BBC NEWSAmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific
BBCiNEWS  SPORT  WEATHER  WORLD SERVICE  A-Z INDEX    

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: UK: Politics 
News Front Page
Africa
Americas
Asia-Pacific
Europe
Middle East
South Asia
UK
England
N Ireland
Scotland
Wales
Politics
Education
Business
Entertainment
Science/Nature
Technology
Health
-------------
Talking Point
-------------
Country Profiles
In Depth
-------------
Programmes
-------------
BBC Sport
News image
BBC Weather
News image
SERVICES
-------------
News image
EDITIONS
Thursday, 21 November, 2002, 16:34 GMT
MPs told to set an example
Elizabeth Filkin
Elizabeth Filkin complained of bullying tactics

MPs must show the way on good behaviour if they want to try to stamp out misconduct in other industries, according to the chairman of an influential committee.

Sir Nigel Wicks was speaking as his Committee on Standards in Public Life said imposing fines on misbehaving MPs was one way of alleviating people's fears about sleaze.

Key proposals
Standards watchdog be appointed for single fixed term and have power to summon witnesses
New investigations panel with independent chairman
Standards committee have to publish full reasons for decisions
Fines be added to penalties
In an interview with BBC News Online, Sir Nigel outlined why a new investigations panel, headed by a judge or QC, would deal with the most "serious and contested cases".

Amid fears over the independence of the current system, his committee says no political party should have an overall majority on the body that judges whether MPs have broken their code of conduct.

The inquiry began after Parliament's former standards watchdog, Elizabeth Filkin, complained she had been victim of "bullying tactics".

Financial penalties

Ms Filkin had also expected to be reappointed automatically and did not reapply for the post when she was not.

To boost the watchdog's independence, Sir Nigel's committee wants the watchdog to be appointed for a single fixed term of between five and seven years.

And the commissioner would be able to summon witnesses and see documents.

At present any offending MP faces three forms of censure - they can be forced to apologise, be suspended from the Commons, or in extreme cases, be permanently expelled.

Sir Nigel Wicks
Wicks says public confidence is "absolutely vital"
Sir Nigel's committee says a scale of financial penalties, decided by the Commons, should be introduced for MPs who are not suspended.

The recommendations will disappoint those who want an end to self-regulation, such as ex-independent MP Martin Bell.

The committee says fundamental change may be needed in future.

Sir Nigel rejects the suggestion the committee held back from pushing for MPs to lose the right to regulate themselves because Parliament would not accept it.

"That is certainly not the case," he said. "We did look at the statutory option and we certainly don't rule it out for the future."

Sir Nigel said the proposals could achieve the twin objectives of boosting public confidence and carrying the confidence of MPs.

Last chance saloon?

Change could happen in a matter of months if MPs agree to the plans, he says, whereas changing the law would take "some time".

Some commentators have suggested the changes could represent a "last chance" saloon for self-regulation.

Those are not words echoed by former civil servant Sir Nigel, who insists Thursday's report is the "right for the time".

Martin Bell
Martin Bell: Self-regulation should end
Sir Nigel is anxious not to perform post-mortems on what has happened in the past.

But the committee does say the current system "has fallen short of delivering confidence in certain respects".

Public perception of misconduct has not helped voter turnout, he suggests.

He says public confidence in individual MPs, irrespective of party, is "quite high".

"But it is the House as a whole where there is less esteem and our objective is to try to increase public confidence in the House of Commons as a whole."

That is "absolutely vital" because the Commons is "at the heart of our democracy".

Sir Nigel argues the overwhelming majority of MPs want high standards but "one or two bad apples can tarnish the whole process".

Setting an example

He acknowledges that efforts to prevent an accounting scandal like Enron increase the responsibility on MPs to set a good example.

The Commons lays down the requirements for standards in local councils, the private sector and financial institutions, he says.

"And if it's doing that it needs to show leadership and so on in the way it regulates standards itself."

Perhaps the most radical recommendation is for the investigatory panel, which will also include two senior MPs.

Sir Nigel stresses the panel can help, not undermine, the work of the standards commissioner Philip Mawer, Ms Filkin's successor.

Public fact finding

The commissioner can ask the panel to intervene where he is having problems "getting to the bottom" of a claim or if an MP disputes evidence.

MPs facing allegations will also be able to call and cross-examine witnesses before the panel, which will meet in public.

That removes worries that the current system does not include all the principles of "natural justice", said Sir Nigel.

MPs on the Commons standards and privileges committee will still decide whether the rules have been broken.

But Sir Nigel insists the proposed changes would make the decision making process "much more transparent".

"If the commissioner's report is disagreed to by the committee, then it must fully explain whey it disagreed and make that public."

Meanwhile, Martin Bell, former member of the Commons standards committee, said the way Ms Filkin had been treated had been "disgraceful" in Parliament.

He welcomed some of the proposals but added: "We should end self-regulation. MPs just don't seem to be able to do it for themselves."

Elizabeth Filkin

The succession

Background

Analysis
See also:

13 Feb 02 | Politics
07 Dec 01 | Politics
05 Dec 01 | Politics
25 Oct 01 | Politics
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


E-mail this story to a friend



© BBC^^ Back to top

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |
Programmes