Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
News image
Last Updated: Tuesday, 8 November 2005, 16:15 GMT
Probation for 999 crew attackers
Ambulance - generic
The crew had been called to assist the attackers' friend
Two men who carried out a drunken attack on ambulance service workers who had been trying to help their friend have walked free from court.

Paul Thomson, 18, and Stuart Dick, 21, had been warned that they faced jail for the attack on Stephen Rutherford and Scott McLeod in Glasgow.

However, a sheriff gave them community service and probation after she accepted that they had shown remorse.

Ambulance chiefs were disappointed at the leniency of the sentence.

Glasgow Sheriff Court heard how Mr Rutherford and Mr McLeod had been called to help the pair's friend after receiving a report of a collapse case in a house in Thornliebank in June.

When they arrived at 2300 BST, they found the two accused and another man dragging the unconscious man along the street.

We are pleased that on this occasion the two individuals who assaulted the paramedics have been brought to justice
Ambulance service spokesman

Thomson, of Invergarry Quadrant, Thornliebank, interfered as Mr Rutherford tried to check on the man and persisted in trying to get him into the ambulance despite being told to stop.

When Mr Rutherford moved to the front of the ambulance, he was attacked.

Prosecutor John Penman said: "He was punched and kicked on the body and Thomson removed a belt and struck him repeatedly.

"Both accused were involved causing the paramedic to fall to the ground."

Mr McLeod tried to stop the attack but he was also set upon.

Mr Penman said: ""He was also punched and kicked. At one point, Dick took hold of Mr McLeod's torch and hit him on the body."

The ambulance workers managed to escape and needed hospital treatment.

'Very confused'

Mr Rutherford suffered a 4cm cut above his eye and bruising to his body and Mr McLeod was treated for bruising to his upper arms.

After they pleaded guilty to the attacks in court last month, Sheriff Deirdre MacNeill said they faced the prospect of custodial sentences.

However, in court on Tuesday, the sheriff decided there was "a compelling case" not to jail them.

They were each given 220 hours' community service and placed on probation for two years.

Thomson's lawyer Des Finnieston said: "At the time, he was in a very confused position as regards to what was happening with his friend.

"He had taken steps to curb his drinking and I would ask that a last chance be afforded to him."

Glasgow Sheriff Court
The pair admitted the assault when they appeared in court

Martin Lavery, defending Dick, of Grange Lane, Gosport, Hampshire, said: "His family moved away from the area shortly after this to ensure he would never get involved in such again.

"He is normally an extremely dedicated individual, but, on this occasion, he went off the rails."

A spokesman for the Scottish Ambulance Service expressed disappointment at the sentence.

However, he said: "We are pleased that on this occasion the two individuals who assaulted the paramedics have been brought to justice.

"Any assault of any kind on a paramedic is deplorable in our view."

The two were charged prior to the introduction of the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Act which was introduced in an effort to get tough on those who attack police, fire and health workers.

The maximum penalty under the act is nine months in jail, a fine of �5,000 or both.


SEE ALSO:
'Red cards' for violent patients
16 Oct 05 |  Scotland
Emergency workers get protection
08 May 05 |  Scotland
Emergency workers protection move
23 Mar 04 |  Scotland


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific