Substitutes in rugby 'absolute nonsense' - McBridepublished at 19:40 GMT 16 December 2025
Image source, InphoWillie John McBride won 63 caps for Ireland and a further 17 for the Lions
British and Irish Lions legend Willie John McBride believes reverting to only using the bench to replace injured players would leave rugby as a "far better game".
Ulster hero Mike Gibson was Test rugby's first substitute when he took the place of Barry John for the Lions against South Africa in 1968.
Tactical replacements in the international game were not introduced until 1996, however.
In recent years, led by back-to-back World champions South Africa and their use of the so-called 'Bomb Squad', deployment of the bench is now considered an integral part of the game.
"We didn't have any reserves. If you got injured with Ireland, they put you on the wing because you knew the ball wasn't going to get there," McBride told the Ireland Rugby Social podcast.
"If you could stay on the field you stayed on and if not, you played with 14. So replacements were very important for injury."
McBride has little time for the modern-day approach to rugby as a squad game.
"I'll be quite honest, that's one of the things that annoys me terribly," he added.
"We have changed rugby from a 15-man game into a 23-man game and that drives me crazy. They talk about bomb squads...absolute nonsense.
"I think we should get back to a 15-man game with reserves for injury only and I think we'd have a much better game."
In their most recent Test match, a dominant 73-0 victory over Wales, South Africa named Cobus Reinach as their only back on the bench, bringing on seven forwards across the contest.
Chief amongst McBride's concerns is the fear that bringing on an almost a fresh pack during a game will increase the risk of injury.
"It's just not fair," he said. "The chances of injury are so much more because you've fresh men against tired men.
"These guys that they rush on at the end are 25 stone probably, huge guys who couldn't play 80 minutes of rugby.
"That's unfair for a start. The whole game is wrong the way they've done this."
Willie John McBride: The ultimate Lion

























