bbc.co.uk
Home
Explore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.
News image 3 Oct 2014News image
Click for a Text Only version of this page
News image
BBC HomepageNews image
BBC RadioNews image
News imageNews image
Home Truths - with John PeelBBC Radio 4

Radio 4

Home Truths
Listen Again
About John Peel

Help
Feedback
Like this page?
Mail it to a friend


Transsexual Dopplegangers

In response to our current run of doppleganger stories, David Gooch takes the subject to another level of spookiness with an experience which, all in all, he seems to have taken rather calmly...

In 1989 in New York during rush hour on a 5th Avenue subway train, a very well-dressed businessman is looking at me intently. He is trying to get closer to me. I am trying to find an alternative centimetre of space to stand in. Too late.

"Can I help you?"
"How could you do it, Cheryl?"
I remember saying, "Sorry?"
"I never thought you'd go through with it"
"With what?"
"The operation of course. How can you be so blasé about it, Cheryl?" he said in a whisper.
I asked him how he knew me and he seemed quite insulted.
"We had a relationship, a very special relationship. Greg. Remember me?"
"So you think I am someone called Cheryl who went out with you and then you left her when she wanted to become a man and you believe I am this man. How can you be so sure I am this girl?"

By now there are a lot of people in this carriage listening closely. He was convinced I was her, no matter how much I told him about my history. Cheryl too was English, from Brentwood, Essex I learned and she had the same eyes, colour hair, same shape lips and nose. She had a large mole near the same ear. My appearance outweighed all other factors as far as he was concerned and he couldn't understand why I was lying to him as if I was trying to forget about my past.

The atmosphere on the carriage was more than a little tense and Greg was very close to tears. When, at last, the next station arrived he was inconsolable and all I could do was pat him pathetically on the shoulder and say I was sure that Cheryl would be out there somewhere.

If you've had a strange encounter whether in a train, plane or automobile, tell us about it in the Home Truths message boards

Join the discussion on the Home Truths Message Board

Listen Again
Hear John Peel's Tribute Program

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy