Summary

  • Andy Burnham and Kemi Badenoch clash over oil and gas licences, and public finances, at Prime Minister's Questions - recap of the back and forth

  • Badenoch began by asking Burnham if the government would overturn Labour's manifesto commitment not to grant new fossil fuel licences

  • Earlier, the government announced it was approving drilling in the Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea - where a licence was granted in 2022, before being delayed in the courts

  • Accusing Burnham of "dithering" over the decision, the PM says his government fixed what the Conservatives had "messed up"

  • Badenoch also presses Burnham on UK public sector debt, which has passed £3tn, calling on the PM to cut the welfare bill

  • The prime minister cites the IMF, which recently praised the UK's efforts to reduce the deficit, and questions how the Conservatives have the "audacity" to "lecture us about how to do a Budget"

  • The PM also says his government is looking at removing standing charges from gas bills - here's what they are

Media caption,
Watch: Badenoch presses Burnham on borrowing costs
  1. BBC Verify

    How much do standing charges add to gas bills?published at 13:15 BST

    By Tom Edgington

    Although they vary slightly by region and payment method, currently, the average standing charge for gas is just under 30p a day - equivalent to about £108 a year.

    To put that in context, under the current price cap, the dual energy bill for a typical household is currently £1,723 a year.

    However, analysts at energy consultancy Cornwall Insight suggest the price cap could increase 16% on 1 January 2027, largely driven by the Middle East conflict.

    That would lead to a £276 increase for a typical household, according to the consultancy.

    The government temporarily removed VAT from electricity bills on 1 October, saving households £45 a year.

  2. Questions raised over PM's gas standing charge announcementpublished at 13:13 BST

    Kevin Peachey
    Cost of living correspondent

    The prospect raised by the prime minister to “remove” standing charges from gas bills brings up a host of questions.

    As we've explained, standing charges are fixed daily fees covering the costs of connecting to a gas and electricity supply.

    It is likely that these charges would have to be shifted onto the price of each unit of energy.

    That would give households the chance cut bills by using less energy, but some vulnerable households with high energy use could be penalised.

    Regulator Ofgem has run a series of consultations (including a massive public response), and now a pilot, on low and no standing charge tariffs for nearly two years.

    The fact it is drawn no firm conclusion suggests this is a tricky issue to solve.

  3. Burnham made an announcement on gas bill standing charges - what are they?published at 13:03 BST

    An electricity smart metreImage source, EPA/Shutterstock

    During his exchange with Kemi Badenoch, Prime Minister Burnham said he has asked the chancellor and energy secretary to look into removing standing charges from gas bills.

    Standing charges are a daily charge passed onto the customer, even if they use no energy. The fixed cost covers the cost of running the energy network, as well as government levies.

    Currently, the average standing charges are:

    Electricity: 54.8p a day

    Gas: 29.7p a day

    Fuel: 84.5p a day

    The maximum standing charges are set under energy regulator Ofgem's quarterly energy price caps.

  4. A recap: Badenoch's grills the PM on Jackdaw, borrowing and inflationpublished at 12:52 BST

    PMQs has wrapped up for another week, but we'll continue to bring analyses of what was debated. Here's a summary of Andy Burnham and Kemi Badenoch's exchange:

    Jackdaw: Badenoch accused Labour of "dithering" over the decision to approve extraction from the North Sea gas field. Conservatives first approved it in 2022, but it was delayed by legal challenges.

    The PM said the decision strengthened the UK's energy security and it would "support us in a difficult time". He added that he asked the chancellor and energy secretary to look into removing standing charges from gas bills.

    Borrowing: Badenoch said the only solution to reducing debt was to cut spending and borrowing. The PM avoided a question on whether he'll cut the welfare bill, arguing that he's made big decisions that the Conservatives have avoided, like social care.

    Inflation: The Tory leader brought up this morning's inflation figure, which showed a third successive increase. The PM said the situation in the Middle East had contributed to inflation.

  5. Davey heckle an attempt to punch a political bruisepublished at 12:45 BST

    Chris Mason
    Political editor, in the House of Commons

    "Behind you, Ed!" came the instant heckle as the deputy leader of the Liberal Democrats, Daisy Cooper, was called to ask a question.

    Davey has faced some internal grumbling about his leadership recently — and there was an audible attempt by an opponent to punch that political bruise.

  6. Gas would be imported from elsewhere if UK didn't use 'own reserves' - Burnhampublished at 12:41 BST

    Green MP Dr Ellie Chowns asks about the Jackdaw gas field, accusing the government of "pouring more fuel on the fire of climate breakdown".

    The PM says the gas would still be needed, it would just be imported from somewhere else if we didn't use "our own reserves".

    "In these difficult times, when we have resources, I think the public would expect us to use them," he says, adding that the revenue will "enable us to speed up the roll-out of renewables".

  7. UK working 'on every level' to support Ukraine, Burnham says following Starlink questionpublished at 12:38 BST

    Davey now turns to the war in Ukraine and recent reports that Elon Musk directly asked his Starlink system to be slowed down above the country, limiting Kyiv's ability to respond to Russian attacks.

    "Does the prime minister agree that directly supporting Putin is beyond the pale?" Davey asks.

    Burnham says he has concerns about anything that limits Ukraine's military capacity.

    The PM tells Davey the government is working "on every single level" to maintain international support for Ukraine.

    A woman stands by destroyed cars, near an apartment building that was damaged by Russian drone attacks in Kyiv earlier todayImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    A woman stands by destroyed cars, near an apartment building that was damaged by Russian drone attacks in Kyiv earlier today

  8. Lib Dems leader Davey urges Burnham to return UK to single marketpublished at 12:36 BST

    Ed DaveyImage source, UK Parliament

    Following the initial exchanges between Burnham and Badenoch, Liberal Democrat leader Sir Ed Davey is pressing the PM on the UK's relationship with the European Union.

    He says best thing Burnham could do to bring growth is to take the UK back into single market and customs union, adding it would "boost revenues" and would allow the government to "give people tax cuts".

    Burnham responds by pointing to the upcoming UK-EU summit, saying it is a chance to get betters deals for farmers and food producers and he would appreciate the Lib Dems' support on the issue.

    "It is an important step to get growth in the British economy," Burnham says, calling for cross-party support in the House on the issue.

  9. Analysis

    On Jackdaw, Badenoch and Burnham agree on the direction - if not the pacepublished at 12:33 BST

    Chris Mason
    Political editor, in the House of Commons

    "Faff about" and "mess up" were the two punchy quotes that summed up the exchanges between the prime minister and the Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch about the approval of drilling at the Jackdaw gas field.

    For Badenoch, the argument is one grounded in accusing the government of taking too long to come to this decision, with other decisions, not least the Rosebank oil field, still to be taken.

    In other words, as she put it, faffing about.

    For Andy Burnham, he responded that it was the Conservatives who had messed up, as he argued — by approving the licences in question but then finding out they didn’t stand up to legal scrutiny — which led to a delay.

    The intriguing element of this debate today between Badenoch and Burnham is they are on the same side — the difference is about pace rather than direction.

  10. Muttering on the Tory benches as Burnham mentions Liz Trusspublished at 12:30 BST

    Jennifer McKiernan
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    Most Labour MPs are smiling and nodding as Burnham talks up his focus on social care.

    But Conservatives are equally enthusiastically backing their leader as she accused the PM of only talking about, not actually making, changes.

    That is, until Burnham attacks the Liz Truss' mini budget, when many on the Tory back benches cross their arms and start muttering.

  11. Badenoch says Burnham must 'cut spending, cut deficit or cut tax' in next week's Budgetpublished at 12:30 BST

    Kemi Badenoch in Parliament.Image source, UK Parliament

    Badenoch says next week at the Budget, the PM has a choice "he can cut spending, he can cut the deficit, or he can cut tax", adding that there's "no other way".

    She goes on to ask Burnham whether he will follow that plan or "bottle it, just like Keir Starmer did".

    Burnham says there are signs of growing strength in the British economy. He goes on to say that before the Budget next week - on 28 October - there will be a book on the mini-Budget from 2022.

    "Does anybody on this side, or anybody around the country believe that this party [Tories] of all parties has the audacity to come to this house and lecture us about how to do a Budget?"

    British households, he adds, are "still paying the price of that disastrous Budget".

  12. Burnham says Middle East crisis has contributed to rising inflationpublished at 12:25 BST

    Badenoch then accuses the prime minister of talking and not making a decision, noting that inflation figures published today showed a third successive increase.

    • For context: Inflation, the increase in the price of goods over time, has risen from 3.1% in August to 3.5% in the year to September, hitting its highest level for a year.

    Badenoch says families are paying more for bills and asks the prime minister if he accepts his "failure" to control borrowing is contributing to higher inflation.

    Burnham says he had made the difficult decision to end the pension triple lock, allowing for financial support for older people but with "better social care support later in life".

    He adds he doesn't want to see see anybody in their 20s on benefits in the UK, but rather in work and education.

    The prime minister says the situation in the Middle East has contributed to inflation, but adds: "The fundamentals of the British economy are getting stronger and stronger under this government."

    Chart showing inflation rate hitting 3.5% in September
  13. Only solution to reducing debt is to cut spending and borrowing, Badenoch sayspublished at 12:23 BST

    Badenoch says the government is spending more on debt interest than schools, army and the police combined.

    Meanwhile, she says, the PM is worrying about "loud music on trains" - a reference to an announcement this week that passengers who play loud music on buses in England could be fined up to £100.

    The only solution is to cut spending and borrowing, the Conservatives leader claims. "So will the PM get a grip, and cut the welfare bill?" she asks.

    Burnham says he won't apologise for doing "the small things that help people have better lives".

    He says he's also taking on the big decisions that the Conservatives have avoided for years, specifically social care.

  14. Labour MPs shaking heads as Badenoch calls for more drillingpublished at 12:19 BST

    Jennifer McKiernan
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    Labour MPs are shaking their heads as Kemi Badenoch argues for more North Sea oil and gas drilling to boost the economy.

    They get rowdy as Andy Burnham says the IMF has highlighted the UK as having the fastest deficit reduction in the G7.

    They start pointing at the Conservative benches and laughing as Badenoch warns Labour could be out of government at the next election.

  15. Badenoch presses Burnham on government borrowingpublished at 12:18 BST

    Badenoch carries on pushing Burnham about drilling in the North Sea, saying that the world is facing a "global energy crisis" and that there is a "red warning light" flashing on the government's accounts.

    This morning, total government debt hit £3tn, its highest ever - read more on that here. Badenoch asks what the PM is doing to get borrowing down.

    Burnham replies that he is "not sure" that Badenoch has read the International Monetary Fund's report last week which he says concluded that Britain is the "stand out nation" for deficit reduction.

    This Flourish post cannot be displayed in your browser. Please enable Javascript or try a different browser.

  16. Jackdaw decision 'will support us in difficult time' - Burnhampublished at 12:16 BST

    Badenoch asks Burnham whether he accepts that every barrel of North Sea oil the UK produces is a barrel of oil European partners won't buy from Russia.

    In response, the prime minister says the decision strengthens the UK's energy security and it will "support us in a difficult time".

    He says the reason why the previous Tory government "messed up" gas and oil licence decisions is because they are quasi-judicial decisions.

    "The energy secretary considered this decision against our climate obligations and concluded it was consistent. She will oversee the same process in relation to future decisions," he says.

  17. Burnham says he has asked ministers to look into removing standing charges from gas billspublished at 12:13 BST

    Media caption,

    The PM tells the Commons that he has asked his ministers to look into removing standing charges from gas bills

    Burnham responds by saying to the leader of the Conservatives that Labour has made a decision "that her government messed up", saying this is why there was a delay to Jackdaw being approved.

    He accuses the Tories of not carrying out the process "properly", saying his party had made a "pragmatic decision".

    The prime minister adds today's decision will allow the government to do two things: "build a bridge to a renewable future", as well as doing more to help people with bills.

    Burnham finishes his response by saying he has asked the chancellor and energy secretary to looking into removing standing charges from gas bills, adding they will report back.

  18. Badenoch accuses Labour of 'dithering' over Jackdawpublished at 12:10 BST

    Kemi BadenochImage source, UK Parliament

    Leader of the Opposition Kemi Badenoch begins by thanking the PM for approving the Jackdaw gas field, a long-awaited decision which came this morning.

    She accuses the government of "dithering" over the decision. The Conservatives first approved it in 2022, but it was delayed by legal challenges from environmental groups.

    Badenoch asks Burnham whether he'll overturn Labour's ban on new oil and gas licences.

  19. Prime Minister's Questions begins - watch livepublished at 12:02 BST

    Burnham in the CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    Andy Burnham is now on his feet in the Commons for the start of Prime Minister's Questions - his fourth since becoming PM.

    Watch live at the top of this page.

  20. PM arrives in the Commons ahead of PMQspublished at 12:01 BST

    The prime minister has now entered the Commons and taken his seat on the government benches.

    He is set to be grilled shortly by Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch.

    You can watch live at the top of this page, and we'll be providing text updates on all the key points.