|
BBC Homepage | |||
Contact Us | |||
Robbie WilliamsYou are in: Stoke & Staffordshire > Entertainment > Music > Robbie Williams > Can you love Robbie TOO much? ![]() Can you love Robbie TOO much?In her letter of protest, Katharina Murer admitted that Robbie and his music made her life better, but also worried that his fans overdo it. Such an overwhelming response from you has prompted her to write again... 'I would never ever have guessed what reaction it might cause to write my protest letter...With my words against self-destruction in the name of fan-dome it seems I have found only the surface of what appears to me like a gigantic iceberg... After all that happened following my letter I often felt overwhelmed. So many of the replies really touched me and I'm so grateful for all the people who sent me messages and emails and all the other things to show they care as well. I will never forget when I was asked to send my letter to a young girl who considered committing suicide because of Robbie. I don't know if my letter can help someone in that situation, but if it can, nobody can guess how happy I am about it. And when reading some of the really sad replies, talking about depression, suicide or self-destruction, I couldn't stop thinking about where, in all this incredible mess, where are you, Rob? Where are you Rob?Personally, the answer I found to this question really surprising… I am convinced that Robbie Williams cannot cause a person's depression, suicide or self-destruction. All these can be caused by a lot of reasons - personal, physical, or medical, but music cannot cause that - Robbie Williams cannot cause that. I think obsession and excessive fan-dome is a way to compensate. It is a flight from reality to dreams. As Robbie said himself, he writes the lyrics of a depressed alcoholic and these are people who feel touched by them. But if Robbie himself knows the pain of such diseases, why does he not care better for his fans? Rob, don't you care? …More than anyone else, you do indeed care...…More than anyone else, you do indeed care. You have let your fans look deep in such personal matters as fighting depression and alcoholism. We have seen you battle your diseases in films; we have read along in books, we have heard you talk about it a million times, remember? “And the only reason why I talk about it is just that maybe someone who reads this will find himself and think: ‘That’s me, that’s what I have too and when he did it that way, then I can do that too.” Thank you, Kathi' My Protest letter'For many of us “Robbie Williams” has become much more than any other person in this universe. This is why today, I want to write a letter of protest against this simple fact. I know that for many of Robbie’s enormous fan community this must be a quite insulting thing to do. But I believe it is not. I see myself as a member of a worldwide Robbie Williams fan community, and these are the people I speak of. Too muchSome fans do things like spending vast amounts of money for hotel rooms to catch Robbie at the lounge; skipping work or school to just catch a glimpse of Robbie at the airport; getting fired because of frequent daydreaming; getting depressed because he never answered a letter; staying up all night waiting for a call that never comes; watching TV rather than going out; dumping a boyfriend for Robbie; letting go of our community to spend a little more time with those who understand. LoveAll of us love Robbie. A lot of us have seen Robbie, at least from a distance. The heart of the matter is that some of us are losing control. Why?Because it is so much easier to get lost in a dream. Being a Robbie fan for more than six years now, I started to let Robbie enter my life when I was about 14 years old. DecideEvery one of us can decide. We can choose to love Robbie forever - or to go and find love our own. We can decide if we will listen to his songs and appreciate his work - or listen to the soul mate we have always searched for. LoveI believe we all love Robbie in one or the other way, and I am sure Robbie loves all and each of us just as much very likely not in the same way at all. But today we should stop thinking about a love we will never experience - and start to learn love ourselves just a little bit more. Kathi' THANKS FOR ALL YOUR COMMENTS. THIS MESSAGEBOARD IS NOW CLOSED last updated: 23/01/2009 at 12:38 Have Your SayWhat do you think of what Kathi's point of view? Grace Sarah Paula Love Strawberry Strawberry kellie Joanne jo, lincolnshire Simah helen t lee barclay Jane, Australia. princess Abi paula Emily Collins, Hertfordshire emma Annette Roberts aged 44 Australia debra sugden sofia sr M yana mil louise robertson from edinburgh age 13
lucinda Jaybird suzy Ms Turner maria do mar Storm Darc Grainne (GC) sara Oda Maria Rose ariuka bolera Tanja Domino Sarah Sabine kaz ELMO Nadja It's me karen carpenter Liz SNA L. Katrina Burke Marlijn Chie Julie sigrid Mary love chick Sunshine! Ellie nina Estrella natalie markia SEE ALSOYou are in: Stoke & Staffordshire > Entertainment > Music > Robbie Williams > Can you love Robbie TOO much?
|
About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy |