BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014
GloucestershireGloucestershire

BBC Homepage
»BBC Local
Gloucestershire
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Gloucestershire

Bristol
Coventry
South East Wales
Hereford & Worcs
Oxford
Wiltshire

Related BBC Sites

England

Contact Us

Dil Ne Jise Apna Kahaa
15Dil Ne Jise Apna Kahaa (2004)

updated 03 September 2004
reviewer's rating
1 out of 5
Reviewed by Jamie Russell
average user rating
3 Star


Director
Atul Agnihotri
Writer
Atul Agnihotri
Stars
Salman Khan
Bhumika Chawla
Preity Zinta
Helen Khan
Rati Agnihotri
Length
143 minutes
Distributor
Eros Entertainment
Cinema
10 September 2004
Country
India
Genre
Bollywood
Drama
Romance

Rate This Film
What did you think of this film?
Select your star rating from the options below

Star Rating: 1  1
Star Rating: 2  2
Star Rating: 3  3
Star Rating: 4  4
Star Rating: 5  5
Average star rating: 3 from 272 votes

Bollywood heads into the ER ward in Dil Ne Jise Apna Kahaa, an unlikely blend of Hindi melodrama, surgical gowns and heart transplants. It's the wearisome tale of a young Indian couple - ad agency copywriter Rishabh (Salman Khan) and his doctor wife Pari (Preity Zinta) - whose happily ever after lives are ripped apart after a motorway pile-up leaves Rishabh a widower. But what Rishabh doesn't know is that his late wife's heart has been donated to Dhani (Bhumika Chawla), a woman who's about to fall head over heels in love with him.

Bollywood has always been fascinated by grand emotions, but it's hardly suited to coping with the tragic outcome of this storyline's trajectory: muscular hero Khan simply weeps and wails and generally mopes around with a dopey expression on his face for a couple of hours.

"A MOVIE LACKING HEART, SOUL AND A BRAIN"

In other hands, this slightly spooky set-up might have made a half decent horror picture. Debut writer-director Atul Agnihotri turns it into nothing more than Bollywood business as usual, as the bereavement and love are spiced up with the odd song and dance number, an embarrassing gay stereotype, and some risible philosophising about the nature of love: "The doors to the heart don't open and shut when they want to." Genius.

Skimping on the genre's usual glitz and glam - this is a bereavement drama after all - Dil Ne Jise Apna Kahaa crawls towards its blindingly obvious conclusion with all the enthusiasm of a flatlining patient. Aside from the rather surprising attempt to blend Christian faith with ideas about the reincarnation of souls, there's nothing here to disprove accusations that Bollywood's increasingly stale output is in desperate need of rejuvenation. This is a movie that's already undergone a triple bypass operation, since it's lacking a heart, a soul, and a brain.

In Hindi with English subtitles.

Find out more about "Dil Ne Jise Apna Kahaa" at
Movie Review Query Engine
The Internet Movie Database


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites


music
bullet
Latest news & reviews
bullet
Comedy nights
bullet
Festivals guide
bullet
On stage in Cheltenham
bullet
On stage in Gloucester
bullet
On stage in Stroud
bullet
On stage in Tewkesbury
bullet
On stage in the Cotswolds
bullet
On stage in the Forest
bullet
Get YOUR event listed
bullet
FREE nights out on us!
bullet
News & reviews
bullet
Latest releases
bullet
County cinema listings
bullet
Gloucs in the movies
bullet
The Harry Potter file
bullet
Tolkien's Forest
bullet
The Review Archive
bullet
News & reviews
bullet
Gig guide
bullet
Venues
bullet
Local talent: get listed!
bullet
News & reviews
bullet
Club nights
bullet
Venues
bullet
Tourist attractions
bullet
Ghostly Gloucestershire
bullet
Royal Gloucestershire
bullet
Gardens to visit
CONTACT US

BBC Gloucestershire
London Road
Gloucester
GL1 1SW

Telephone (website only):
+44 (0)1452 308585

e-mail:
gloucestershire@bbc.co.uk





About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy