On Radio 3 Now

In Tune

16:30 - 17:30

Sean Rafferty presents a selection of music and guests from the arts world.

Architecture on 3
Best Loved Buildings
Reviews
Portcullis House
Name:
David Howells
Building:
Portcullis House
Location:
Westminster, London
What is your relationship to this building?:
Passer-by
Why do you love this building?:
My first response when it was under construction was one of outrage! However, I have grown to love the building.

It has a foreboding, serious, strong personality. It's constructed of brick, concrete and metal cladding.

It seems to have been designed to make a positive statement at such an important site next to Big Ben. The scale is right, though, it doesn't detract or try to compete with the Houses of Parliament. I cannot comment on the interior functionality - but the underground station beneath it works well.

Speaking to a few people, many like me, have grown to admire it.


Name:
Gareth Wilson
Your comments on this building: Initially I hated the building - I thought that it was a white elephant, completely out of place beside parliament. However, once I got used to it, I thought that it fitted in well.

Unfortunately I would not put it amongst the best buildings in the UK. The Swiss Re building is one of the best in London - amazing!

Name:
Andrew McDuffie
Your comments on this building: My feelings are kind of an inversion of the comments that have gone before. At first sight I was rather amazed by this structure but lately all I can see are the rather prosaic bits of it - of which there seem to be many. Agree about the Swiss Re building though - wonderful; check Fosters' website for details of the new project that's mooted for the seafront in my home town of Hastings; it's rather fab!

Name:
Edward Lyons
Your comments on this building: Would any corporate client have paid money for this ghastly building? It's stolid awfulness is puzzling, though: a cluttered brown grid with industrially turreted roofline seems anything but modish. Neither ingratiating nor brutalist, it cost us a packet but seems to settle for a worthy functionality - custom-built for a down-at-heel MP, perhaps.
Add your own comments to this review

Your name:


Email address: This will be kept confidential and only used if we need to contact you.


Your comment:




Disclaimer: The BBC will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published. The BBC reserves the right to edit comments that are published
Write a review of your best loved building in Britain
We want to find out what qualities make buildings truly loved, rather than simply admired from a distance, so tell us about a building that you know really well – preferably inside out!

Submit Your Building
Listen Again
Listen to...Night Waves Debate: "This house believes that Prince Charles has been good for architecture"
(Broadcast 28/06/04)


Listen to...Night Waves Debate: The Value of Architecture (Broadcast 12/06/03)
Architecture Walks
submit your walk
find a walk
recommended walk
night waves walks

Best Loved Buildings
best loved buildings gallery
submit your building

Programme Archive
Browse the programme archive for interviews and features on architecture

Rising Stars
Night Waves profiles the potential Architectural talent of the future.
Elsewhere on BBCi
Visit our BBC Architecture links page to find other sites of architectural interest on BBCi
Elsewhere on the Web
Visit our 'Architecture on the Web'links page to find other sites of architectural interest on the internet


BBC © 2014The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.