Effectiveness of custodial and non-custodial responses to crime The Scottish Prison Service (SPS)

There are different types of courts in Scotland. Young people are treated differently from adults within the Scottish criminal justice system. The Scottish government are looking to reduce the number of people going to prison.

Part ofModern StudiesCrime and law

The Scottish Prison Service (SPS)

The Scottish Prisons Service (SPS) has several aims, including holding those serving a prison sentence securely in custody as well as looking to support offenders so they don’t re-offend on release.

Scottish Prison Service aims:

  • to protect the public by maintaining secure custody
  • to humanely care for offenders
  • to reduce re-offending
  • to offer value for money for the taxpayer

Examples of Scottish prisons

HMYOI Polmont
Figure caption,
HMYOI Polmont

There are 15 prisons in Scotland, but they do not all serve the same purpose:

  • Prisons such as HMP Perth hold a mix of long and short-term adult male offenders, from those serving life sentences to those on remand - held waiting for trial
  • HMYOI Polmont is a young offenders institute, for offenders aged 16 to 21 years
  • There are YOIs at HMP Grampian, HMP Perth and HMP YOI Stirling.
  • HMP YOI Stirling is Scotland’s only women’s only prison although there are also Community Custody units located in Glasgow and Dundee.
  • There are smaller units for women prisoners at Edinburgh, Greenock and Grampian
  • HMP Castle Huntly is Scotland’s only 'open prison' where low risk, long-term offenders complete the final part of their sentence
  • Two prisons, HMP Kilmarnock and Scotland’s newest prison HMP Addiewell, are privately operated. HMP Kilmarnock will return to public sector in 2024.

How has Scottish prison life changed?

The exercise yard, HMP Edinburgh, 1980s
Figure caption,
The exercise yard, HMP Edinburgh, 1980s

Historically, prisons were places where extreme forms of punishment were prevalent. Today's prisons are still very strict environments. Offenders have little privacy and no freedom. There are many restrictions on their lives.

However, today's prisons focus more on education and rehabilitation. Modern prisons allow outside visitors and encourage offenders to educate themselves. For example, there are creative writing classes and writers can come in to help offenders to develop their talents.

The hope is that, upon release, offenders will have the knowledge and skills to enable them to find work outside and therefore increase the chances of them not re-offending.