BBC Sportrugbyunionwelsh

IN ASSOCIATION WITH

Related BBC sites

Page last updated at 08:39 GMT, Sunday, 28 February 2010

Wales - great, or greatly deluded?

By Sean Davies

Wales v France Six Nations highlights

Highlights - Wales 20-26 France

Wales coach Warren Gatland has never been shy of aiming his verbal hand grenades at teams in big-match build-ups.

But after Friday's 20-26 defeat to France, the New Zealander chose to unload his ammunition at his side's most-recent conquerors.

"At no stage did we feel under pressure because I don't think France played a lot of rugby," said Gatland, who saw his side fight back from 20-0 down at half-time.

"Our fitness was superb, and we had France on the ropes. They were out on their feet."

Gatland proud of Wales in defeat

The Kiwi's take on the game was echoed throughout the camp, players and coaches lining up to stress how close Wales are to greatness.

Ryan Jones claimed Les Bleus were "creaking" and "there for the taking", Shane Williams said France were "on the ropes" and Stephen Jones talked of Wales aiming to be "one of the best sides in the world".

It is a view that can easily seduce when one remembers the thrilling fight backs that have characterised the men in red's last three games, against France, Scotland and England.

606: DEBATE

But the idea can just as easily shatter when considering the lax and error-ridden early action that had left Wales so distant in those three Tests, and in November's hammering against Australia.

So what is the reality for Wales?

Former England coach Dick Best famously claimed that Wales' 2005 Grand Slam was built on foundations of sand, but that surely cannot be said of the present side.

The scrum shared the spoils with a formidable France eight and - although the line-out creaked once again - that seems to be a frustrating case of failures in accuracy and execution rather than personnel.

Key players like Gethin Jenkins, Matthew Rees, Alun Wyn Jones and Mike Phillips have been missing for extended periods, although strength in depth has been built in their absence.

Physicality at the breakdown is a concern, but Wales clearly have the fitness to live with the best and their attacking potential is beyond doubt.

The biggest deterioration since Gatland's inaugural, Grand Slam year of 2008 has undoubtedly been the defence.

Two years ago Wales conceded just two tries as they stormed to Six Nations glory. In three games in 2010 they have leaked seven.

Last week Gatland pointed to the continued absence of Gavin Henson as a key element in the defence's decline, but after the France game there was a more positive spin.

"We've picked an attack-loaded team and I was very proud of the defence," said defence coach Shaun Edwards.

Shane Williams celebrates his try in the defeat to France
If we can be on a level playing field going into second half against Ireland... we feel we can beat anybody

Wales flanker Jonathan Thomas

"To keep France to no offensive tries was a great effort. But there is no doubt people are doing their homework and have seen they can get intercepts, because more than 30% of our tries conceded over the last 18 months have come from intercepts."

Attack coach Rob Howley added: "We've got one of the best defensive coaches in the world and we've let him down [with the intercepts]."

Whatever the problems in the Welsh side, it seems that self belief is not one of them.

This would seem a deliberate ploy from Gatland who has identified Welsh pessimism as a weakness and has been keen to build confidence in victory ahead of major Tests.

It is the sort of thinking that saw him question Mathieu Bastareaud's fitness before the France match, to ask whether New Zealand had lost their aura before the All Blacks game and to stress his players' dislike of Ireland before last year's Six Nations decider.

When it does click for us it's going to be good

Warren Gatland

A trip to face the Championship holders in Croke Park on 13 March is next up for Wales.

"If we can be on a level playing field going into second half against Ireland... we feel we can beat anybody," flanker Jonathan Thomas has already declared.

Gatland said: "We're critical of ourselves and hard on ourselves and hopefully that will make us a better side moving forward.

"When it does click for us it's going to be good."

The coach's further pronouncements ahead of another grudge clash with his former side, Ireland, will be eagerly anticipated.

Shane Williams scores for Wales

Williams' record try can't stop France



Print Sponsor


see also
We can be great - fly-half Jones
27 Feb 10 |  Rugby Union
Gatland defiant after Wales loss
27 Feb 10 |  Rugby Union
Wales 20-26 France
26 Feb 10 |  Rugby Union
Wales v France photos
26 Feb 10 |  Rugby Union
Gatland hopeful of Henson return
24 Feb 10 |  Welsh
Six Nations table
10 Aug 06 |  Tables
Wales' rugby fixtures
26 Jun 07 |  Welsh
Wales rugby results archive
15 Oct 03 |  Welsh
Coming up next on Scrum V...
03 Nov 08 |  Welsh
BBC Sport Wales coverage
03 Oct 11 |  Wales


related bbc links:

related internet links:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites