ScotlandWalesNorthern Ireland
BBC Homepagefeedback | low graphics version
BBC Sport Online
You are in: In Depth: West Indies v South Africa  
Front Page 
Results/Fixtures 
Football 
Cricket 
Rugby Union 
Rugby League 
Tennis 
Golf 
Motorsport 
Boxing 
Athletics 
Other Sports 
Sports Talk 
In Depth 
Photo Galleries 
Audio/Video 
TV & Radio 
BBC Pundits 
Funny Old Game 

Around The Uk

BBC News

BBC Weather

banner Wednesday, 11 April, 2001, 10:14 GMT 11:14 UK
In a class of their own
South Africa celebrate their win
South Africa were superior in all facets
Caribbean broadcaster Donna Symmonds reviews the fourth Test between West Indies and South Africa in Antigua.

It was very obvious as the third Test progressed that the confidence of the West Indies' team was flagging.

At the end of the Barbados Test, I asked Shaun Pollock if he thought that the West Indies were wilting and becoming weaker.

His reply was: "I don't know. I think under the pressure of today they didn't perform like they'd like to, but the next Test match is a different game.

"It's not really for us to worry about how they're going only when we get out there and make sure we can get the wickets."

Contrast that to Carl Hooper defending his decision to bat first after winning the toss with just two pace bowlers and two spinners in the side in the fourth Test in Antigua.

Shaun Pollock celebrates their win
Pollock was not concerned with West Indies
"My major concern is that if a wicket has preparation moisture, it's what the South African seamers can do to us as opposed to what we can do to them.

"South Africa has got the type of seam attack that can set up a Test from the first innings."

These were most revealing reasons.

The decision to field first by Hooper has been blamed by many for the defeat.

On a pitch that looked dry and likely to give bowlers great assistance and deteriorate - which it did - batting first would have been an advantage.

Bowling last on the wearing pitch with two spinners would have been beneficial.

However, at the end of the game Hooper did not feel that, even with hindsight, his choice was an error.

He blamed the failure on the batsmen in the first innings conceding a 107-run lead.

Dinanath Ramnarine
Ramnarine could have benefitted from bowling last
But why was such a lead given?

In the Windies' first innings, the South African bowling was accurate and versatile despite the forced omission of Allan Donald through injury.

It was not devastating; yet the West Indies' batting ranged from abject to amateurish with a few exceptions.

The most vivid difference though, and perhaps the greatest effect on the sides, has been the fielding.

The South Africans have been dazzling in the field. This put almost unbearable constraints on the West Indies batsmen.

Neil McKenzie's catch to dismiss Brian Lara in the first innings was stupendous and the best example of how this can change the dynamics of the game

Overall, the home team's catching has been found wanting throughout the series and so it was in this match when they could least afford it.

At the times they most needed to raise their game, the hallmark of true champions, the West Indians couldn't and paid the ultimate price.

Justin Kemp is helped off the field
Justin Kemp is helped off the field
The team is generally acknowledged to be in a rebuilding phase and looked it here.

It has even been described as weak in the international context.

The West Indies have to face the fact that it was beaten by a superior team who deserve all the credit it will receive for this victory.

Now 2-0 up with one match to play, the Sir Vivian Richards Trophy is South Africa bound .

In addition, Shaun Pollock will be congratulated on captaining the seventh team to have won a series in the Caribbean.

They are just the second in 28 years and the first team since 1973 to have won a series with a match to play.

Hopefully, this loss at home will finally dispel any vestiges of belief that things were alright with West Indies cricket and the problems of the team abroad were a totally separate issue.

The talent level between the teams may be debatable. What cannot be disputed is the ability of one team to impart and withstand pressure at the highest level of the game.

That was no more starkly shown than in this fourth Test.

Search BBC Sport Online
News image
News imageNews image
News imageAdvanced search options
News image
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to top West Indies v South Africa stories are at the foot of the page.


Links to other West Indies v South Africa stories

News image
News image
^^ Back to top