Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
News image
Last Updated: Sunday, 16 October 2005, 11:54 GMT 12:54 UK
'Red cards' for violent patients
Nurses
Staff will be trained to de-escalate difficult situations
Staff in Glasgow hospitals and health clinics have been given the power to refuse to treat patients who submit them to physical or verbal attacks.

NHS Greater Glasgow said the step was a deterrent which would only be used in the most extreme circumstances.

Patients would be given a written "yellow card" warning for unacceptable violence or aggression.

If their behaviour continued they would be handed a "red card" which barred them from treatment on that occasion.

The case would be reviewed every time the patient returned for treatment.

Citywide policy

The decision to withhold treatment could only be taken by a senior clinician.

Glasgow's first citywide policy on dealing with violence and aggression towards healthcare staff covers hospitals, GP surgeries and clinics.

Treatment will not be refused to emergency patients, people with head injuries and those not responsible for their own actions, such as those with learning disabilities.

Incidents of violent and aggressive abuse are a serious factor for healthcare workers in our hospitals and communities
Sir John Arbuthnott
NHS Greater Glasgow's chairman

There were an average of three assaults a day on staff in Glasgow's hospitals over the year ending in March, and about 20 incidents of physical violence daily in community-based settings.

NHS Greater Glasgow's chairman, Professor Sir John Arbuthnott, said: "Unfortunately evidence shows that incidents of violent and aggressive abuse are a serious factor for healthcare workers in our hospitals and communities.

"This is clearly unacceptable, and NHS Greater Glasgow is totally committed to reducing and deterring such incidents as well as ensuring staff are trained to deal with situations when they do arise."

Staff are also to receive advice and guidance on dealing with difficult situations.

Sir John added: "It is our preference that we never reach the situation where we have to withhold treatment; preferring instead to de-escalate a situation before it gets to that stage."

This policy sends out the message that violence against healthcare staff will not be tolerated under any circumstances
Joe Gallagher
Royal College of Nursing

The policy was welcomed by Dr Phil Munro, an accident and emergency consultant at the Southern General Hospital.

He said staff deserved the chance to work without fear of intimidation, abuse or violence.

"My colleagues and I are all too aware from personal experience what it is like to deal with an aggressive situation," he said.

"The new policy therefore is helpful to us as it is clear, pragmatic and based on common sense."

The Royal College of Nursing's officer for Greater Glasgow, Joe Gallagher, said: "This policy sends out the message that violence against healthcare staff will not be tolerated under any circumstances."

Unison's Scottish organiser for health, Glyn Hawker, said the policy would "help to create a safer environment for staff and patients alike".


BBC NEWS: VIDEO AND AUDIO
Hear from staff who have faced abusive threats



SEE ALSO:
NHS staff 'facing abuse threat'
22 Mar 05 |  Health
Figures highlight NHS violence
28 Oct 04 |  Scotland
Two NHS staff attacks 'each hour'
26 May 04 |  Scotland


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific