Brobbey scores for SunderlandImage source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Sunderland move above Newcastle in the Premier League table

At a glance

  • Anthony Gordon scores early goal for Newcastle after defensive error

  • Chemsdine Talbi equalises in second half for Sunderland

  • Brian Brobbey scores 90th-minute winner for visitors

  • Newcastle drop to 12th, one place below Sunderland

  • PLAYER RATER

ByMichael Emons
BBC Sport journalist at St James' Park

Brian Brobbey scored a dramatic 90th-minute winner as Sunderland came from behind to beat Newcastle in a thrilling Tyne-Wear derby at St James' Park.

Newcastle had been on target for their first home victory in this fixture since 2010 when Anthony Gordon gave the hosts a ninth-minute lead.

Sunderland played out from the back but defender Luke O'Nien's pass was intercepted by Nick Woltemade and he gave it to Gordon, who did the rest to score his 17th goal of the season.

The hosts almost made it 2-0 just before the break, but Sven Botman headed against the post following a cross from left-back Lewis Hall, one of five Newcastle players to be included in Thomas Tuchel's latest England squad.

But the visitors equalised 12 minutes into the second half.

Goalkeeper Aaron Ramsdale, another called up by Tuchel, did not get great distance on a punch, the ball was played back into the box, Brobbey chested it goalwards and Dan Burn cleared off the line, only for Chemsdine Talbi to fire in the rebound.

Noah Sadiki had a chance to put Sunderland ahead, only for him to shoot at Ramsdale.

Yet it did not prove costly as Brobbey scored the late winner, to the delight of the away fans, when he converted a rebound from close range after Ramsdale saved his first attempt.

The result gives Sunderland their first league double over Newcastle since 2014-15.

Newcastle analysis: European return looks a long way off

Before the game, Newcastle manager Eddie Howe had spoken of looking for a quick return to Europe. That came on the back of a humiliating Champions League elimination on Wednesday when they conceded four second-half goals to lose 7-2 at Barcelona and 8-3 on aggregate in their last-16 tie.

Depending on who wins the FA Cup, eighth in the Premier League may be enough to secure European football next season, and at half-time Newcastle were heading ninth and would have been only one point behind eighth-placed Everton with seven league games to go.

But, in a turnaround that had not looked likely, Sunderland responded superbly after the break and were much the better team.

In the end, the away supporters, situated high behind the goal where their team had scored twice, were the ones left cheering as they followed their 1-0 win at the Stadium of Light with another success.

After Sadiki's shot was saved by Ramsdale when it was 1-1, Newcastle thought they had regained the lead with substitute Malick Thiaw heading into the net from Lewis Hall's corner.

However, the home cheers soon turned to grumbles when the goal was ruled out with Jacob Murphy impeding goalkeeper Melker Ellborg while also standing in an offside position.

Newcastle drop to 12th, one place below Sunderland, with this result a big blow to Howe's hopes of an instant return to continental action.

The atmosphere at the end was in marked contrast earlier when thousands of black, white and gold flags had been placed on chairs for the home supporters to wave.

That, along with a spectacular tifo that ran along the side of one of the stands, produced a stunning visual display as the players came out.

The home supporters also held up banners, mocking Sunderland's absence from the top flight with one saying 'Welcome to the region's capital, you've been gone for so long'.

But, in the end, the visitors were the ones who had the last laugh.

More to follow.

How to play

Rate players out of 10 for this game. The rater will close 30 minutes after the final whistle. You must be signed in to a BBC account to play.

1Give it up
10Pure perfection

Number: 32 A. Ramsdale
Number: 3 L. Hall
Number: 33 D. Burn
Number: 4 S. Botman
Number: 2 K. Trippier
Number: 41 J. Ramsey
Number: 7 Joelinton
Number: 11 H. Barnes
Number: 27 N. Woltemade
Number: 20 A. Elanga
Number: 10 A. Gordon

Substitutes

Number: 21 T. Livramento
Number: 23 J. Murphy
Number: 18 W. Osula
Number: 12 M. Thiaw
Number: 28 J. Willock
Number: 9 Y. Wissa

After the opportunity to rate players has closed, the score displayed represents the average from all the submissions by BBC Sport users.