Have your say on the action

  1. Postpublished at 18:00 GMT 5 January

    We'll leave it there for this live page, on what has been a remarkable afternoon in Glasgow.

    Wilfried Nancy sacked after just eight matches and 33 days in charge.

    You can read back through this page to catch up, subscribe to our dedicated Celtic page for further reaction and we'll keep you across all the action when the Parkhead outfit next take to the field.

    They host Dundee United on Saturday, but who will be in the dugout, we do not know.

    Until then, goodbye.

    Wilfried NancyImage source, SNS
  2. Who next?published at 17:56 GMT 5 January

    The big question now for Celtic is what on earth they do next.

    Brendan Rodgers walked and Martin O'Neill would possibly be reluctant to take interim charge again.

    Would Ange Postecoglou fancy another stint at Parkhead after his short stay at Nottingham Forest? Might Shaun Maloney step up?

    As we mentioned earlier, will they now wait until the summer for a permanent appointment and hand someone the reins until the end of the season?

    Neil Lennon and Scott Brown are both in jobs. Would managers without a tie to Celtic be keen to walk into such an obviously divided club?

    Only time will tell.

  3. Did Nancy ever 'get' Celtic?published at 17:53 GMT 5 January

    Amy Canavan
    BBC Sport Scotland

    Unsurprisingly, pictures of Martin O'Neill's goodbye to the Celtic support last month, following the narrow win against Dundee, are doing the rounds.

    The feel-good factor had returned and a split support were united.

    I was at Wilfried Nancy's long-awaited first win against Aberdeen 17 days into his tenure, and the drop in mood was monumental.

    There were no big celebrations, no sigh of relief from the manager or any outburst of emotion. He was straight up the tunnel, too.

    In the post-match interview, he was relatively flat. No different to pre-match when he was under enormous pressure.

    Many have said, and questioned, if the Frenchman ever 'got' what it's like being a boss in Glasgow's fishbowl.

    I think we now have the answer...

  4. Warning signs there from day onepublished at 17:49 GMT 5 January

    Kheredine Idessane
    BBC Sport Scotland

    The signs were there right from the first team-sheet that things could go spectacularly wrong for Wilfried Nancy.

    I remember scratching my head at his decision to field just three defenders for the visit of league-leaders Hearts.

    Not just three defenders, either. An back three comprised entirely of left-footed players, one of whom - Kieran Tierney - is a more natural wing-back.

    As for the wing-backs that day? Two forwards whose defensive attributes are not their best qualities: Yang Hyun-Yun and Sebastian Tounekti.

    All subsequent selections looked a variation on a theme: players not deployed in their natural, favoured positions in a system the side didn't look like it fully understood.

    Celtic were unable to stop conceding goals, which came as no great surprise given the roles players were being asked to fulfil. Luke McCowan as a wing-back. Anthony Ralston as a centre-back.

    Wilfried Nancy was apparently not one for round pegs in round holes and it has cost him his job in just over a month.

    In fairness to the Frenchman, not having a reliable striker also doomed his system to failure. The amount of glaring chances created but missed was another feature of his short spell in charge.

  5. Nancy 'was doomed to fail'published at 17:45 GMT 5 January

    Celtic podcaster Tino Callaghan has been talking to BBC Radio Scotland in the past 15 minutes and calls the situation at Parkhead a "shambles".

    "I was taken aback this afternoon," he said. "I thought if Celtic were going to pull the trigger, it would be after the game on Saturday.

    "He's gone now though and the big question is - what next?

    "I wonder if Martin O'Neill would step back in. Maybe Shaun Maloney would be more likely. It all depends if the club decide to bring in an interim or permanent manager. It's a shambles.

    "A galvanising figure tends to bring everyone on board, but we did that a couple of months ago and now we find ourselves back in this position.

    "There's so much going on off and on the park. It's such a crucial decision.

    "Nancy's style is so unique and for any system like they to work, you need a full pre-season and a transfer window. It's almost as though he was doomed to fail. It's such a puzzling decision in hindsight."

  6. 'Doesn't change anything' for Hearts - Gordonpublished at 17:40 GMT 5 January

    Former Celtic goalkeeper Craig Gordon has had his say on Wilfried Nancy's dismissal.

    The 43-year-old is currently in his second spell at Hearts but spent six years at Parkhead.

    The Tynecastle club are six points clear of Celtic and Rangers in the Scottish Premiership table.

    “It's a results business," he said. "It's never nice to see anybody lose their job. But from our point of view, it doesn't change anything.

    “We'll just concentrate on ourselves. We've got a big job to do up at Dundee. And that's all from Heart's point of view that we'll be focusing on.

    “I think whoever comes in, you know the size of Celtic. It's a huge club. They expect to win almost every single match.

    “And when that doesn't happen, it's not an enjoyable place to be. For them, it's about starting again. For us, it's just about concentrating on what we've got to do.

    “We won't be looking at anybody else outside of our own. We've got a big job to do and that's all we'll focus on.”

    Craig Gordon catches a ball during Hearts trainingImage source, SNS
  7. 'Football doctor' Tisdale also shown the doorpublished at 17:35 GMT 5 January

    Amy Canavan
    BBC Sport Scotland

    While much of the attention is on Wilfried Nancy's exit, many supporters will be just as - if not more - pleased and relieved at Paul Tisdale's departure.

    The self-proclaimed "football doctor" was appointed the club's head of football operations in October 2024 and has rarely not been in the firing line.

    It's widely believed Nancy was his recommendation, his choice and his appointment, which is why there has been even more attention on the former Exeter City manager... On top of the dreadful summer transfer window he presided over.

    It didn't help being caught with his eyes closed when the camera panned to him in Nancy's first game against Hearts.

    Its been a collective failure, and Tisdale played a colossal part.

    TisdaleImage source, SNS
  8. Postpublished at 17:31 GMT 5 January

    Former Celtic defender Ramon Vega, who played under Martin O'Neill during his first reign, has weighed in on today's events.

    Ramon VegaImage source, X
  9. 'The board are to blame'published at 17:27 GMT 5 January

    Get involved via the link at the top of the page

    One man I think should be considered is Robbie Keane, who is doing a great job in Hungary.

    Kenny

    Feel sorry for Nancy. He was totally out of his depth, and inherited a squad bereft of the level of quality needed at Celtic. The board are to blame for that. Nancy didn’t do himself any favours, though, by being too stubborn with his preferred 3-4-3. Reinstating O’Neill and Shaun Maloney is the only way to salvage the league campaign, because they have the necessary experience of managing at Celtic, but they’ll need to be fully supported in the transfer window.

    Ian

    Relief, couldn’t get much worse and there’s still time for someone to step in and sort out the mess. At this point it doesn’t matter who comes in as long as they can get the players to believe in themselves and get the fans behind them. Onwards and upwards, the board do not get any credit here though, they are simply cleaning up a mess they made and have some way to go before they get the fans backing.

    Mark

    Why did it take so long to sack such a failing manager? What he's done will have long standing effects for Celtic.

    William

  10. Postpublished at 17:24 GMT 5 January

    What is interesting is that none of the Celtic squad, as far as I can tell, have posted anything on social media today.

    Does silence speak louder than words?

  11. It’s not what you said it’s how you said itpublished at 17:19 GMT 5 January

    Scott Mullen
    BBC Scotland

    So many people will look at the results of Wilfried Nancy’s tenure as being the reason for his departure. And for the most part they’d be right.

    However, the manner of those defeats is what did for him in the end. A stubbornness to play a system his group was not equipped to, defensively passive and meek, while unconvincing in attack.

    Leads were surrendered and against Motherwell they were thoroughly outplayed. Nancy relentlessly argued there was progress, but nobody else could see it.

  12. 'Nancy had neither buy-in nor results'published at 17:16 GMT 5 January

    Kheredine Idessane
    BBC Scotland

    You can only achieve culture change if you take people with you. What Wilfried Nancy was trying to do - significantly alter the side’s style from day one - required a minimum of two things: buy-in from the players and instant results.

    The reason the Frenchman is now the shortest serving manager in the long history of the football club is that he clearly had neither.

    In the end it all boiled down to yet another massive gamble from those running the club. A 33-day experiment - a grand leap of faith - which blew up in their faces in spectacular fashion.

    Nancy wanted to play a certain way, in a certain formation regardless of whether he had players able to turn his vision into a workable reality.

    Rather than use what he had to the best of their ability, he tried to shoehorn round pegs into square holes and his defence - using the word loosely - wasn’t able to stop conceding goals.

    Nancy was a record-breaker. The first time ever a Celtic manager lost his first two matches, let alone four.

    Six defeats from eight games. The opportunity to win the season’s first piece of silverware blown, after the interim-manager had taken care of Rangers in the semis.

  13. 'He's gone'published at 17:11 GMT 5 January

    Dry January is over for Sir Rod Stewart.

    He's off to the boozer to celebrate Wilfried Nancy being relieved of his duties.

    He also wants Martin O'Neill back until the end of the season and perhaps Robbie Keane to follow him in the summer.

    Someone might want to let Rod know that Celtic aren't playing Dundee at the weekend, though. It's Dundee United.

    This X post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.View original content on X
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    Skip X post

    Allow X content?

    This article contains content provided by X. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as they may be using cookies and other technologies. You may want to read X’s cookie policy, external and privacy policy, external before accepting. To view this content choose ‘accept and continue’.

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
    End of X post
  14. Postpublished at 17:07 GMT 5 January

    Scott Mullen
    BBC Scotland

    We now face a scenario where the first four Old Firm games of the season will have be contested by a different pairing of managers for each game. Quite incredible.

    1. Russell Martin v Brendan Rodgers
    2. Danny Rohl v Martin O'Neill
    3. Danny Rohl v Wilfried Nancy
    4. (Likely) Danny Rohl v ???

    Unless O’Neill comes back.

    Or Rodgers...

    We’ve never seen anything like it.

  15. 'Bring back Martin O'Neill'published at 17:02 GMT 5 January

    Get involved via the link at the top of the page

    Bring back Martin O'Neill to steady the ship again until a new appointment is made.

    Anto

    Too little, too late, Nancy will be talked about for decades to come, board should all resign.

    Will

    Great news, never good to see a man lose his job but I don't think he realised what managing Celtic was all about (it's life and death) also clear to see that the players were unhappy and he couldn't inspire anyone!

    Tony

    His tactics never worked. He didn't have the respect of the dressing room and was destined to fail. At least the board have made the correct decision with Tisdale going as well. Long way to go to win back the fans but it's a start!

    Colin

    It was inevitable that this would be the outcome, although the team played well at times, the results were just not good enough. His refusal to stick rigidly to his preferred system was a sign of a poor coach, also the sacking of Paul Tisdale is great news too, fan power has worked at last.

    Henry

  16. Is O'Neill's phone buzzing?published at 16:58 GMT 5 January

    Amy Canavan
    BBC Sport Scotland

    As calamitous as Wilfried Nancy's reign was in its own right, it was even worse given Martin O'Neill's uplifting interim stint which proceeded it.

    The 73-year-old was brought in to steady the shaking ship Brendan Rodgers hopped off... This vessel has been sinking, though.

    Can, and will, the Northern Irishman save the day - and potentially the club's season - again?

    I'm sure his phone is buzzing...

  17. 'A bit similar to Amorim at Man Utd'published at 16:54 GMT 5 January

    Chris Sutton
    Former Celtic striker on Sky Sports

    It's been a really difficult period for Wilfried Nancy, going in there halfway through a season, losing six of his first eight games. It's a little bit similar to the Ruben Amorim situation at Manchester United but in a shorter period.

    Nancy was fixated on changing Celtic’s style, going to 3-4-3, playing in one particular way. He just wasn't adaptable.

  18. Postpublished at 16:51 GMT 5 January

    One major gripe from fans and pundits alike regarding Wilfried Nancy's short tenure was how he ripped up what was working under Martin O'Neill and tried to implement his 3-4-3 formation and unique tactics without a pre-season.

    Players were shoehorned into unfamiliar roles and he didn't adapt, despite admitting before the Old Firm derby that he would ideally have several weeks to teach his players how to play his system.

    O'Neill won seven of his eight matches; Nancy won two. Losing the League Cup final in his second week in charge didn't exactly help matters.

  19. Nancy's reign in picturespublished at 16:43 GMT 5 January

    Wilfried Nancy applauds Celtic fansImage source, SNS
    Image caption,

    Nancy greeted Celtic Park before his first game in charge against Hearts...

    Wilfried Nancy tactics boardImage source, SNS
    Image caption,

    Which he lost 2-1, despite the use of his much-discussed tactics board

    Wilfried Nancy celebratesImage source, SNS
    Image caption,

    His first win didn't come until his fifth match in charge - a 3-1 win over Aberdeen

    WIlfried Nancy looks dejected after the full-time whistle at Fir ParkImage source, SNS
    Image caption,

    A second win followed at Livingston before his team were outfought and outplayed in a 2-0 defeat by Motherwell

    Danny Rohl embraces Wilfried Nancy at the full-time whistleImage source, SNS
    Image caption,

    Then, the final nail in the coffin, a 3-1 loss against Rangers, after which opposition boss Danny Rohl gave him a hug

  20. Postpublished at 16:38 GMT 5 January

    Russell Martin lasted 123 days, in comparison...