Main content

10. Toil and Trouble

Neil MacGregor explains how a model ship hung in a church, reveals differences between Scottish and English witches. From 2012.

The differences between Scottish and English witches are revealed by a model ship, made to be hung in a church.

Object-based history series presented by Neil MacGregor, former Director of the British Museum.

Taking artefacts from William Shakespeare's time, he explores how Elizabethan and Jacobean playgoers made sense of the unstable and rapidly changing world in which they lived.

With old certainties shifting around them, in a time of political and religious unrest and economic expansion, Neil asks what the plays would have meant to the public when they were first performed.

He uses carefully selected objects to explore the great issues of the day that preoccupied the public and helped shape the works, and he considers what they can reveal about the concerns and beliefs of Shakespearean England.

Producer: Paul Kobrak

First broadcast on BBC Radio 4 in April 2012.

Available now

15 minutes

Last on

Sat 28 Oct 202303:15

Model of a Bewitched Ship

Date: c.1589, possibly the 1590s

Size: H:650mm, L:645mm

Made in: Denmark

Made by: Unknown

Material: Wood, Paint

Although it may look like a toy, this ship model was actually intended as an offering to God. It was made to give thanks for survival at sea and for delivering the ship’s royal passengers and cargo from the clutches of tempest-brewing witches.

On board the real ship in the spring of 1590, King James VI of Scotland and his new bride, Princess Anne of Denmark, had been at the mercy of the powerful storms in the North Sea. The Danish and Scottish rulers concluded this could only be the work of disturbed spirits conjured by witches and a string of trials and executions followed.

Witches would continue to be associated with James VI, through the vastly popular publication about the trials, News from Scotland, and most famously in Macbeth, the Scottish play that features three ‘black and midnight hags’ at the centre of the action.

This object is from the National Museum Scotland

British Museum Blog: Toil and Trouble by Keith Thomas, Historian

Quotations

But in a sieve, I'll thither sail, And, like a rat without a tail, I'll do, I'll do, and I'll do.'

Macbeth, Act 1 Scene 3

'Double, double toil and trouble;/Fire burn, and cauldron bubble./Cool it with a baboon's blood,/Then the charm is firm and good.'

Macbeth, Act 4 Scene 1

Background

  • This ship model was probably made to celebrate the marriage and safe return to Scotland of James VI and his bride, Anna of Denmark, in 1590
  • Terrible storms had prevented the couple meeting and marrying earlier. The Danish Admiral Munk attributed the storms to the work of Danish witches
  • Six women were tried in Denmark in May 1590 and executed for their alleged part in this plot
  • At least 20 of Shakespeare's plays have overt references to witches or witchcraft, without counting the general references to bewitchment, sorcery or magic
  • James I's interest in witchcraft was well known in England, not least through his book Daemonologie published in 1597 and reprinted in London in 1604

More from Radio 4: The mechanical galleon

More from Radio 4: The mechanical galleon

Neil MacGregor's world history explores the impact of the great age of European discovery between 1450 and 1600. Today he is with a magnificent clockwork galleon.

Listen to the programme

More from Radio 4: Witchcraft

More from Radio 4: Witchcraft

Melvyn Bragg discusses witchcraft in Reformation Europe; misogynism or a sustained attempt by the Christian Church to root out the last of an ancient religion of Europe?

Listen to the programme

Broadcasts

  • Fri 27 Apr 201213:45
  • Fri 27 Apr 201219:45
  • Fri 19 Oct 201214:15
  • Fri 20 Mar 201514:15
  • Sat 21 Mar 201500:15
  • Thu 23 Jun 201613:45
  • Fri 27 Apr 201814:15
  • Sat 28 Apr 201802:15
  • Fri 27 Oct 202307:15
  • Fri 27 Oct 202312:15
  • Fri 27 Oct 202317:15
  • Sat 28 Oct 202303:15

Podcast