ScotlandWalesNorthern Ireland
BBCiCATEGORIES  TV  RADIO  COMMUNICATE  WHERE I LIVE  INDEX   SEARCH 

BBC SPORT
You are in: You are in: Cricket: England  
Front Page 
Football 
Cricket 
Statistics 
England 
Counties 
Scorecards 
The Ashes 
Rugby Union 
Rugby League 
Tennis 
Golf 
Motorsport 
Boxing 
Athletics 
Other Sports 
Sports Talk 
In Depth 
Photo Galleries 
Audio/Video 
TV & Radio 
BBC Pundits 
Question of Sport 
Funny Old Game 

Around The Uk

BBC News

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
bannerFriday, 21 December, 2001, 06:54 GMT
Tantrums over new tactic
Tendulkar and Hussain argue
England's tactics prompted an on-field row
BBC Sport Online's Martin Gough looks at the rebirth of leg theory, with less teeth than the original but always a controversial tactic in Test cricket.

"There are two sides out there. One is trying to play cricket: the other is not. The game is too good to be spoilt. It is time some people got out of it."

Australian captain Bill Woodfull was vehement in his opposition to a new England tactic in 1932/33, a tactic which began life as "leg theory" but became immortalised as Bodyline.

Faced with taking on Donald Bradman - the finest batsman in the world - England captain Douglas Jardine opted to utilise a method first seen at Trent Bridge earlier that year.

Formner England captain Douglas Jardine
Jardine was the architect of Bodyline
Nottinghamshire fast bowlers Harold Larwood and Bill Voce had enjoyed success in county cricket by pitching short at batsmen, with a cluster of fielders behind square on the leg side.

With the ball aimed at his head, the batsman had little option but to take evasive action.

But fielders were in place to snaffle any edge resulting from a rash hook.


It was never intended that cricket should be played this way and it goes against the whole spirit of the game
Commentator Henry Blofeld
Australia was incensed, especially during the third Test at Adelaide, when Bert Oldfield was struck on the head and sustained a fractured skull.

But the tactic worked. England lost only the second Test of the series, heading home with the Ashes after a 4-1 victory. Bradman averaged 56.57 - almost 40 lower than his legendary career mark.

The political ruck that followed, though, saw a rule brought in limiting the fielding side to two fielders in catching positions behind square leg.

New plan

Although short-pitched bowling remained, and has become an accepted part of a bowler's arsenal, leg theory eased into the shadows.

On Monday, though, England captain Nasser Hussain gave hint of what was to come.

Tendulkar runs past Flintoff
Flintoff bowled short down the leg side to Tendulkar
England began the series against India adopting an 8-1 off-side field to Tendulkar - a man Bradman once described as being "a little like myself".

And that tactic was criticised by India coach John Wright, even after his side's 10-wicket victory in Mohali.

But the Little Master found the solution in Ahmedabad, when he was able to whip the ball from outside off stump to the leg-side boundary on the way to the 27th century of his Test career.

"People will adapt. Nothing is going to work for long periods, you have a window of time where they will have to work out how to play," Hussain admitted.

"When they have worked it out, you have to move on to something else."

  Law 25, Wide ball
The ball will be considered as passing wide of the striker unless it is sufficiently within his reach for him to be able to hit it with his bat by means of a normal cricket stroke.
Having seen Craig White nick a short ball from Javagal Srinath to short leg in the first innings, the plan was finalised.

With left-arm spinner Ashley Giles bowling around the wicket to keep Tendulkar bottled up, Andrew Flintoff went on the attack.

He pitched short, on a leg-side line, with a short leg in and a man at deep backward square for the hook.

If Tendulkar wanted to make runs he would have to take risks, and the intention was to frustrate the world's finest batsman into proving his mortality.

Wide rule

With Tendulkar and his collegues protected by their batting helmets, and used to the shorter delivery, the hostility of the bowling was not an issue.

But still tempers frayed, with Giles' tactics apparently the main bone of contention.

In September, the ICC tightened its rules on the calling of wides in Tests, allowing the same interpretation used in one-day internationals - basically anything down the leg-side which a batsman cannot reach - to be used in the five-day game.

The umpires could easily have called the spinner, and possibly Flintoff too, and they could have changed the course of the match in an instant.

Ashley Giles chats with captain Nasser Hussain
Hussain asked Giles to bowl negatively
But they chose not to, and were forced to step in when Tendulkar's complaining found Hussain unsympathetic.

The tactic did not find favour in all quarters, even among English onlookers.

"A slow left-hander bowling into the rough outside the right hander's off-stump produces a situation which is as near to stalemate as cricket gets," complained Henry Blofeld in the Independent.

"By adopting these tactics which are an innate admission of weakness, the captain is effectively saying to the batsmen: 'Look, we are not a good enough attack to get you out, but we are most generously going to give you the chance to commit suicide.'

"Why should the batsmen oblige? It was never intended that cricket should be played this way and it goes against the whole spirit of the game."

But the counter argument has been that England feel they have identified the best way to prevent Tendulkar from scoring quickly, and to take his wicket.

They suceeded in the first innings, when Tendulkar was stumped for the first time in his career, stepping wide of leg-stump in an attempt to drive Giles.

But the real test of the tactic will come if England need to bowl India out in their fourth innings.

If the tourists use containing tactics again, India could easily bat out a draw, and thus win the series.

See also:

08 Dec 01 |  England on Tour
From Bodyline to Boring-line
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more England stories are at the foot of the page.

 

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more England stories

News image
News image
^^ Back to top