Diamond Geezers, Guilty Pleasures
Do you still make up lists of your favourite records? Man, that’s so last century. These days, the done thing is to reel of a sequence of those guilty pleasures - the horrid little tunes that were never invited to the cool party. So now it’s permissible to like the Electric Light Orchestra and their symphonic twaddle. Likewise with Meatloaf and ‘Bat Out Of Hell’. Apparently it’s been given a reprieve, after years of mockery. And you thought it was just a gormless bunch of shouting and half-remembered Springsteen choruses? Apparently not.
To my mind, guilty pleasures should never be given absolution. A bad song will always stink. All this ironic stuff is just another makeshift, a temporary plug to fill the vacancy in our current music lives. I can never forgive Abba for their pop crimes, and if anyone ever wants to make a case for Nik Kershaw in my presence, be warned that I consider this fighting talk.
Yes, I do have an emotional attachment to some dodgy tunes. All that’s left of one doomed love affair is the Genesis song, ‘Follow You Follow Me’. But it would never have worked: she had a lousy record collection. I used to like Alvin Stardust, but I was 11 at the time. And yes, I will dance with abandon to Fleetwood Mac and ‘Everywhere’. But that was never a bad song to start with.
The song that troubles me most is ‘Cracklin’ Rosie’ by Neil Diamond. I find myself singing it in public. The melody gives me some pleasure. And when Shane MacGowan recorded a stumblebum version with banjos and everything, I truly appreciated how bold the song was.
But there’s a line in ‘Crackin’ Rosie’ that troubles me a lot. It’s when Neil boasts, “I had me a time with a poor man’s lady”. I find it morally appalling. Why didn’t he pick himself a rich man’s wife for his entertainment? Or maybe even a single girl? I still have an indelible picture of the poor man, coming home in his dirty overalls, only to realise that his missus is cavorting with Neil Diamond, his clanking medallion and a purple jump suit. It’s just not right.
Am I being too judgmental? Should I forget my guilty feelings and simply enjoy a decent pop song? Kind readers, how should I plead?

A bloke comes up to me the other week and tells me he’s cracked the secret of my radio show. I’m intrigued. There’s me on a Friday night, working alone in BBC Belfast’s Studio 8 of a Friday, from ten until midnight, playing my fave tunes in a kind of random order. Hey, I care about the records and that’s reason enough for me. But this guy understands. “It’s all about passion,” he declares, with a tremendous smile. And you know, he might be correct.