Sen
I just want to say that our society needs a lesson on respecting others I mean we are in the year 007 c'mon! This is the problem in our society people just do not respect others no matter what their colour or background is ... I think Shilpa is being bullyied in many ways not just coz she is a higher class than Jade. She is more respectfull than others in the hoouse. People like Jade discuss me and there are many people like that in our country, people should learn a few things about backgrounds and respect it. Because at the end of the day we are all different and how can we live with each other if we don't respect one another!
HEATHER- DERRY
Shilpa IS DEFINITLY BEING BULLIED- IT IS RACIST!! DANIELLE AND JADE SHOULD BE THROWN OUT OF THE HOUSE!! IM IRISH AND ASHAMED TO BE ASSOCIATED WITH THE BRITISH TODAY!! DISGRACEFUL!! JADE AND DANIELLE HAVE NO SELF RESPECT OR DIGNITY- SO WHY PICK ON SOMEONE THAT DOES!! DANIELLE ALSO REMARKED THAT 'SHE SHOULD F*** OFF HOME, AND PROBABLY CANT SPEAK ENGLISH ANYWAY!!' SHAME ON YOU BIG BROTHER!!
Simon
Its a mixture of all. Let us not get confused with 'motivation' and 'execution'. Many are saying that its not racism its purely class, culture and this is true, but that is the motivation. Yes the girls feel threatened and out-classed. But who would ever say that? The easiest way to display this is to vent your anger and they have chosen the race card. Just because you don't understand someone does not give you the right to mimic tone, accent or gestures. Their 'execution' is one of racism. Its simple what they are actually saying is ..we may not be as wealthy or have as much class, but at least we are not an Indian. Its very simple painful, but the truth. Simon - Leeds.
leanne
i do not think it is racism. i believe she is being bullied because of her diffrences culturaly.they are treating her diffrently because of her diffrence. i also think the other girls are jeleous of her.
Adele G
Whether it's racism or cultural differences - it makes no difference to the fact that it's pure discrimination and someone's being emotionally effected by it. Furthermore, a few series back (when Science etc were in), a similar social division occured - where was the major hype then?
jaspa edwards
shes not the victim of racism she really is just stuck up!! its just the different cultures clashing pretty badly!!
Jase
I think most Blacks and Asians, particularly first generation, know and acknowledge there is still an undercurrent of racism in the country. However, Shilpa has not been on the end of any racist abuse - yet. Racism, along with her obvious beauty and class may be the cause of her bullying, but the housemates are yet to expose themselves fully if that is the case. Yes Jackiey called her "The Indian", but that is not a racist comment. She stated fact, Shilpa is Indian. To flip it round, if Shilpa had called her "The Englishwoman" would that have been deemed racist? No.
Hannah
If you've ever been a victim of racism then you'll know that people don't need to call you a racist name for you to realize that there racist. Although i don't think that the main reason for he arguments is racism but no one can deny that racial undertones are coming out.
Matt 'Wilts'
i quote 'she should f*** off home' if thats not racism then i dont know what is.....nuff said
A concerned citizen
Finally Britian is having to look at itself in the mirror at a face that is racist, fuelled by an ever increasing appetite for tabloid journalism. There's nothing new about the way in which Shilpa is being treated, immigrants have faced the same experience for years - ask anyone who emigrated here in the 60s and 70s. To use the basis of a person's origin or accent as a tool for mockery is racism. If Britian continues with these statements that Jade Goody and Co aren't racist, then there's a word for that too - denial.
Marxy
I think Shilpa is turning everything around and in fact bullying Jade.
Jade to win
Outloud
From what I've seen of the show (and the public will only ever see the most controversial clips) the issue is one of general ignorance not racism. The racism word is used too freely, in this case, it seems that cattiness between women is the problem which isn't a racial issue. Shilpa may be aware that she could be viewed as a victim of cattiness by the public and will be using that to gain support, she is clearly intelligent. The alleged racists will also have been made aware by their PR people that they will need to check what they say on air as they will have been advised that comments of any kind could be damaging to their public image. Its a game after all to raise all of the contestants profiles, thats why they agree to do the show, she doesn't seem to feel like a victim of racial abuse......
S
Also, it's not the way it's being edited! How can it be? The things being said aren't scripted. The scummy threesome are saying what they're thinking. How the hell could you possibly twist that & say it's being portrayed as racist due to the editing... oh please!
S
They are being racist. Full stop. It started out as bullying but has now taken on a racist tone. For those arguing it's not racist by substituting her Indian accent for a London/Scottish/Welsh one, well, let's put it this way. It's being said behind Shilpa's back in a extremely malicious way. That for me consitutes racism. And Channel 4 are carrying on saying that they're monitoring the situation closely & how if there was anything racist going on or if anyone was being bullied they'd step in. Well it is going on AND they're still letting it go on all for the sake of ratings.
Lisa
I don't understand all this fuss. Jade's mum was reffered to by Jamaine Jackson as 'White Trash' but that hasn't got such a huge reaction if any at all. Is it ok to direct racism at white English/British people?
liz robinson
the behaviour in CBB is racist behaviour. One has to be blind not to recognize cultural racism. Some liberals are into denial. Unfortunately, it is a microcosm of British society. The international community can come to its own conclusion.
Sharron
Well, lets face it, Shilpa is stunning. She has class. She is far more successful, beautiful and intelligent than the other 3 - and Jack. Its a shame they are so insecure and insanely jealous they need to make such cruel remarks. When you really think about it, bearing in mind the behaviour of these housemates, I'm not surprised Shilpa looks down on them as some people are suggesting (if indeed she has been and I'm not convinced), besides, she has proven she IS better than they are by keeping her dignity intact and not retaliating. The bullies should be made to feel ashamed of themselves. How can such biggots be allowed to represent our country? Shows their lack of education and class. How should we deal with such people? Simple, the media should shun them entirely and not give them the time of day. Frankly, none of them are worth it and I have no desire to read, see or hear about such pathetic, dense and frankly, common people.
Katie
I believe she is being bullied purely for the fact that she is more classy then the other girls. Jade, Danielle and JO are trashy and nowhere near as classy as Shilpa and they notice and b**ch about instead of just accepting it. Obviously there is nothing else to do in the house so Shilpa is there main topic. Sad trashy girls aren't they?!!
Yoshi
Regardless of whether it's racist or not, it's anyway bullying of somebody by a gang of nobodies. Shilpa is a successful actress, thus, a real celebrity, while the bullies are just a bunch of jealous ego-driven chav scumbags who cannot do anything decent and not even remotely celebrities. Why are those human filth in the "Celebrity" BB, in the first place? I have enough chavs around my student house. I don't wanna see them on the TV, please.
Kyah
THANK YOU Eileen. Has the world gone mad? When Racism truley happens, we never have this kind of outpouring of emotions!! IT IS NOT RACISM, Shilpa is from another culture, it wouldn't matter if she was White Asian, the fact is they just dont get along, it would be the same if one of the girls went into an Indian CBB, they would clash, which is EXACTLY what BB wants! Shilpa is no wall flower and can take care of herself.
ps I am a black woman and have experienced racism.
jazz
For all those who think this is not bullying with hints of racism, are obviously living in another world,. How much outrage would there be if this was a house full of asians and one white female was picked on like this. It doesn't suprise me at all as i've seen it too many times in his country. Too prove my point you only have to look at the biggest selling newspaper in the country is The Sun, which is blatantly racist, sexist, homophobic, etc
Doc Holiday
What is worse is the fact that after they are evicted, they will all proclaim their innocence and how they didn't mean it to come across as racism, However I think the damage by the three-stooges has already been done and the ethnic community aren't going to forgive them for mocking one of their icons. I sincerely hope they do not either.
imran
shilpa thought she was white but was not accepted.tuff should not have gone on the show in the 1st place.then u here people saying how religious she is
Lesta
The treatment of Jodie Marsh was far worse. More blantant and evil. Where were the so called anti bullying campaigners of you then?!! Watch the publicity machine hard at work.
Nicola
It's really embarassing that it's the English girls that are acting sooooo stupid, immature and ignorant. What must Jermaine and Shilpa think of us English girls if thats what they see!!!!!! They're a disgrace
Hannah - Yorkshire
Jade and Danielle are jealous of Shilpa, because she has a real job in the Entertainment business and doesn't strive on the media making her into a name. Shilpa is a beautiful, pleasant and fun lady and others see her as a threat. Jade and Danielle don't have a proper job and bitching is their only form of conversation, because there is nothing going for them in their own lives. (other than jades kids).
richie c
jades fit!
Rishi
Absolutely no racism. She's playing a devious game and BB edits it so we only get to see "good tv". Really objected to her starting the "evictions conversation" with Cleo and Carole but being let off with no penalty. Nasty piece of work there. Jade to win!
Joseph Alapatt
Except for some of the housemates in the big brother show , the rest are loosers .Its quite natural that they can get aggrevated by their perplexed brains. Shilpa should not have committed herself to such physic programmes which actually brings in a sense of envy among these bunch of desolate housemates....
Austin
Watever be the case racisim or jealousy Big brother has got good advertisement and Shilpa also got benefitted from this....
James Martin
This is racist bullying. full stop.. It makes me ashamed to be british... For god sake, its 2007!! racism should have stopped centries ago.... I hate people who are racist!!
Sheela
I am a British Indian. I am proud of my adopted country.But hey I must say that the racism and bullying faced by Shilpa is not unusual. Its part of xenophobia which lot of small minded Britishers feel. Did you not notice when you are in the supermarket how the till girl speaks to you as opposed to others !Come on we face it all the time.Some in people here have only travelled as far as Majorca/tenerife. Their knowledge is limited and their upbringing makes them prone to abusing bullying and racism. Wake up Britain.Rest of the world respects you for what you have done in the past[ science,technology, literature etc]but if you want to maintain the repect in future, you need to respect other cultures! Yes Indians eat by their hands but they wash their hands before.Dont forget not long ago people here shared the same bath water !
eileen davison
Im truly angry at the way the media are always creating situations that are'nt the the true of full story.and your programme has done the same by airing jades question about eskimos what about clios if laurel hardy was clint eastwoods dad.
i worked on big brother and left after the 5th series because of the revenue they make from phone votes and how they manipulate the public by showing only half of the incident that happend so the public get angry towards certain house mates and then at the end of the day its at the top where the decisions made as to who wins but the public still think they voted that person to win.from what we are seeing shilpa looks a victim to bulling and racist but she is no weak cookie believe me this is her brake into the english media and if this is what it takes for her than so be it.
imran gill
There might be some bullying going on but as an brit pakistani, I feel thoroughly ashamed. It seems racism is still rife in this country!!! It makes me feel sad and ashamed. Why do people have to behave like this? And why do so many people find it easy to apologise and rationalise? Some may call it racism, some may not - but I imagine there are a great many Indians living in this country who certainly feel more isolated because of this and more fixed in their beliefs that this country would never truly embrace them Channel 4 should take a very clear line and stop this behaviour.
It's about saying what is right in society and what is wrong
Alittle shocked at jo's statement in which Jo opined that Indians are thin because they are always ill as a result of undercooking their food. HARSH!!!
Guberg-Unit
There is a difference between ignorance, bullying and stupidity, and rascism. Jade and the other girls are definatly on the igonorant side. And shheez weell fitt. blap blap.
Lee
Jade and Danielle are bullies, I believe they would be bullying Shilpa whatever nationality she was because she is different. Shilpa is a huge star, she is talented and beautiful. Most of all she has class, knows how to behave and how to treat people with respect. They are jealous, as essentially they are talentless nobodies and to use the word celebrity in regards to them is a joke. Their behavior is exactly the type you she from gangs of girls in school yards. I was very glad to she Jade stripped of her Ant-Bullying charity spokespersonship. I sincerely hope that the media will stop writing about and putting either of these girls on TV as they are an embarrassment and as a nation we should be ashamed of them.
Rukhy
Big brother had called Shilpa to appear on their show, and she is being extremely bullied by jade, jo and Danielle. I feel that they make very rude and hurtful comments that are racist and i feel that Big Brother should do something to support Shilpa. Big brother should be ashamed to see this happening on their show. Is that how asians should be treated on tv, we know it happens in reality but it should not appear on tv as it is almost encouraging racisms. When white people visit india they are welcomed with huge smiles and treated with great respect, so wy should they be able to treat Shilpa in this way? I think that it is unnacceptable!
kammy k
what are jo (two faced) danielle and jade playin at, they are clearly jealous of shilpa because of her insane beauty and her popularity back home, racist jestures have kind of been made about her country back home i believe the three jade jo and danielle should get evicted or this may get worse and something bad may happen in the house
shell
i cant stand her, she constantly seeks attention, and everytime there is a situation its because she goes lookin 4 something 2 create a problem about!!
Rich
What Jade and her allies are displaying, is pure racism decorated with manifest ignorance that . It takes one to be on the receiving end of racism, if one has to fully grasp what Shilpa is going through in Jade's 'manor'. It is more than time to call that disgraceful show to an end. Numerous and deliberate cheattings have been taking place and noone has ever defended the public. E.g. Jade will never vote for jack, and Jack would never vote for jade. yet they can still vote the other housemates. This is giving them more advantage than the other housemates. In all fairness, during the nominations, jade and her boyfriend should have 1/2 voice each in order for the remaining housemates to compete with them fairly. Rich
Sandeep
I personally think that Shilpa is far too good for Big Bro!
She has come from India to take part in a game show where in respect to her was for wider acknowledgement. She is in the house with some people that have a brain the size of a fish. Jack was unaware of what an embryos was I mean come on my 10 year old cousin knows what that is. Just because Jade has changed her appearance a little doesn’t mean that she now has a brain. Danielle who is she again?? To me she just looks like standard women you see in town shopping every Saturday afternoon.
Shilpa is beautiful, intelligent and speaks the Queens English and the girls feel threatened. They hate her because she is frankly a much better person.
Jermain is a good man has a lot of time for Shilpa who needs the support as she is playing a game away from home on someone else’s turf. Oh and one last thing she has a black belt in Martial arts so although she is an emotional person I’m sure she could whoop someone's behind all day long!!
ANON
1. She is being called "the Indian", because she is from India, therefore she is Indian.
(If we called Jade a Chav, would that be racist?) 2. She is being ganged up upon because she is a behaving like an upper class, spoilt person. Sick and tired of people using the word "racist" without due cause.
Helen
BB is what it is, good entertainment. We're supposed to see friction, I mean come on there has been a lot worse incidents than whats happening now on that show. It's certainly not bullying and escpecially not racism. Come on people grow up here, think about what you're complaining about.
Sunayna
Big brother is now just disgusting to watch because of the way Jade, Jack, Danielle and Jo are bullying Shilpa and I can't believe that Channel 4 are condoning it, probably because to them it makes 'good TV'. Shilpa treats everyone with dignity and respect and those four don't even know the meaning of the word. And for Jack to keep insulting Shilpa the way he does is just childish, stupid and totally uncalled for, he doesn't even know Shilpa and hasn't made and effort to. What is he doing in there? Regardless, Shilpa doesn't deserve to be singled out the way she has, but she can rise above it, which is what the other girls are so jealous of.
Geddy
Is anyone else picking up on the fact that Shilpa has commented and made snide remarks on the other girls intelligence,grammar and accent. Surely that can be classed as racist and bullying!!
Beth
Jade, Dannielle and Jo are a complete disgrace and should be thoroughly ashamed of their treatment of one of their housemates. I'm not too sure if their intenentions are racist, but they are certainly showing their true colours - a nasty shade of green.
lisa
i'm not sure whether it's racism, i just think it's a bunch of yobbish, uneducated idiots (jade, jo, danielle) picking on someone because she's beautiful, elegant, classy and more successful than they could ever hope to be!
Barry white
Its bullying : plain and simple.
the question is why the hell it has gone on this long ?
Mohammed Ashfaq
i don't think that the girls are racist.However there is a lot of jealousy as Shilpa is more beautiful , alot more intelligent,classy and sophisticated than all the girls put together. Moreover, she has a successfull film career back home.Plus she speaks better English than the rest.Jade does even know how to put a sentence together gramatically and her vocabulary is also very week. Shilpa to win.Bradford as well as England have hopes on you Shilpa.Shilpa to win. Insha Allah
adil
i know some people say that girls can be bitchy which is true sometimes, but as a victim of bullying myself i feel the racial tension in that house and i'm not living there, some people think it isn't racism which is debateable however it is defintely Bullying at the highest order, i feel and most people might feel, apprehension, anger, fear and anxiety the same emotions i felt when i was bullied.
santosh
I would agree that it was initially jealousy because shilpa is an intelligent beautiful women who carries herself with respect and dignity, but after watching the show today I now think it has turned into a form of bullying and racism because she is different. To call a women a bitch, a wa....er, and a dog is just not moral. It has become racist because now Danielle, Jo and Jade are saying things like 'do they not all eat with their hands in India' and 'maybe that is how they cook chickens over there' which is generalising and making assumptions about a culture they obviuosly know nothing about. Makining fun and ridicule about someones accent is discrimination because you are picking on the indivivual because they are not like you. Jermaine, Dirk, H and I think Clio are feeling very uncomfortable with this. If these are the people who are living with these individuals they can't all be wrong in saying this is not right and are noticing the bullying and discrimination. I personally think that Mr Sheringham as a role model for youngsters should be ashamed to be associated with someone like Danielle
Gemma
This is ridiculous! Shilpa has been bitchy and snidey from the beginning. She looks down on everyone in the house, thinks she's better than them all, and always has to stick her nose in where it's not wanted. I don't think she's being bullied at all, the other housemates are just reacting to her nastiness. She's stuck up and needs knocking down a peg or 10!
Jai Arora
Jermaine is her big support. The way he handles the things is amazing. He is a god sent gift I would say in most troubled time of her career she is going through with no mannered girls who are just finding excuses to mock at her. ' Carole is an intelligent women and I bet she would have understood when shilpa raised her hand for Carole eviction. Shilpa put it very nice way by saying she is playing game by rule not by minds. Her relation with Carole was great and would be great once she is out of the house. Shilpa we are proud of your persistence and work. Keep it up
zeddy
shilpa- get the idea- you're on British Soil, welcome to this great Nation.
Rick
It really shows how Jade/Danielle/Jo are not being tolerant of Shilpa's cultural differences and their intolerant view is making her a social outcast within the house. This is no fault of Shilpa's who is trying very hard to integrate and is purely down to bigoted and narrow-minded attitudes. They need to grow up.
Tom
theres a clear difference between a classy beautiful hindi actress adored by 800million people, and flop pop stars whos hardly known by name in this country. and jayde?who?This is exactly what c4 wants..contreversy..more money!!its almost like they paid jayed to do it.
Dave
Shilpa will never win as Britian is the most racist and backward country in the world.... I know as I have travelled the world and live here!... she might as well enjoy the fee for her apperance.
sush
I think it is a combination of racism and jealousy. I do not feel sorry for Shilpa at all but feel sorry for the others who have no idea how to behave infront of the nation. Their true colours are showing. Perhaps Big brother should ensure that it does not turn nasty and that they do not loose out on all the new viewers attracted by Shilpa's entrace to Big Brother!! Hang to your dignity Shilpa....we are with YOU.....
=Snoop=
Is the motive racial or just a group of girls taunting something they find a threat to them? The fact that Shilpa initially got and still gets far more attention from the guys can't have gone unnoticed by the rest of the girls. The introduction of Jade has changed the group dynamics, as has Carole’s eviction, as she was the link between Shilpa and the trio of girls. The likes of Jo and Danielle have come out of their shell far more than before, it is very difficult to restrain your "real" side for too long! I think the straw that really broke the camel's back was when Shilpa was overly domineering during the ordering of items when she brushed aside Jackie. Danielle stoked up the fire secretly to Jo and Jade by making her displeasure, towards Shilpa, very clear. Must say Cleo has done well to mediate and explain the gulf in culture between Shilpa and the rest, Jo has acknowledged that but when she is in the company of the other two girls she takes the back seat and does nothing to quell the taunts, she cowers behind the two! The clique within the trio is far too strong for a cessation in their behaviour. The lack of intelligence within that group is leading to basic school ground taunts and the fact that Shilpa's name is unusual as is her accent she is the convenient target, classic school bullies. However, there is no sign of racial bigotry, just nasty behaviour. My personal view of Shilpa is she is very attractive and articulate but lacks personality and is often very irritating.
paul
if some one gave an impression of someone, with a yorkshire accent or london accent would this be a racist attack????
2kool4skool
i think shilpa is bufffffffff :)
saffah
Danielle is just a two faced lost girl, Jade looks like a pig and Jo looks like a man so its obvious that the girls are jealous of Shilpa because she is beautiful and has alot more class and dignity than them. she can deffinately speak better english than Jo Danniele and Jade. Jack who? He's just jade's toy boy who has no personality and really should not be in the house.
I think Shilpa is being to nice and should just do her own thing and ignore the bitchy remarks because at the end of the day it is Shilpa who was paid the most for entering the house and she's g
oing to go back to India and never see these people again.
Richard Wignell
I agree with all those who've pointed out that Shilpa's behaviour and dignity puts the others to shame. And when she has a disagreement, as she did with Danielle, she is always the first to try to smooth the situation over, as she did last night when Danielle was part of the 'Jackson 5'. As for racism I think the other girls are insecure around Shilpa (although I can't see that Shilpa has tried to present herself s superior) and this, rather than racism, is the reason for their viciousness, but they are using racist terms and abusing her in a racist way behind her back. lets hope Danielle, Jo and Jade are thrown out, in that order.
sujatha
Shilpa is been bullied over n over again!!
The lunatics Jade and Danielle should be thrown out of the show with immediate effect...Its time to remind them that Shilpa is a blackbelt in karate...
Jade n Danielle lack everything and they are just ugly souls and characterless!!!!
Of course I want Shilpa to win and prove the point!!!!
Megan
Well, i just want to say that what would it be hailed as if shilpa had turned around and called jacky the "white" one? or jacko, japo or whatever your name is....blah blah blah....all these girls are blatently stupid and jealous of what shilpa has....CLASS, something jade can only dream of...eventhough shes made 8 million....please everyone just look at the big picture...and all you shilpa supporters VOTE FOR HER TO WIN!!
Ryan
Am concerned Channel 4 haven't done something about this. Comments and behaviour from Jacky and Danielle have been unacceptable in this day and age. Jo, Jacky, Jade, Danielle and even Jack are as common as muck, stupid and totally ignorant, i hope they get what they deserve. Shilpa is gorgeous and successful and too good for the show!
Jade (yep i share a name with HER!)
straight up. yeh...shes indian...is that the first thing that pops up in your head when you see someone...what their colour is ? is that the first judgement you should make ? u should see beyond colour. her names SHILPA...not 'the indian' . she doesnt walk around the house saying....WHITEBOI? or BLACKMAN ? does she. as for jade n her family. they got iq's of goldfish. and that jack. all he is ...is a pretty face..attracted by the money of Jade.Simply. lol.
Abdul Hye
Well i got to say the jealousy here would be an under statement. compared to her beauty and fame. she is royalty to them. and they just can't except that. all the other housemates should just walk out. they have no chance. if only india was able to vote. they would not stand a chance with her. Shilpa you rock.
Rahi
I personally think these girls will have a gang war against Shilpa, They just need an excuse to keep her morale down. They have made her an odd man out in the house. I think shilpa is strong and can deal with the situation, but i personally think Dani, jo and Jade feel unsecure when she is around, and i think you people already know why.
Claire O'Hara
It is not racism...yet. Nobody has mentioned her skin colour or mocked her for it. Plus, if there was racism going on in the house surely the other hpusemates would also have a problem with Jermaine?! At the end of the day, it is just a case of a few bitchy girls getting themselves caught up in a series of petty conversations becuase they have nothing better to do and it probably gives them a feeling of superiority even though they are only proving that Shilpa is a more more dignified, respectful person by doing so. I just hope that they don't go as low as to make remarks on the basis of her skin colour.
Stephanie
everyone is stereotypical to an extent, and someone denying this is only kidding themselves.....
however, for such a multicultural society that we live in, and in fron of the millions watching BB, this is atrocious. She is different, and the ladies of the house are seeing her as the outgroup to their own ingroup. Its just going to be a shame seeing the bullies become the bullied when they exit the house
Shore Michael Keystone
Shilpa is the prettiest girl in the house. She does not run or try to hide where she comes from. She is doing a great job. I do think that Jade was being a bully. But that kind of behaviour is by no means outside the parameters of BB Behaviour. I think Shilpa has something up her sleeve. Because a woman is what a woman does. And all kinds of factors could've let Shilpa take what she took from Jade. raar. the cats are out.
Lisa
The bb girls vs Shilpa scenario is just another example of how the UK is now devided today. Any kind of conflict however small, the people of ethnic minorities instantly use the racism card. This is not racism. The subject has been simply blown out of proportion by those that can use the racism card. Jades accent/voice has often been taken the mick out of - but no body ever has ever said that was racist!!
Fiona
Jackiey's defiant refusal to put any effort into pronouncing Shilpa's name was racism, whether she knew it or not. She seemed to dismiss it as not something she should be expected to manage as it's one of those funny foreign names.
The way the girls are treating Shilpa now is not overt racism, but it is bullying and they cannot cope that she is different to them. They seem to resent her poise, intelligence and beauty, and find any excuse to criticise. They find this easy because they don't identify with her, and that is partly because of racial or cultural differences that they don't seem to want to bridge.
Vidhatri
Jees what can you say. Shilpa is definitely being victimised. Danielle and Jade have no talent and are very threated by Shilpa. They are also proving to be very two faced. What surprises me is how channel four does not concentrate on this bullying issue on big brothers little brother or big brothers big mouth. Its as though they chose to ignore the hypocracy of a joke that Danielle and Jade are. I hope the public pipe up against their childish behaviour and give them a hard time. Plain and out right idiots!
suze
There is no way there is racism going on in the big brother house, all those people who have complained have just taken political correctness to an extreme level. How come no one said anything about carol, dirk, jermaine and leo slating Jakie saying she was 'white trash' and calling the family scum, how come that isn't racism? How come when Carol was telling the girls to watch themeselves because Jackie is a lesbian and she would fancy all of them, that wasn't homophobia?? Why is nobody up in arms about leo saying the reason he left the country is because of the take over of 'lower class' families like the Goody's? Why is the only time anything is brought into the media limelight when some up herself woman is told wots for and then people claim that is racism?? Absolutely ridiculous!
shaz....
I don't think this situation is out right racism, although i'm sure a lot of people have seen some of the footage were shilpa has been called certain things and bb has bleeped out some words were f***** is used as the second word. So there can only be a few words that bb find they need to bleep out and its probably not "ugly or fat" etc...
i think the situation dores high light a number of issues....
Nisha M
Im an attractive asian female and I experienced the same treatment shilpa is getting when i first went to uni and joined an all white female household.
Shilpa is defending herself and upholding the way she has been brought up, she has class and her up bringing has taught her to be strong, polite and friendly to all. Yes she wants to please everyone but wouldnt you being non-brit and asian in a predominantly british and white household. its a case of culture clash and misunderstanding and people forget that we are all human and that our colour aint a wall and doesnt change the fact that we all got to live together! 1st they say shes too posh to be in the servant quarters and now when shes doing all the cooking and cleaning now shes a pain in the butt! make up you mind haters! shes beautiful, talented and speaks better english than the natives! she aint gotta be a gob shite like jade to show shes not gunna take it either!
nicki
this show is going down hill get it off the screens what genius thought of putting shilpa in a house with jades family.girls like her are bi***y anyway and remember jade and her family aint the brightest sparks are they, danielle probably has the same IQ as jade which is LOW maybe the producers should call it big jade!!!!! why doesnt shilpa stand up for her self or play them at their own game!!!!! im sure there is alot to be said about jade.
rg
I think Shilpa is amazing. Beautiful, talented and intelligent. And with regards to Danielle and Jo mocking her accent lets hear their indian. Jade does my head in. Everyone going on about how much weight she had lost. (yeah right). she is a fat, ugly twat. Her equally lame boyfriend is only with her for the money. The only reason Jack is mocking Shilpa is because he fancies her and who wouldn't when your stuck with what hes got. Shilpa to WIN
Manraj
Shilpa has come from India, and is probably not use to the common British xenophobia. I feel sorry for her as she has gone into a house when Asian people are easy targets. Also on Becky’s comment Shilpa is far from hard to say, I think it goes deeper than just the name though. If you have never experienced racisms you will never know what we are taking about.
Sam
It's typical of white british middle lower class people to bring race into it the minute they don't get along with someone who's non white. They really need to be educated and groomed and taught how to meet and deal with people of all backgrounds cultures etc. Talk about proving they are pure white trash!!!! They might have mad quick money but obviously failed to buy any common sense manners and knowledge.
Sarah
Shilpa is being relentlessly racially abused on this programme. It makes uncomfortable, unpleasant and disturbing viewing. Shilpa is an intelligent, graceful, articulate woman who speaks better English than any of the bullies in Jade's gang, and goes out of her way to be friends, but is subjected to taunts about her accent, her cooking and her name. That is clearly racism and the Channel 4 producers should step in to prevent it happening anymore. Failure to do this is tantamount to encouraging the unacceptable. People should complain to Channel 4 about it. It is ugly to watch. I can't imagine Danielle or Jade would be treated like that in the Indian version of BB. It seems that a lot of people in this country have been brought up with no manners and a predilection for intolerance. I think the only ones who have behaved with true dignity and kindness on this programme are Shilpa and Jermaine. Even Cleo is not bringing the others to task for their abhorrent behaviour and seemed to admire Jackiey for her ignorance.
Jas
It is blatant racism. Jackiey referred to her as 'the indian', which constantly singles her out from the others, Jo took the mick out of her accent behind her back, which is unfair seeing as English is Shilpa's second language. Jack said 'she wants to be white', which implies he thinks whites are superior and everyone wants to be white. Jade and Dani both laughed at this and it wasnt shown on the highlights. Plus they call her all sorts of names, most of which are totally offensive and disgusting.
Samir
1. Shilpa has been referred to as "the indian"
2. Her accent has been mimicked
3. Jackiey went out of the way not to pronounce her very difficult name!
4. Shilpa hasnt portrayed any bitchiness or bad behaviour towards those picking on her. racism or whatever, shes being picked on for no reason whatsoever
Gail
Why are these girls being called "racist". Maybe Shilpa is not a likeable person, Indian or White. Girls are generally very b**chy, there is no reason to call it racism
BALLY
I THINK DANIELLE IS SOOO JEALOUS BECAUSE SHILPA IS MUCH BETTER LOOKING & MORE INTELLIGENT THAN HER, AND WHO THE HELL IS "JACK" APART FROM JADE'S BOYFRIEND HE DOESNT DESERVE TO BE IN THERE, GET HIM OUT!!
Jezzerd
Well it's simple...... The 'girls' in the house think Shilpa is a threat. They realise that Shilpa is naturally attractive & has more intelligence than them all put together! I Personally don't think there is a racist angle at the moment.
Sat
I would like to think that if there was racism taking plce in the house that CH4 would have the decency to do something about it, i dont think daniella and jade are being racist but it is very clear they have issues with shilpa and cannot resolve them with a bit of diginity. I dont think it has anything to do with communication, i think adults these days should be able to speak to each other properly without barking at each other..especially if the other person has the decency to not raise their voice. Jade and Daniella are very immature and acting like they are back on the playground, they are too busy bitching about shilpa behind her back to other housemates but when shilpa is asked about the situation has she even said anything deogratory about Jade or Daniella? Nothing..just that she doesnt understand them and that she wont take being spoken to like that..who would? Daniella and Jade are defo jealous, even if they dont realise it, shilpa is gorgeous, handles her self with alot of diginity, class and self respect and knows how to string a sentence together better than the both them put together! Thing is people always feel threatened by something they know nothing of..if they got to know her instead of judging her am sure they would all get on alot better.
Brian Nigel Parks
How is it racist? to mimic somebodies acent, infact Shilpa, started a conversation doing the same to jade, She has an indian accent? so if you mimic her? err u will mimic that accent!? Jackie isnt racist, she is un PC, but that is a generation thing, im sure there are plenty of people her age of all colours that refer to people in a way that a younger generation finds unacceptable... also "this" country accepts all Races, find another country in the world that allows people to openly come out and attack "our" way of life and say how people should be killed?! No only Brittain!
LYNN
I do think the girls (Danielle, Jade and Jo) are being typical - young bitchy girls. No one would ever admit jealousy. As for racism, not to sure about that! Shilpa cannot pronounce Dirk's name - is that racism? Also what about Shilpa and Jermaine discussing the fact that someone had said Jade's family were White Trash - Shilpa sat there with a smile on her face. Aren't they both "above" those sort of comments, even though they were repeating what someone else had said? I was a bit confused by Jermaine as Jade had told Jermaine she was of mixed race. I think Shilpa does bring a lot of the problem on this herself. She expects to be treated as she is in India - the show is Celebrity Big Brother - Not the Shilpa Show! Also when she accused Jade of not speaking to her (whilst she was actually having the conversation with Danielle),she didn't like the fact that Jade tried to reply and cut her off saying I don't like this, I expect to be spoken to with respect. You earn respect it isn't given freely, something all parties should be aware of.
Somayeh O'Driscoll
Racism?!?!?!? The world has definitely gone mad if Shilpa's treatment in the house is being attributed to racism. Danielle is merely a silly girl who doesn't show any respect for the bollywood beauty. This is just another example of what happens when a group of girls are put together and given alcohol and similar incidents have occured throughout all series of BB. Call a spade a spade - these girls are just thick NOT racist (although...despite Jade's treatment of Shilpa, I'm still rather fond of her, whereas Danielle seems to be inherently nasty)
Fiona
I watched BB in tears last night. It brought back memories of my school days where I was bullied by a group of girls for years. I feel so sorry for Shilpa - she has always tried to be nice. She doesn't deserve this treatment at all. I want those girls thrown out!
Pav Leong
If this was happening inany other country racism would not be tolaranted, why is it okay for this to happen on British TV
Kyah
I think there is a big communication breakdown. Shilpa is obviously not used to people answering her back in such a manner and fails to understand that just because a person disagrees with you it is not necessarily a personal attack. Her cultural background and professional status back home means that she will find it difficult to fit in and be one of the girls and will not get their sense of humour. I do not feel it has anything to do with her colour, she's just used to a different lifestyle and is not as tolerant as she thinks she is. It makes me mad that nowadays if people have an argument on telly and the other person starts crying, they are accused of bully!! Who is bullying her? NO-ONE!!
Nimisha
I think that Shilpa is the victim of racism in the house. I'm not just saying this because im Indian and i don't want to play the race card. I mean why take the mickey out of her accent. Jackiey calling her 'the indian' was out of order..... why didn't Davina pull Jackiey up about that?? If they can't understand Shilpa's culture then they need to open their minds!!! They are SO ignorant it's unacceptable behaviour. Danielle and Jade are bullies and insecure. So more for integration??????????????? This country is never going to accept any other colour than white.
Irfan
It is a clear form of racism. Whether it is direct or indirect, you can sense the vibes. If you have experienced any form of discrimination, you will know that what is taking place in the house is very ugly and sad. CH4 should make a point of it. Shilpa to win!
George
I definitely feel uncomfortable about the way Shilpa seems to be targetted by these girls. If they have a problem with her that's fine but rather than discussing it on a one to one basis there just seems to be a group onslaught and the bitching seems to revolve around her being Indian i.e. her accent, her name, etc. To me this borders on downright racism and it will be interesting to see how the producers of BB will deal with this if it continues, so far they just seem to be ignoring it. We sholud ask ourselves as a nation would we have allowed this type of behaviuor on our mainstream tv five years ago? On Shilpa's part she seems to be taking it extremely well and showing great restraint and poise i handling them
tanya
i think they are treating shelpa bad and she shouldnt be treated like that.i like both daniel and shelpa but daniel got out of control.i want shelpa to win to show the others how much she is liked.i like shelpa.i want durk to go.xxxxshelpa to winxxxx
Anon
The behaviour displayed is representative of the underlying racism that is still prevalent in our society, despite what most people will say. The behaviour by those in the BB house is due to a number of reasons. Jealousy probably plays a major role, but also fear of the unknown, which they are reacting to with hostility. Racism in this country has become increasingly worse in the last few years. People try to deny it or cover it up but there is no disputing the fact that it is occurring.
Roger
Think Jermain put his finger on it: White Trash.
Natasha
Shilpa is a internationally known star. Her face is familiar to millions and millions of people across, Asia, the Middle East, Europe and the US. Unlike certain other housemates she does not need the fame and personally I think those picking on her cannot handle the fact that she is so much more successful.
Becky
I just heard that some people are up in arms about Shilpa being racially abused. What a load of Bull. If she was white with a complicated name (eg Ghislaine) Jackiey wouldnt have been able to say it as she is like that (common as!). If she was an essex girl (like Jade in the original BB for example!) they would be just as likely to take the mic out of her voice. Get over yourselves you idiots. Should we say that all the housemates are racist as they donned afro wigs, obviously taking the mic out of Black people?!!
sharon, derby
I feel really sorry for Shilpa. She isnt my favourite person in the house but i definitely think that she is the victim of bullying.
People can be so cruel and i dnt get it. It seems as though they jump down her throat as soon as she says something. Its not hard to see that she is a lady with so much self respect and dignity i think the other girls must be slightly jealous.
Nat
It's obvious the girls are well jealous of her - she's beautiful, intelligent and speaks better English than all of them! Let's hope there's no real rascist element in it though...
GTheFunksta
I dont think it is racism. Shilpa is beautiful, intelligent and has some real class. Qualities which the green eyed girls severly lack. They are just hating on her because they feel threatened, any one with half a brain cell can see that Danielle and Jade are feeling a little insecure around Shilpa.