Main content

Believing in reason is childish

John Gray argues that believing in the power of human reason to improve humankind is more 'childish' than believing in religion.

Some critics of religion see having faith as being childish. But John Gray argues that believing that human beings are rational is more childish than believing in religion. The belief in the power of reason to improve humankind rests on childishly simple ideas he says. One of the commonest is that history's crimes are mistakes that can be avoided as we gain greater knowledge. But if history teaches us anything, Grey asserts, it's that behaviours and attitudes like cruelty and hatred are permanent human flaws. To imagine that we can become more rational is an example of magical thinking and an expression of the belief in the omnipotence of the human will that psychoanalysts identify as the fundamental infantile fantasy. John Gray believes that we'd all be better off if we saw ourselves as we are: intermittently and only ever partly rational creatures, who never really grow up.

Available now

10 minutes

A Point of View: The child-like faith in reason

A Point of View: The child-like faith in reason

Belief in human rationality requires a greater leap of faith than any religion, argues John Gray.

Read John Gray’s article on the BBC News website

Credits

RoleContributor
PresenterJohn Gray
ProducerArlene Gregorius

Broadcasts

  • Fri 18 Jul 201420:50
  • Sun 20 Jul 201408:48

Podcast