BBC Sportrugbyunion

IN ASSOCIATION WITH

Related BBC sites

Page last updated at 13:29 GMT, Sunday, 27 July 2008 14:29 UK

Rugby union 'stuck in a ghetto'

South Africa win the 2007 World Cup
The report said failing to award the 2011 event to Japan was a mistake

The 2015 Rugby World Cup must be awarded to a developing nation so the sport can break away from its "ghetto", according to a report.

England and Wales may make a joint bid for the event, along with South Africa.

"Rugby union is stuck in a ghetto," said consultant Quentin Smith, who is also chairman of Sale Sharks.

"The first question for any decision made by the International Rugby Board (IRB) must be 'How does this push forward globalisation?'"

Japan are also understood to be vying for the 2015 competition, having been pipped by New Zealand for the right to host the 2011 tournament.

"Quite clearly that was a mistake - deciding to go to Japan would have opened up substantial new markets," added the report's co-author William Field, a partner at Spectrum Value Partners, a consultancy group whose work encompasses the sports industry.

The report stated that the sport's world governing body, the International Rugby Board (IRB), was "unrepresentative and undemocratic" with too much power awarded to the eight foundation unions.

"Over half of the world's 4m registered players are English and 97% of people watching last year's World Cup final came from foundation unions," said Field.

"There is a deep, systemic problem within rugby, The perspective needs to shift to be more international. Globalisation needs to become the number one agenda item within rugby

606: DEBATE
"The first question in any decision made by the IRB must be 'How does this push forward globalisation?'

"A cultural shift needs to take place. The World Cup is one of the biggest decisions the IRB has to make. It is important rugby makes the right decision next time."

Earlier in July, Australian rugby chief John O'Neill said that smaller countries were being priced out of the opportunity to host the Rugby World Cup.

The IRB wants �100m and �120m respectively from the hosts of the 2015 and 2019 events.

"There are very few countries that could put their hands up for that sort of commitment," said O'Neill.

"I'm not sure these can be sustained over the long haul without reducing the candidates down to France and England."

The IRB will announce the host nations for the 2015 and 2019 World Cups next July.


see also
England and Wales ponder Cup bid
09 Jul 08 |  Rugby Union
O'Neill criticises World Cup cost
14 Jul 08 |  Rugby Union
Autumn plan for 2011 World Cup
17 Nov 06 |  Rugby Union
Wheeler questions World Cup vote
12 Jan 06 |  Internationals
Japan accepts World Cup decision
09 Jan 06 |  Internationals
New Zealand handed 2011 World Cup
17 Nov 05 |  Internationals
Johnson backs Japan 2011 RWC bid
17 Oct 05 |  Internationals
Rugby World Cup 2007 results
14 Oct 07 |  Rugby Union
BBC Sport Wales coverage
23 Mar 08 |  Wales


related bbc links:

related internet links:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites