| You are in: BBC Pundits |
![]() | Murrayfield set for war
The story goes that a certain Alex Murphy, mercurial half-back and Saints legend, sent a telegram to Wigan after his side's 21-2 win in the 1966 Challenge Cup final. It read: Roses are red, violets are blues, St Helens 21 Wigan 2. The two clubs didn't meet again in the Cup final until 1989, when Wigan gained revenge with a 27-0 thumping of the old enemy.
The win prompted another telegram, this time to St Helens. It read: Roses and violets are red and blue still, Wigan 27 St Helens 0 (nil). If 23 years seems a long time to bear a grudge, that's nothing. This is St Helens-Wigan - and they've been bearing grudges since the turn of the century. There isn't a derby quite like it in rugby league. Warrington-Widnes have their moments, Leeds-Bradford is quite a spat while Hull-Hull KR was once a tie to lick your lips over. But for sheer longevity of hatred, perpetual passions and a mutual longing for the other not just to fail but fall hopelessly flat on their faces, St Helens-Wigan takes the biscuit. Why? Well, they share a boundary for a start, squaring up to each other on either side of the East Lancs Road, with the village of Billinge a kind of no man's land between the two. And a derby of any real significance needs an enemy worthy of your loathing.
Throughout most of their illustrious, trophy-winning histories, Wigan and Saints have been on a par. Hence annual games become an obsession of the locals when league points are at stake. Make the Challenge Cup the prize and you have a recipe for sleepless nights and churning stomachs days before the final. There have been those who dared step foot in both camps. Murphy himself, chief tormentor of Wigan in the 60s, became coach at Central Park and led them to a then rare Wembley final in 1984. In the modern era, Bobbie Goulding, Sean Long, Andy Platt and Ellery Hanley are among those who changed allegiance. Back in time, the great centre Eric Ashton coached and captained Wigan before returning to his home town St Helens to become club chairman. Despite being born and brought up in the shadow of Knowsley Road, Ashton admits there were always those at St Helens who treated him with great mistrust because of his previous connections with Wigan.
You will never see a dull Wigan-St Helens match, they claim. But when the two sides walk out at Murrayfield on Saturday, some of the rivalry may appear to have been diluted. Too many out-of-towners in both sides for some peoples' liking. Indeed, the St Helens team could have as many players born in the Wigan Borough as in the town of St Helens. But something will catch them all - and all the intensity of the rivalry felt on the terraces will be felt by those on the pitch. And St Helens and Wigan will provide another memorable occasion for the rugby league history books. Pity they don't do telegrams anymore. |
Other top BBC Pundits stories: Links to more BBC Pundits stories are at the foot of the page. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Links to more BBC Pundits stories |
| ^^ Back to top | ||
| Front Page | Football | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League | Tennis | Golf | Motorsport | Boxing | Athletics | Other Sports | Sports Talk | In Depth | Photo Galleries | TV & Radio | BBC Pundits | Question of Sport | Funny Old Game ------------------------------------------------------------ BBC News >> | BBC Weather >> -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- © MMII|News Sources|Privacy | ||