BBC News, coverage of the political implications following the newly released Epstein files, February 2026

Summary of complaint

We received complaints from people who felt our coverage of the political implications of the Mandelson scandal was biased against the prime minister.


Our response

The political fallout from the Mandelson scandal was a fast-developing story, which we followed closely, scrutinising the potential consequences.  We included the response from Sir Keir Starmer and statements from Downing Street throughout our coverage.

There were questions raised over the prime minister’s judgement in relation to his decision to appoint Lord Mandelson to the post of US ambassador, and the vetting procedure that had been undertaken.  This led to calls, not just from his political opponents, but also some Labour MPs, two Labour affiliated unions and notably the leader of Labour in Scotland, Anas Sarwar, for the prime minister to resign.  Three senior Downing Street officials left their roles within the space of a week.  In this context, it was fair that we reflected the difficult situation facing the prime minister, and that he had already been politically vulnerable.

It was relevant for us to detail attitudes within the Parliamentary Labour Party, (PLP), towards Sir Keir. While only a few Labour MPs had publicly called for the prime minister to resign, there were many more who had been privately critical.  Cabinet Minister Ed Miliband had openly spoken about the Labour Party having looked “over the precipice”.  Our political correspondents and editors spoke to Labour MPs off the record to inform their analysis; they were transparent with our audience about where they got their information, which included signposting when sources wished to remain anonymous.  

Following the meeting of the PLP, which was seen as a crunch point for the prime minister, we heard from many Labour voices supportive of him, with our analysis reflecting that Sir Keir appeared to be safe in his role for now, having received the public backing of all cabinet members.

We believe our coverage of the political implications of this story has been proportionate and duly impartial, reflecting the significant issues highlighted.  With the police now investigating allegations against Lord Mandelson of misconduct in public office, this is an ongoing story, which we will continue to report on appropriately.