| You are in: Business | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Friday, 20 December, 2002, 08:34 GMT Italy's pensions timebomb ![]() Emanuela Foglietta wishes she had been born earlier
The United Kingdom is not the only country in the middle of a pensions crisis. Italy, with a low birth rate and a high proportion of the elderly, has worries of its own. When 28-year-old Emanuela Foglietta looks at the deductions on her monthly pay cheque she wishes she had been born half a century earlier.
"Because even if the state pension system survives there will be only crumbs left for us." Like many other young people, Ms Foglietta is a victim of Italy's pension timebomb. Her regular contributions to the state fund are gobbled up to finance current pensions. Old certainties vanish As the ratio of pensioners to workers increases, the younger generation will bear an increasing financial burden. And they can forget the comfortable state pensions enjoyed by their predecessors. Ms Foglietta's grandmother receives a generous government pension of 1,500 euros (�954; $1,540) a month. Her mother, a teacher, retired 10 years ago aged 50 and draws around half that amount. "Retiring early she settled for a lesser pension but she got out just in time" says Ms Foglietta, ahead of drastic changes to one of Europe's most generous pension schemes. Until 1995, all pensions were indexed to salaries and employees could finish their days with a pension equivalent to 80% of their final salary. Warnings ignored "The system was a complicated patchwork with pockets of privilege," says Daniele Pace, a pensions consultant who helped draft the 1995 reform. "We had the famous 'baby pensioners' who could stop work after just 20 years, pensions based on seniority, pensions based on age, special conditions for certain categories, such as people in the navy, even if they had spent their careers behind a desk not in a submarine." The system functioned while Italians were still having lots of children and there was economic growth. Recurrent warnings that the system was unsustainable went unheeded until the early 1990s when Italy's public finances required drastic measures. Demographic timebomb The state provisions for retirement were already struggling because of demographic changes.
Increased life expectancy does not help. Women, whose current life expectancy is 81, can stop work at 60. In 1995 Italy's pension calculations changed from salary-indexed to contribution based - in other words, you get out what you pay in. Those already working had their pension until then based on salaries, and in future on contributions. New entrants went straight onto the new system. "The reform was radical and the savings will be immense," says Mr Pace. "The problem is that they won't be felt for several decades." Options limited For critics, including Antonio Fazio, the governor of Italy's central bank, the measures are insufficient. Pensions currently eat up an estimated 13.6% of gross domestic product, a proportion expected to increase to 15% by 2015. The options open to the current coalition government are limited. They could extend the new contribution based system even to those near retirement but that would be politically unpopular. They are considering liberalising the retirement age and offering incentives to those who remain in the workforce. "In the late 1990s there was an exodus of people near retirement age," says Daniele Pace. "Early retirement has traditionally been used as a social shock absorber by industries in crisis, and that puts more pressure on the system." The government is urging people to take out private pension schemes but that market is still in its infancy. Emanuela Foglietta would like to take out a private pension plan but because she is on short term renewable contracts, she is reluctant to take on such a commitment. "I'll just have to have lots of children and hope they will support me in my old age." |
See also: 18 Dec 02 | Business 19 Dec 02 | Business 17 Dec 02 | Business Internet links: The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites Top Business stories now: Links to more Business stories are at the foot of the page. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Links to more Business stories |
![]() | ||
| ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- To BBC Sport>> | To BBC Weather>> | To BBC World Service>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- © MMIII | News Sources | Privacy |