Summary

  • Keir Starmer and Kemi Badenoch have clashed at PMQs over government policy changes on mandatory digital IDs and farmland inheritance tax

  • Badenoch welcomes the "latest U-turn" after the government dropped plans requiring workers to sign up to its digital ID scheme in order to prove their right to work in the UK - she says the plan was "rubbish"

  • Starmer says he is determined to make it harder for people to work illegally, and insists there will be mandatory ID checks

  • Badenoch runs through a series of policies she says Starmer "didn't get right first time", and points to the government's watering down of plans to apply inheritance tax to farms

  • Starmer defends the principle of the policy as the "right one", but says ministers listened to concerns and so changed the threshold it will be paid from £1m to £2.5m

  • The PM criticises social media site X over concerns its AI tool is being used to create sexualised images - he says he was told today it's "acting to ensure full compliance with UK law", adding: "We're not going to back down"

Media caption,

Kemi Badenoch challenges Keir Starmer on U-turns

  1. Starmer and Badenoch clash over 'U-turns' at PMQspublished at 14:12 GMT 14 January

    This image is split into two images with a white dividing line down the middle. Kemi Badenoch is on the right wearing a blue jacket and speaking into a microphone in the House of Commons. Keir Starmer is on the left wearing a dark blue suit and navy tie and addressing the House of CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    The prime minister went into PMQs having dropped plans to require workers to have digital IDs, which Badenoch welcomed as the "latest U-turn", describing the policy as "rubbish".

    Despite the change, Starmer insisted he is "determined to make it harder for people to work illegally", and insisted "there will be checks, they will be digital, and they will be mandatory".

    But Badenoch expanded on what she characterised as a wider theme, pointing to a list of times the government has changed policy, including on watering down changes to inheritance tax on farmland and winter fuel payments, and scrapping the two-child benefit cap.

    Starmer defended his government's record, and hit out at the Tories' own. He said the economy is "turning a corner" under his leadership, adding "nobody is ever going to listen to [the Conservatives] on the economy ever again".

    We're bringing our live coverage to an end now - we'll be back next week. You can read more on today's PMQs and the issues raised here:

  2. Explainer: Starmer's row with X over AI imagespublished at 13:42 GMT 14 January

    Phone screen displaying Grok tab openImage source, FAZRY ISMAIL/EPA/Shutterstock

    As we've been reporting, Starmer repeated threats to act against social media site X at PMQs earlier, following widespread concerns its AI tool Grok is being used to create sexualised images.

    On Monday, the UK's communications watchdog, Ofcom, announced it would be launching an investigation, saying there have been "deeply concerning reports" of the chatbot being used to create and share undressed images of people, as well as "sexualised images of children".

    Starmer said earlier this week that X could lose the "right to self regulate", promising to act quickly on addressing the issue.

    Labour backbencher Emily Darlington raised the issue at PMQs today, prompting Starmer to call X's actions "disgusting and shameful".

    He said he had been informed this morning that X is acting to "ensure full compliance with UK law", which he welcomed, before adding the government will "not back down" and could yet take further measures.

    The BBC has approached X for comment. It previously said: "Anyone using or prompting Grok to make illegal content will suffer the same consequences as if they upload illegal content."

    Read more here.

  3. Home secretary to make statement on West Midlands Police later, says Starmerpublished at 13:02 GMT 14 January

    A few minutes ago we heard Conservative MP Nick Timothy raise controversy around the chief of West Midlands Police Craig Guildford, who earlier today admitted to misleading MPs.

    He admitted AI had been used in an assessment which led to Maccabi Tel Aviv fans being banned from attending Aston Villa's stadium in November, a decision which has been strongly criticised by MPs of all parties.

    Timothy says West Midlands Police "fabricated intelligence", and goes on to accuse police forces more broadly of bowing to pressure from "Islamists". He calls for an investigation into "the corruption of our criminal justice system".

    Starmer repeats his criticism of the West Midland Police over the Maccabi Tel Aviv decision, and says Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood will be making a statement on the matter later today.

    Starmer points out that the ability of the government to sack chief constables was stripped under Theresa May's police reforms, adding: "It was him [Timothy] working for Theresa May that stripped that power away."

    If you want to read more about the West Midlands Police row, you can follow our coverage here.

  4. U-turns and water shortages - the key moments from today's PMQspublished at 12:49 GMT 14 January

    • Badenoch's attacks on Starmer centred around what she called "the prime-minister's latest U-turn" on digital ID cards, which she said was a "rubbish policy"
    • She also asked Starmer to apologise to farmers over plans to apply inheritance tax to farmland, which were watered down late last year after protests from the agriculture industry
    • Badenoch also claimed Labour's budget has doubled business rates for thousands of pubs
    • Starmer said 7,000 pubs closed when her party was in power, and that the economy is "turning a corner" on the government's watch
    • Lib Dem leader Ed Davey asked whether the government would "immediately" strip South East Water of its licence over widespread shortages for customers this week. The prime minister gave no such commitment but said the situation was unacceptable
    • We also heard questions about plans to deploy British troops in Ukraine in the event of a peace deal, concerns over the Grok AI tool and criticism of the chief constable of West Midland Police over the decision to block Maccabi Tel Aviv fans from attending Villa Park in November
  5. Starmer attacks Reform from the despatch boxpublished at 12:39 GMT 14 January

    Brian Wheeler
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    In response to a question about Ukraine, Starmer describes Nigel Farage as a "Putin apologist".

    Will the Speaker give Reform - which is not guaranteed a question at PMQs - a right to reply?

    Unlike last week, Farage is in the chamber this afternoon, but he is leaving it to his deputy Richard Tice to try and attract the Speaker’s attention.

  6. 'Shameful': Starmer threatens more action against X and Grokpublished at 12:37 GMT 14 January

    Media caption,

    Watch: “X is acting to ensure full compliance with UK law”

    From the backbenches, Labour MP Emily Darlington references this week's criticism of the Grok AI tool, which was developed by Elon Musk's X and faces an investigation over concerns it can be used to create sexualised and abusive images.

    Starmer says the actions of X and Grok are "disgusting and shameful".

    He says he's been informed this morning that X is acting to "ensure full compliance with UK law", which he says is welcome, before adding the government will "not back down" and could yet take further measures.

  7. Davey calls for South East Water to be stripped of its licencepublished at 12:32 GMT 14 January

    Davey then turns to issues with South East Water, which have seen thousands of people in Tunbridge Wells, East Grinstead and in parts of Kent and Sussex left without water since Saturday.

    South East Water keeps failing its customers, Davey says, before asking if the government will strip the firm of its licence?

    Starmer describes the situation as unacceptable and says ministers have held daily meetings to hold South East Water to account, adding that the company must invest in infrastructure to prevent further shortages.

  8. Lib Dem leader Ed Davey questions the PMpublished at 12:29 GMT 14 January

    Ed DaveyImage source, House of Commons

    We are now on to the questions from Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey, who asks the prime minister to end waits of more than 12 hours for admission to hospital from A&E.

    Starmer points to Davey's voting record and criticises him for not voting for Labour policies that he says would put more money into the NHS.

  9. Jokes and U-turn attacks in Starmer-Badenoch clashpublished at 12:29 GMT 14 January

    Brian Wheeler
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    Labour’s joke writers have been working overtime in an effort to deflect Tory attacks.

    Starmer has dubbed the Tories the "Ikea shadow cabinet" and says they held “more positions than the Kama Sutra” when in government.

    But Badenoch landed some blows with her attack on the prime minister's U-turns.

    Her own side certainly seem to enjoy some discomfort on the Labour benches.

  10. Starmer says UK is 'turning a corner' as Badenoch presses on U-turnspublished at 12:26 GMT 14 January

    Badenoch leads Tory MPs in unison as she lists what she describes as a series of U-turns from the government, including on winter fuel payments and changes to the two-child benefit cap.

    The Tory leader references an unnamed minister quoted in a newspaper saying it would be "worth rolling the dice" on a new leader to boost the government's popularity.

    Starmer ends by pointing to what he says is the government's progress on the economy, saying "inflation is down, wages are up", and repeating his line from last week that the "country is turning a corner".

    And that's that from Badenoch. We'll be hearing from other parties now.

  11. More back and forth on U-turns and the economypublished at 12:22 GMT 14 January

    Badenoch continues on the theme of U-turns and says the government has "no sense of direction".

    She points to Conservative proposals to abolish business rates for small businesses on the high street and asks if Labour will do the same.

    Starmer responds by saying the Conservatives crashed the economy and "nobody is ever going to listen to them on the economy ever again".

  12. Starmer raises high-profile Tory defection to Reformpublished at 12:20 GMT 14 January

    StarmerImage source, House of Commons

    Badenoch returns to pubs and asks if the prime minister understood what the impact of his policy would be on the industry.

    Starmer repeats that the government is "working with the sector" and that other supportive measures were included in the Budget, adding: "What did they do? Opposed it."

    The prime minister says it's "no wonder" Nadhim Zahawi has defected to Reform UK, describing the steady stream of ex-MPs switching allegiance as a "second Boris wave".

  13. Badenoch moves on to problems in the pub industrypublished at 12:18 GMT 14 January

    Badenoch says Starmer's budget doubled business rates for thousands of pubs and asks for a change of course to prevent more from closing.

    Again, Starmer points to the Tory record in government, and claims 7,000 pubs closed when the party was in power.

    He says they are working with the sector to ensure they get support they need.

  14. Lots of cheers for Badenoch from Tory benchespublished at 12:16 GMT 14 January

    Brian Wheeler
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    BadenochImage source, House of Commons

    There are signs of Badenoch’s growing confidence at PMQs.

    A big cheer from her own side - and a broad grin - as she tells Starmer: “The prime minister doesn’t need to worry about me.”

  15. Badenoch turns to farmland inheritance taxpublished at 12:16 GMT 14 January

    Badenoch turns to the government's changes on plans to apply inheritance tax to farmland, a proposal the government watered down late last year when Parliament wasn't sitting after protests.

    She asks the prime minister to apologise to farmers for the "misery" the proposal caused.

    Starmer defends the government's action and says that the principle the government put in place on inheritance tax was the "right one", but that ministers have listened to concerns by changing the threshold it will be paid at from £1m to £2.5m.

  16. 'More positions than the Kama Sutra'published at 12:13 GMT 14 January

    Media caption,

    Watch: ‘They’ve had more positions in 14 years than the Kama Sutra’

    On ID cards, Starmer says he is determined to make it harder for people to illegally work in the UK.

    He says the government is making the "right choices" for Britain, including investing in the NHS.

    Starmer accuses Badenoch of hypocrisy by attack U-turns, saying the Tories had five prime ministers during their time in government and "more positions in 14 years than the Kama Sutra".

  17. Streeting shaking his head on the front benchpublished at 12:11 GMT 14 January

    Brian Wheeler
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    StreetingImage source, House of Commons

    Health Secretary Wes Streeting is shaking his head and saying “I didn't say that” as Badenoch repeats his call for the government to “get it right first time”.

    To be fair to Streeting, he did not mention the prime minister by name in his speech yesterday - even if it was widely interpreted as a dig at Starmer.

  18. Badenoch begins with question on ID U-turnpublished at 12:11 GMT 14 January

    BadenochImage source, House of Commons

    Kemi Badenoch begins by saying she welcomes "the prime minister's latest U-turn", calling digital ID cards a "rubbish policy".

    She then references comments made yesterday by the health secretary, who said ministers need to get things "right the first time".

    Badenoch asks: "Does the prime minister agree?"

  19. An early dig from Starmerpublished at 12:06 GMT 14 January

    Brian Wheeler
    Reporting from the House of Commons

    That was a bit naughty from the prime minister.

    He got in a political attack on the Tories’ record in government on investing in towns and cities in his opening remarks.

    MPs opposite were not happy.

  20. Starmer condemns 'sickening' scenes in Iranpublished at 12:06 GMT 14 January

    Before PMQs kicks off, the prime minister starts by condemning the "sickening murder" of protesters in Iran.

    He says the UK is "working with allies on further sanctions".

    Starmer also references today's transport announcement, which he says will create "a major new rail network across the north" and bring "renewal" to the region.