Confused...
I'm a red blooded male and I think Beyonce is one of the most beautiful women in the world, however here's a couple of things.
1. This video is for a single off her new album that has already been released in the U.S. I love this song - if it is released in the UK I think it'll be a huge hit. However, in the video, she scares me a little bit. I don't like the violent dancing and there is just something a little odd about it.
2. Rumours abound on the internet that one of the dancers is of dubious gender, i.e. is it a man or a woman? Look closely and discuss.
Comment number 1.
At 11:15 13th Nov 2008, Chuchika wrote:omg, i really think that that is a man o.O or maybe it's just a really manly looking girl :O
Complain about this comment (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
At 10:24 14th Nov 2008, gregbrocklehurst wrote:there,s definately a wanger in there some where ........but you stil would eh?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
At 23:01 14th Nov 2008, ValentinaL wrote:1. I love the dancing! haha looks very nice in my opinion!
Im a dancer so I understand if you dont like it.. Its still bloody brilliant tho!
2. Yeah... I think someones not really a girl... but maybe its a manly lady... or a girly boy... I guess we'll never know!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 3)
Comment number 4.
At 00:43 15th Nov 2008, Jessica Lares wrote:The one on the left, I can see what you mean.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 4)
Comment number 5.
At 15:13 15th Nov 2008, wrdmatt wrote:S-He...is a man,
Nice one Greg
Complain about this comment (Comment number 5)
Comment number 6.
At 15:15 15th Nov 2008, ChloeBabe-x wrote:definatly a man no question about it
:)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 6)
Comment number 7.
At 15:15 15th Nov 2008, Little_le wrote:NO - I cant see it AT ALL!!
Greg me thinks you need your glasses me lovely
Cheap Video though!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 7)
Comment number 8.
At 15:15 15th Nov 2008, gemmaa91 wrote:there's definitely some manly traits in there!
see what you mean.
he-she. girl-boy. lady-boy.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 8)
Comment number 9.
At 15:16 15th Nov 2008, kelbee_xx wrote:Definitely a love sausage there.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 9)
Comment number 10.
At 15:17 15th Nov 2008, AndyK1801 wrote:that is such a man. more man than i am.. i wouldn't like to meet her??? him? it in a dark ally!!! errrrr!!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 10)
Comment number 11.
At 15:17 15th Nov 2008, lubylou7 wrote:omg how manly is he/she.. greg i think ur right, bit ott with the dancing lucy x
Complain about this comment (Comment number 11)
Comment number 12.
At 15:17 15th Nov 2008, xenathekat wrote:'She' has very manly features. that chap should go on the maury show!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 12)
Comment number 13.
At 15:18 15th Nov 2008, drfish7876 wrote:I think she's just a bloody ugly woman.
She's got the right hips for a female, and she's got boobies, and a round bottom.
Then again, so as Chris Moyles lol
Complain about this comment (Comment number 13)
Comment number 14.
At 15:18 15th Nov 2008, PlobyR wrote:I don't think people should be making judgements on the dancer's gender in such a superficial way. Perhaps the dancer is transgendered and identifies as a woman. Gender identity is what you feel like, not what parts you were born with. If the dancer identifies as a woman then she is a woman.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 14)
Comment number 15.
At 15:18 15th Nov 2008, vicky_lea wrote:wow thats if its a man its had its bits taken off!! not that i looked that closely :D
but he/she has great legs lol
x
Complain about this comment (Comment number 15)
Comment number 16.
At 15:19 15th Nov 2008, sol_player29 wrote:not gonna lie greg, the one on the left does look like a man but i doubt he/she is coz beyonce has this new found hatred for men so would she hire him/her as a backing dancer? shes always going on about how her all band are all woman etc
Complain about this comment (Comment number 16)
Comment number 17.
At 15:21 15th Nov 2008, LovingTheAwesomeness wrote:huummm
well, the dancing,, iss quiteee scary to be comletely honest
freaky even
and i'm a dancer, i dance well though
haha
well
the girl/man,, its hard to tell really
she's a scary woman if she is one
Complain about this comment (Comment number 17)
Comment number 18.
At 15:22 15th Nov 2008, Hugh9191 wrote:I agree with Little_le, I cant see anything!
It is a scary video tho, wouldn't want to get on the wrong side of any of them!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 18)
Comment number 19.
At 15:22 15th Nov 2008, Ollid62 wrote:She/He is soooooo manly it is strange at the begining i couldn't tell but then it was so ovious.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 19)
Comment number 20.
At 15:23 15th Nov 2008, Ollid62 wrote:MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....
Complain about this comment (Comment number 20)
Comment number 21.
At 15:23 15th Nov 2008, LindsayWalkerX wrote:I think it is a woman, just a bit manly.
why would they dress up a man to look like a woman ? when they could get a woman dancer just as easy, maybe even easier. Might be wrong.
if it is a man, looks like woman, if it is a woman then, doesnt make a very good one. haha S-HE cant win :)
xxx
Complain about this comment (Comment number 21)
Comment number 22.
At 15:23 15th Nov 2008, Ollid62 wrote:MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....MAN....
Complain about this comment (Comment number 22)
Comment number 23.
At 15:24 15th Nov 2008, maz_9300 wrote:Hmm, looks like a man at times, but looks like a woman at times... im thinking it is a woman, although i do understand why people think its a man... im going to stick with " it "
Complain about this comment (Comment number 23)
Comment number 24.
At 15:24 15th Nov 2008, 3Alexx wrote:Omg .. Its a Shmale / Gorillia Type Thing
Complain about this comment (Comment number 24)
Comment number 25.
At 15:27 15th Nov 2008, Ciogravenhorst wrote:Excuse me??
I'm a laaaaaady!!!
Love the dancing, and I don't think she is a man. Just very manly... you should go more often to the gym and you will see real confusing things...
Complain about this comment (Comment number 25)
Comment number 26.
At 15:28 15th Nov 2008, cleverArina wrote:After choosing such a cool suggested member name i cant make a mistake))) I think she is a woman))) but with some male features))I am sure she would be very upset if she read another 9 comments))))))Poor dancer))))
Complain about this comment (Comment number 26)
Comment number 27.
At 15:30 15th Nov 2008, allys-girl wrote:Why does it matter?
If this woman did used to be a man it has no bearing on fabulous she looks now and if she didn't used to be a man then you are quite mean for suggesting it.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 27)
Comment number 28.
At 15:31 15th Nov 2008, clairerepper wrote:It turns out she really is a girl, her name's Ebony. She just unfortunately has "strong features".
Complain about this comment (Comment number 28)
Comment number 29.
At 15:48 15th Nov 2008, sasaroo wrote:Hi Greg,
I really don't think that's a man, and I'm suprised you do... did you honestly think Beyoncel would have some sort of trans gender dancer? Not that there would be anything wrong with that!
Though I agree she does have STRONG features!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 29)
Comment number 30.
At 15:58 15th Nov 2008, -ShellFish- wrote:Hmmm... Tricky ,
It Definatly Looks Like A Man..
I can see why you think He/She Is..
Love The Radio Station xx
Complain about this comment (Comment number 30)
Comment number 31.
At 18:38 15th Nov 2008, Hundredsofshoesgal wrote:I think the dancing is a bit over the top for a music video tbh but ther's no denying beyonce's an amazing dancer!
Not totally seeing the he/sheeness of the dancer, if it is a man where exactly are they hiding their manliness in that leotard!? :p
Complain about this comment (Comment number 31)
Comment number 32.
At 20:54 15th Nov 2008, nikkistevo wrote:i think you will find out they are both male. his name is shane
Complain about this comment (Comment number 32)