BBC SPORTArabicSpanishRussianChinese
BBCiNEWS  SPORT  WEATHER  WORLD SERVICE  A-Z INDEX   SEARCH 

BBC Sport
 You are in: Other Sports: Horse Racing: Epsom Derby 2002 
Sport Front Page
-------------------
Football
Cricket
Rugby Union
Rugby League
Tennis
Golf
Motorsport
Boxing
Athletics
Other Sports
Statistics
US Sport
Horse Racing
Snooker
Sailing
Cycling
Skiing
-------------------
Special Events
-------------------
Sports Talk
-------------------
BBC Pundits
TV & Radio
Question of Sport
-------------------
Photo Galleries
Funny Old Game
-------------------
Around The UK: 
N Ireland
Scotland
Wales

BBC Sport Academy
News image
BBC News
News image
BBC Weather
News image
SERVICES
-------------
LANGUAGES
EDITIONS

 Saturday, 8 June, 2002, 15:40 GMT 16:40 UK
Your Derby verdict
Who do you fancy for success at Epsom?
High Chaparral's victory in the Vodafone Derby on Saturday gave trainer Aidan O'Brien his second consecutive win in the race.

Send your congratulations to the winning team.

HAVE YOUR SAY

The Irish trainer won his first Derby at Epsom in 2001 when Galileo triumphed.

This year, O'Brien clocked up a one-two with High Chaparral and runner-up Hawk Wing.

Moon Ballad, who led for much of the race, finished in third place.

The race was marred by the death of Coshocton, who had to be put down after falling in the latter stages of the race.

Was High Chaparral a worthy winner?


This debate is now closed. A selection of your e-mails appear below.


This is from a gambling point of view. High Caparral and Hawk Wing are two very high class colts but the poor punters were completely bamboozled as to which horse to back. Aidan O'Brien was only concerned with winning the Derby - it didn't really matter which one.

There was confusion all day about the going, stamina doubts, etc. If he was restricted to one entry then the choice would have been easy, albeit the one left in would have been odds on. Similar confusion reigned in the 2000 Guineas when O'Brien had the first two home in Rock Of Gibralter and Hawkwing. Martin Pipe does the same thing - at Cheltenham I had Lady Cricket/McCoy and was done on the line by his 25/1 outsider. Give us a break. Katy O'Halloran
Katy O'Halloran, England

I would just to express my congratulations to the winning connections of High Chapparal. Also sincere condolences to all connected with Coshocton.

Horses will break legs, shoulders etc - Mother nature didn't have a particularly good idea when she made their legs so thin compared to the weight carried on top. All that racing can do is make it as safe as possible for them. It could happen to any horse any time but in such a public arena it brings in home how precious they are.
Rita Simcox, England


An excellent race and, in the conditions, a worthy winner in High Chaparral
Alan Hyndman, Northern Ireland
I watched my horse break a leg playing in his paddock. It is absolutely heartbreaking but can happen at any time to any horse. My deepest sympathies to all connections. On the race itself - not as exciting as last year but still a great spectacle.
Caroline, UK

Great race, but I think questions need to be asked. Not only did Coshocton, break a leg and lose his life, but we now see Fight Your Corner has also had to have major surgery to have his leg pinned. Some of those horses still had baby fluff in their tails! Only the most mature 3 year olds should be put through this type of endurance. If anyone had seen the state Coshocton was in at the start it was obvious he had already taken too much out of himself and the poor chap ran his heart out.
Kimberly Moore, England

I am a keen racegoer and enjoyed watching the Derby. However - I saw a horse pushed beyond when a human would have cried enough. To me this can only be done by the fear of the whip. Ban it! I have heard all the arguments for it, ie "it keeps me balanced"etc.

Just take the whip out of the game.

Jockeys would still be on a level playing field and Carshocton might still be alive.
Peter Teague, Wales


The death of the beautiful colt Coshocton was horrific
Victoria Parker, England
Flat racing is becoming uncompetitive with Ballydoyle and Godolphin dominating the big races, as in the Oaks and Derby, but High Chapparal's win was a good one. I don't believe the renewals were substandard - Kazzia is proving to be as good as Oh So Sharp at the moment.

It is simply the two-team dominance that is watering down Flat racing. The death of the beautiful colt Coshocton was horrific, especially being right near the scene. My thoughts are with his connections and Philip Robinson, who is thankfully alright now.
Victoria Parker, England

"That's what horses are bred for...our pleasure"... Willie Carson's comments about Coshocton's horrific fall were unforgiveable.
Kate Bergman, UK

An excellent race and, in the conditions, a worthy winner in High Chaparral. On soft ground and over this distance, the offspring of Sadler's Wells and Daarshan mares are hard to beat indeed.
Alan Hyndman, Northern Ireland

Awesome win by High Chaparral! Thought Hawk Wing would catch him with a few lengths to go but no chance!
Paul Taylor, England

It was a fine race comparable to any from recent years, but for me it will be overshadowed by the death of the beautiful Coshocton.
Joy, England


The glory days of the Epsom Derby are now firmly behind us
Nigel Baptiste, Trinidad, West Indies

The Ballydoyle express marches relentlessly on. I don't believe the better of the two won the race and the ground was on the slow side of good. High Chapparal is a very good each-way bet for the Arc and I believe Hawk Wing is a shoe-in for the Breeders' Cup.
James, Ireland

Congrats to Aidan O'Brien - another excellent showing - proving once again that the Irish are kings of the Flat.
Daniel Smyth, Dublin

The glory days of the Epsom Derby are now firmly behind us. The horses are running just for the prize money.

The standard of this year's Oaks and Derby left a lot to be desired and both races were won by sub-standard animals. Oh for the glory days of Mill Reef, Nijinsky, Shergar, Reference Point - those were racehorses!
Nigel Baptiste, Trinidad, West Indies

News, reports and features on the Derby

High Chaparral wins

Oaks Day

Special features

Sports Talk

Official site

AUDIO/VIDEO
Links to more Epsom Derby 2002 stories are at the foot of the page.


News image
News imageE-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Epsom Derby 2002 stories

News imageNews imageNews image
News image
© BBCNews image^^ Back to top

Sport Front Page | Football | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League |
Tennis | Golf | Motorsport | Boxing | Athletics | Other Sports |
Special Events | Sports Talk | BBC Pundits | TV & Radio | Question of Sport |
Photo Galleries | Funny Old Game | N Ireland | Scotland | Wales