bbc.co.uk
Home
Explore the BBC
News image 3 Oct 2014News image
Click for a Text Only version of this page
News image
BBC HomepageNews image
BBC RadioNews image
News imageNews image
TodayBBC Radio 4
Today
Listen Again
Latest Reports
Interview of the Week
About Today
Britain at 6am
Have your Say
Contact Today

What to do with Money
by Macer Hall
DAY 27: WITH THE END NEARLY IN SIGHT, THE SOCK REMAINS A DEPENDABLE ALLY.

Click here to see his money chart - updated daily.

It is four weeks since the Today programme launched an experiment to investigate how to make money. The time has arrived to tot up the balance sheet. And the bad news? In total, I ended up exactly £23.33 worse off. At the start of the experiment I raided the office piggy bank to see how five different ways of investing money would fare during this worrying time of turmoil on the money markets.

The investments included: a tracker fund based on the FTSE-100 index, a building society mini-ISA account and a portfolio of randomly chosen shares. I also stuffed some cash in a sock which was then hidden under the bed. Finally, I tried buying a lottery scratchcard every day to see if luck could make me rich. Each of the five investment was worth £28 and lasted for 28 days.

Surprisingly, the tracker fund did best, showing a profit of £1.71. Tracker funds work by “tracking” the movements of the stock market. Given all the financial gloom in recent weeks, I did not expect the fund to end up in the black, with a return of nearly six per cent. The best explanation is that the investment started when the market was very low and recovered slightly over the four weeks.

By far the worst performer was the scratchcards. Out of 28 tries, I won just twice, with sums of £1 and £2. That made a net loss of £25.

The shares lost as well, but only 13 pence. The building society made a steady but unspectacular profit of nine pence.

And the sock? Predictably, there was still exactly £28 left under the bed at the end of the experiment. But inflation will have whittled away some of that spending power over the 28 days. So that was a loser, too.

The conclusion is that making shrewd investments is all about getting the timing right. Getting it wrong can be costly.

Today listeners sent the programme lots of emails with their own money-making suggestions. The best has to be: “Grow Brussels sprouts. £28 would buy about 750 seeds. If all the plants flourished, that would make £292.50.

“I chose Brussels sprouts because I loathe their taste. I would therefore not be tempted to eat into the profits.”


He could put it in a sock, but inflation even reaches under the bed
News imageNews imageNews imageListen - What is the best thing to do with your savings?News imageNews image
Macer consults the investors bible.
Macer could join the ranks of Lottery millionaires
Soros: speculator extraordinaire


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy