ScotlandWalesNorthern Ireland
BBCiCATEGORIES  TV  RADIO  COMMUNICATE  WHERE I LIVE  INDEX   SEARCH 

BBC SPORT
You are in: You are in: BBC Pundits  
Front Page 
Football 
Cricket 
Rugby Union 
Rugby League 
Tennis 
Golf 
Motorsport 
Boxing 
Athletics 
Other Sports 
Sports Talk 
In Depth 
Photo Galleries 
Audio/Video 
TV & Radio 
BBC Pundits 
Question of Sport 
Funny Old Game 

Around The Uk

BBC News

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
bannerMonday, 18 March, 2002, 18:22 GMT
Cricket moves with the times
Match umpires Peter Manuel of Sri Lanka and A V Jayaprakash of India
Umpires will have more access to the third umpire
BBC Sport's Rob Bonnet believes that use of the third umpire can only serve to help the game of cricket.

It had to come and cricket should be better for it.

That has to be the view now that the International Cricket Council has approved the experimental introduction of unrestricted access by the third umpire to video replay at the Champions Trophy in Sri Lanka this September.

In striking the balance between retaining the highly personal authority of the umpires on the pitch and the all-seeing eyes of the cameras and their video replays, the ICC has drawn up a series of sensible regulations.

The third umpire must wait to be consulted - as at present.

And for decisions beyond run-outs and stumpings, he must make his decision on the basis of just two glimpses of the action.


This experiment simply lends the umpire an extra pair of eyes with the 20/20 vision of hindsight.... why reject it?
Rob Bonnet
This deals neatly with the two most cogent objections of the Luddites that the authority of the men in the middle will be undermined and that interminable references to the video replay will constantly interrupt the natural rhythms of the game.

It will not and they should not. What we have here is a formula for speedy and authoritative justice, with the umpires' authority enhanced, not diminished, by technology.

Naturally enough, former Test umpire Dickie Bird does not like it.

He was never a fan of the third umpire and his limited role in the first place now he likes it even less.

"The umpire as we knew him is finished" he says.

Only in one respect. The umpire retains all his qualities, his good faith, his skill, his perception and his impartiality. Only his fallibility is going.

Dickie Bird was a glorious showman on the field and was loved for it by the public, but the fundamental role of the umpire is low-key and unobtrusive, to serve the players - the real stars - with correct decisions as quickly and efficiently as possible.

This experiment simply lends the umpire an extra pair of eyes with the 20/20 vision of hindsight. Why reject it?

Dickie Bird
Dickie Bird is not a fan of the third umpire
Short of a power-cut or a technicians' strike, how could the new system fail its test in Sri Lanka?

Only if the umpires lean too heavily on it and the replay machine goes into meltdown.

Maybe in the past umpires have resorted a little too frequently to the replay as a kind of back-saving exercise (100% certainty is better than 99%) and just occasionally they decline the opportunity to consult the tape when perhaps they should.

What we certainly do not want is this experiment boiling over with gratuitous demands.

For instance, from batsmen that the third umpire should be called in to adjudge a catch which he suspects might be grounded or that bowlers should try to pressurise umpires into having the tape re-run for lbw every time the ball hits the batsman's pads.


The players have a responsibility here to keep their side of the bargain
Rob Bonnet
Of course the players can still appeal - though perhaps a little less extravagantly than before - but once the umpire has satisfied himself of his own decision without the tape, then that must be the end of it.

The players have a responsibility here to keep their side of the bargain.

They like the video replay because it has gone some way - and could go further - in removing the arbitrary nature of faulty decisions which can conceivably affect careers.

But they must approach this experiment in a spirit of co-operation, not exploitation. Football-style hectoring and badgering of officials just will not do.

 WATCH/LISTEN
 ON THIS STORY
News image Professional umpires chairman Alan Jones
"Anything that helps is always good"
See also:

18 Mar 02 |  Cricket
Third umpire to get more power
Links to more BBC Pundits stories are at the foot of the page.

 

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more BBC Pundits stories

News image
News image
^^ Back to top