ScotlandWalesNorthern Ireland
BBC Homepagefeedback | low graphics version
BBCiCATEGORIES  TV  RADIO  COMMUNICATE  WHERE I LIVE  INDEX   SEARCH 

BBC SPORT
You are in: You are in: Boxing  
Front Page 
Football 
Cricket 
Rugby Union 
Rugby League 
Tennis 
Golf 
Motorsport 
Boxing 
Statistics 
Athletics 
Other Sports 
Sports Talk 
In Depth 
Photo Galleries 
Audio/Video 
TV & Radio 
BBC Pundits 
Question of Sport 
Funny Old Game 

Around The Uk

BBC News

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
Friday, 3 August, 2001, 05:15 GMT 06:15 UK
Featherweight fury hits New York
Continuing his look at boxing duels that dominated a decade, BBC Sport Online's Alex Trickett revisits the 1950s and Willie Pep versus Sandy Saddler.

American historians remember the 1950s as a decade of innocence.

Enjoying the lull between World War II and the cynical sixties, the US public sat back on kitsch plastic furniture to watch I Love Lucy and The Lone Ranger on television.

It spent its hard-earned cash on new commodities like Hot Rod cars, McDonald's hamburgers and rock-and-roll music.

Willie Pep during training
Pep: One of the all-time great featherweights
And sports fans rejoiced in the prestigious achievements of their 'boy next-door' heroes, Johnny Unitas (football) and Mickey Mantle (baseball).

In New York City boxing rings, however, things were very different.

Willie Pep and Sandy Saddler had started up their rivalry in 1948 and, by the early fifties, were literally knocking lumps out of each other.

There was nothing innocent about their four featherweight bouts.

Pep was an artist.

His defensive guile earned him the nickname, 'Will 'O the Wisp' and, legend has it, once won him a round without even throwing a punch.

He came into their first fight a prohibitive favourite, boasting a record of 135 wins, one draw and one defeat with an unbeaten streak of five years.

Sandy Saddler during his training
Saddler: Pure puncher
The lean-and-mean Saddler, meanwhile, was a pure puncher.

A veteran of 93 fights himself, he was considered by many to be boxing's best kept secret before the 1948 encounter.

And so it proved.

Saddler drove forward at the opening bell in Madison Square Garden and floored a surprised Pep twice in the third en route to a fourth-round stoppage.

Pep, who admitted that he was not mentally ready for such power, prepared hard for the following year's rematch.

And, at the same New York venue, produced one of his best efforts, outboxing his opponent to notch a unanimous decision.

Saddler, who rallied strongly in the latter rounds of that contest, did not expect to get a chance of revenge.


I thought a punch to the kidney did it - but if they say I twisted his arm, okay, I twisted it
Sandy Saddler
But, not one to duck a challenge, Pep agreed to fight him again in September 1950.

This time, both men were ready and fiercely determined.

At Yankee Stadium they waged a bitter war, during which Ring Magazine assessed: "Referee Ruby Goldstein was needed in triplicate".

In a display unbecoming of two of the greatest featherweights in history, Pep pushed, pulled and thumbed his way forward, while Saddler retaliated with his share of illegal punches and wrestling moves.

Illegal armlock

Unsurprisingly, the fight ended in controversy.

Locked in a clinch at the end of round seven, the two men broke apart leaving Pep in agony.

He did not answer the bell for the eighth round and Pep accused his foe of beating him with an armlock.

"I thought a punch to the kidney did it," retorted Saddler: "But if they say I twisted his arm, okay, I twisted it."

McDonalds takeaway
The birth of McDonalds
With tempers already stretched to breaking, it was perhaps unwise to lock the two men in combat again.

But, on 26 September, 1951 they met for a final, fateful time.

On this occasion, against the genteel backdrop of New York City's Polo Grounds, the bout degenerated quickly.

Gouging, lacing, heeling and butting their way through the early rounds, the fighters even conspired to haul the referee to the canvas during a wrestling exchange in round seven.

In the end, Saddler won by a technical knockout, a result that was overshadowed by the lengthy bans handed out to both boxers.

Ignominious end

But this ignominious end should not detract from an intriguing and explosive rivalry.

And should certainly not muddy the career's of two boxing legends.

Saddler - the puncher - retired in 1957 with 103 knockouts to his name, more than any other featherweight.

Pep - the artist - fought until 1959, recording a remarkable 229 wins in 241 contests and fully justifying the description of one boxing writer, who labelled him "the tap dancer with gloves on."

Links to more Boxing stories are at the foot of the page.

 

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Boxing stories

News image
News image
^^ Back to top