Is there an event planned for 2006? Si www.mister-pink.co.uk
Si Pink
no the judges didnt make the right desicion. out patients had the crowd motivated right from the start. WJ? kept them moving with the second set of the night... then i noticed people started to leave the building when KSA played their first song. it was a shame that the sound, although better than in the heats, was very muffled and "muddy" its also a shame that it seems to be the last band on that always wins, to me this shows that the decision has already been made before the night has started. GET SOME ROCK IN YOUR LIVES!
-virus-
No, AVR and FInal Rest were the best bands there, AVR should have won.
Dan
Because they both sounded like the sound of a dieing camel...
Meg
So the KSA won because they're different, yeh they're different but so would be the sound of a dieing camel, bad decision there. Why didn't either metal band get through?!?!?!
Dan
I think the judges made the right decision! i love both of the other band especially where's jonny, i think they are great! but i think sometimes it does take something different to make a winner, you need someone that stands out and you think wow!! that was different so you can remember it!!... deffinatly agree i think the marking system needs to be changed as there is so much controversy over how the judges come to there decisions! well done to all!!
Amy
Well done guys. Now; the world!
Luke Littleboy
Who needs to have a good grasp of what makes a song when you can make lots of noise and shout a lot? The KSA clearly put everything they could into their performance and that came across really, whereas WJ? I thought were really boring.
Meg
I think maybe the wrong decision was made. Yes the Khe Sahn did something different and it was a good performance, but being different doesn't make something good. Without the visuals the Khe Sahn would probably come across as nothing but noise. The reviewer states they don't do 'standard guitar grunge' when in essence that's all it is with added noise and politics. Where's Jonny have good structured songs with a distinct style running through them all and are actually excellent musicians with a good grasp of what makes a song (dynamics, texture etc). From what I hear, it was only down to the 'erratic' marking of one judge which actually swung it Khe Sahn's favour which brings up the validity of the marking system - maybe they need to adopt the Olympic style 'drop the highest and lowest score' and use the average. Just my 2p worth, well done Khe Sahn anyway.
Moog
Yes yes yes the right decision indeed!!!
Dr. Sprtsch
of course they made the right decision! The Khe Sanh Approach are amazing, well done =).
Charly
A good night.. Congrats to The KSA for winning and doing something different. Also I thank them for Including me on the Flip chart of the Christ Is Right thus enhancing my Messiah complex.
"the judges didn't have to think too hard to award victory to the KSA."
This report seems a little one sided considering WJ? were beaten by .16 of a point out of total of 40.. thats not sour grapes but the only information you seem to have on my band is that we like films..
Trevor (Yes I do have a Sister)Hurley, Where's Jon