Open response questions
Extended open response questions require longer answers than structured questions that have fewer marks. Open response questions are usually worth six marks, but some are worth fewer marks.
It is wise to plan your answer first by making some notes. This will help you to include all the key points.
To gain full marks, you need to:
- support explanations using scientific knowledge and understanding
- use appropriate scientific words
- write clearly and link ideas in a logical way
- maintain a sustained line of reasoning
Open response questions often use these command words:
- Describe means you should recall facts, events or processes accurately. You might need to give an account of what something looked like, or what happened.
- Explain means you need to make something clear, or state the reasons for something happening.
- Compare means you need to describe similarities and differences between things. If you are asked to compare X and Y, write down something about X and something about Y, then give a comparison. Do not just write about X only or Y only.
- Evaluate means you must use information supplied, or your own knowledge, to consider the evidence for and against or to identify strengths and weaknesses. You must then complete your answer with a conclusion, stating which is better and why, for example.
Open response questions may be synoptic questions, which bring together ideas from two or more topics. For example, a question about fertilisers could include ideas about covalent substances, acids and alkalis, chemical calculations and effects on the environment.
The answers shown here give marking points as bullet points. You do not usually need to include all of them to gain full marks, but you do need to write in sentences, linking them logically and clearly.
This page contains AQA material which is reproduced by permission of AQA.
Sample question 1 - Foundation
Question
The graph shows how the concentration of carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere changed between 1900 and 2000.
Explain how the changes shown in the graph can have harmful effects on the environment. [4 marks]
Indicative content
Consequence of rise in carbon dioxide levels:
- carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas
- it stops infrared radiation escaping from the Earth
- warming up the atmosphere
- rise in level warms atmosphere up more
- so leads to global warming
- leading to climate change
Effects on environment:
- extreme weather fluctuations
- rise in sea levels
- effects on human habitats
- effects on animal habitats
- decrease in biodiversity
- effects on food producing capacity
Sample question 2 - Foundation
Question
All life on Earth depends on water.
Explain how the water molecules in an iceberg could end up as water in a lake. [4 marks]
Indicative content
- Water in the iceberg is in its solid state.
- When the iceberg melts water is in its liquid form.
- The water molecules go into the sea.
- Water evaporates from the surface of the sea.
- The water molecules go into the air as vapour.
- As the air rises it cools.
- Water vapour condenses into droplets in clouds.
- Clouds can be moved around the world by winds.
- Droplets then fall as rain / snow / hail /precipitation into a lake.
Sample question 3 - Higher
Question
In the last 200 years the concentration of carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere has risen.
Explain how a rise in carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere can decrease biodiversity. [6 marks]
Indicative content
- Rise in carbon dioxide increases atmospheric temperature / causes global warming.
- Global warming causes extreme weather patterns.
- Such as rise in sea levels.
- Increased or decreased rainfall.
- Frequency of storms / droughts.
- Rise in sea levels means habitats will change due to flooding.
- Rise in sea levels could increase salt in soil.
- Severity of storms/droughts could affect photosynthesis.
- Consequences of changes are loss of or damage to habitats.
- Which will affect animal and plant distributions.
- By increasing migration or species dying off.
- Which decreases biodiversity.
Sample question 4 - Higher
Question
Ivy plants can grow up trees and walls.
The figure below shows two ivy leaves. One leaf is from an ivy plant growing up a tree in the centre of a shady woodland area. The other leaf is from an ivy plant growing up a tree in a sunny area at the edge of the woodland.
The student makes the following hypothesis:
"The size of the ivy leaves decreases as light intensity increases."
How would you use a 100 metre tape measure, a 30 cm ruler and a light meter to test this hypothesis?
You should include details of how you would make sure the results are valid. [6 marks]
Indicative content
- Use of tape measure to produce transect.
- Transect placed coming out of shady area (eg woodland) into lighter area.
- Repeat transects.
- Samples at same height above ground.
- Samples at same aspect (north, south, east or west) on trees.
- Measurement of length, or width, of leaves using ruler.
- Measure several leaves at each location.
- Use of light meter to measure light intensity.
- Repeat measurements of light intensity on several days.
- Measure light intensities at same time of day.
- Calculate mean for each location.
- Plot graph of mean leaf length, or width, versus light intensity.