BBC - Ouch! (disability) - Fact - Reviewing the BBnav

Home > Fact > Reviewing the BBnav

Reviewing the BBnav

by Tim Rushby-Smith

15th February 2009

Every disabled driver carries with them a wealth of motoring horror stories. From the one where they drove around endlessly for an hour before returning home unable to find a disabled parking bay, to the incident with the fizzy drinks bottle when they were in an unfamiliar place and every service station for miles around was lacking an accessible loo.

It's no surprise then that an enterprising company has attempted to solve such difficulties with a new in-car product.

BBnav is a satellite navigation system, which in addition to the usual map information claims to know about Blue Badge bays, disability-friendly points of interest, and the position of the nearest accessible toilet. We asked disabled driver and Ouch! columnist Tim Rushby-Smith to put it through its paces.
Tim driving in his car
While I am a frequent driver, I do not own, nor ever have I used a satnav, so when asked to review BBnav, I had no idea what to expect. Immediately, I was impressed by its simplicity, consisting of a single on/off button and a touch sensitive screen. My first action with the BBnav was to go to the quick start option and set a destination. Of course, I didn't look at the instructions, because I am a man. Fumbling about, it wasn't long before I had the destination postcode programmed. This could be quite difficult for a person with limited dexterity, as some of the 'buttons' are on the small side. There is a 'wand' for use with the screen, but getting it out of the slot at the back of the device may be even more of a challenge.

I hit the go button, but it was a good five minutes before a little car appeared on screen in a multi-coloured map, showing my current position.
Picture of the BBnav system
My first adventure with the device took me to the Camden area of London. The disabled folk in Camden are special. Not only do they have a normal Blue Badge - a nationwide phenomenon, which when displayed on a disabled person's car allows us to park in designated accessible parking bays - but they also have a 'green' blue badge. Most of the disabled bays in the centre of London require an additional differently-coloured badge only available to you if you live, work or study in that area.

Unfortunately, the BBnav didn’t seem to know this, so I found myself driving past a dozen empty Green Badge disabled bays flagged up on the gadget's map as blue, before I saw one I could use without getting a ticket. BBnav also doesn't inform the Blue Badge user that they get an extra hour on meters and pay & display bays in Camden. Someone travelling into London for a visit wouldn't necessarily know that there are different parking restrictions for Blue Badge holders in different boroughs, so that's where this particular product should come into its own. By studying the key which comes with the device, users should be able to recognise various parking restrictions by a change in background colour on BBnav’s map. Navevo, the product’s developers, will be amending the Camden info in time for their next update, downloadable from their website in the very near future.
Tim in his car
On the next outing, I took the BBnav for a drive all the way across London so that I could play wheelchair tennis. I was asked whether I wanted to travel inside the congestion zone or not - a useful option for someone visiting London because, although disabled drivers are exempt, the vehicle has to be registered in advance with Transport for London.

I also tried to use the device to find disability-friendly points of interest and information on accessible public toilets and car parks during my journey. It takes practice to navigate the complex menu system to find this stuff, and while it is possible to search for POIs when you get to an area, BBnav tends to assume that you will plan every aspect of your trip in advance on the machine, rather than looking for access information while on the road. Symbols for toilets, car parks and points of interest flash up as various icons on the gadget’s map, rather than being read out loud by a voice. It does make planning a trip more straightforward than using the internet, but isn't ideal if you suddenly need to stop for a coffee or to use the bathroom.

On my journey across London, I had to make an executive decision on several occasions, as the BBnav's map was indicating one route while the voice was telling me something entirely different. No matter how many times the voice implored me, I was never going to drive off the side of the Westway flyover to land on Edgware Road forty feet below. Apparently, the device thought I was travelling on the road below the flyover - a mistake which could have been made by any other regular satnav.

When I got to Hammersmith, I followed the instructions a little too literally, getting into the right-hand lane to turn right off the roundabout, only to find myself in the bus depot, where I was tooted and scowled at from all directions by irate bus drivers.

Despite our disagreements over the route, the BBnav did warn me about upcoming speed cameras, a service which users can subscribe to for a fee, with updates regularly downloaded online.

This made me wonder why the additional, disability related information on the BBnav couldn't be offered as a subscription download to all satnav devices. The manufacturers believe that this would be unlikely due to the cost of the licence to use the databases containing all the disability related information. The databases used on BBnav are owned by PIE, the Public Information Exchange, who sold Navevo the rights to use them and who make available an online and printed version of the Blue Badge guide used on the device.

BBnav holds access information for 150 UK cities, which are listed on their website. More are being surveyed all the time by PIE and will be downloadable from the product’s website as soon as they become available. Navevo say that we are very lucky to have a database containing access information for so much of Britain. They would love to develop a similar device for other countries, but the relevant information on disabled parking, accessible toilets and disability-friendly points of interest just hasn’t been pulled together. The big satnav companies make their products with a global market in mind, so it would be a mammoth task to assemble this information for every country they serve.

On balance, BBnav is a useful tool for disabled drivers who travel regularly to unfamiliar places. At £195, as with many disability-related products, the limited numbers involved means that the cost is higher than the equivalent mass market satnav. Hopefully, the success of the device will make other manufacturers start to consider the market potential of the 2.6 million Blue Badge holders in the UK.

Comments

    • 1. At 5:04pm on 18 Feb 2009, Baz wrote:

      The most important fact is the price that price to me is utterly to dear, but at least this is the first one on the market to try and make our life a bit more better, does it show petrol stations that use service call?

      Complain about this comment

    • 2. At 08:01am on 17 Apr 2009, Sidbtm wrote:

      Tim seems to suggest that £ 199 is resonable given that things for disabled people are made in such small numbers. Normally I would agree, even if I don't like it. But here we have an example of an expensive GPS device where other examples can now be found on sale for less than £60. The special bit being the "Points of interest" (POI) specifically for finding disabled things ! This bit ie POI is a simple data file, which is dirt cheap to compile and easy to load into a GPS. For example if you are in the Caravan Club they give you FOC a POI file with all their caravan sites on. All we need is someone to gather the data and put it into a data file. Then all of us could get to find Blue Badge bays with no cost !

      Complain about this comment

    • 3. At 10:08am on 12 Jun 2009, muteangel wrote:

      I bought this satnav. The touch screen was faulty so I returned it about 6 weeks ago. However, it was still useable when I had it. It was rubbish compared to the Tomtom I have since bought at half the price. The BB satnav was slow and unreliable. To make matters worse, I still haven't received a refund for the returned machine. DO NOT BUY THIS. Blue Badge bays are always changing anyway.

      Complain about this comment

    • 4. At 10:12am on 12 Jun 2009, muteangel wrote:

      the BB Satnav is rubbish. The one I bought was faulty, so returned it about 6 weeks ago. However, the few days I used it, it was slow and unreliable and twice the price of the Tomtom I have since bought. To cap it all, I still haven't got my money back from PI Enterprises.

      Complain about this comment

      View these comments in RSS

      Bookmark with...

      What are these?

      Live community panel

      Our blog is the main place to go for all things Ouch! Find info, comment, articles and great disability content on the web via us.

      Mat and Liz
      Listen to our regular razor sharp talk show online, or subscribe to it as a podcast. Spread the word: it's where disability and reality almost collide.

      More from the BBC

      BBC Sport

      Disability Sport

      All the latest news from the paralympics.

      Peter White

      In Touch

      News and views for people who are blind or partially sighted.

      BBC Radio 4

      You & Yours

      Weekdays 12.40pm. Radio 4's consumer affairs programme.

      BBC © 2014The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

      This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.