western system, not 13th. Just a reminding, not trying to challenge you. ^_^

Hi,James,It is definitely true that Knowing is one thing,teaching is something else.Beacause i have been a teacher for six months,and like you,i can totally understand how it feels when you try to teach the kids.

I totally agree with you. This problems can be easily found no matter in secondary school and university. Some teachers or lecturers who have high quality education background may not good at teaching. They may know how the model runs but don't know how to explain how the model runs. This will make students confused when learning. Therefore, a good teacher should be presentable. Otherwise, he had better be a researcher.

hi,bro!i'm as happy as a dog with two tails to see the taiwanese guy be a blogger.BTW,I'm not taiwanese ,i'm the NTU of overseas chinese student.Most of our teachers are very helpful and care for students like me (overseas student).From today on ,i'll be one of your big fan . BYE~

Haha, I like the words "victim" and "torture". They remind me of one of my former English teachers. By the way, he is pretty good! (Just in case he might read your article. :) )

Hi James I 'm pary from Iran , it's my first comments on your Blogs , So welcome to this moth Blog ( I know it's a little late ) . I wish you, have a enjoyable time with this hilarious service ( Blog ) . It seems you have some sense of humor like other man Blogers . I 'm really eager for reading your every day entries . But it will be grate if you explain us more about your country , it's important cities ,it's culture , it's customs and etc . I 'm very curious about your Brizillian host and the lottery program . According to your Blogs , I guess , you have studied , math in high school , don't I ? If so , how you are a law man , know ? These days , rhere are many cram English school in my country , but in my childhood there are not more current . But all of the teathers are native and you know it;s not good at all , so the BBC BLog servic is very good , spesially for me . So i have oppurtunity for having native teachers here . Kiss your lovely daughters for me and send my hello to your wife Bye

Hello James, your entry about teachers and teaching in your country was really interesting! Especially, that I am a teacher too, so I am interested in such stories. It is a pity that you cannot recollect the end of the story! Try to concentrate please or find out a decent happy ending to it!:) Best wishes Kriszta

Hi James. I personaly appretiate when a man has his own attitude and own style. Sumarizing, I like your blogs. I have been reading them and they are all interesting.

Hi, Jame! It's so fun for me to read your entry on the site. I can study the structure and phrase of english from yours. It's useful. From now, I will write blog to express my feelings of life, love...Inshort, I like your blogs.

Thanks for all your contributions. This blog has now closed and can no longer accept new comments.

May 2007

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Archive