BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.


Accessibility help
Text only
BBC Homepage
BBC Music
BBC Radio 2On air now
-

Radio 2 Home
Shows A - Z
Listen by Genre
Presenters A - Z
Music Club
Podcasts
Documentaries
Schedule
Radio 2 Playlist
Radio 2 Comedy
Events
Messageboard
Radio 2 Help

Sold on Song


Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

Reviews
Honest WaterFRASER FIFIELD
Honest Water
TANCD001



In a youthful career that to date includes memorable successes with the bands Old Blind Dogs and Salsa Celtica, this is multi-talented Fraser Fifield's first solo outing. It is indeed a measure of this man's gifts that he can produce an album with so many instruments on it and still consider it to be a solo production. Malcolm Stitt provides guitar on one track and Graeme Stephen is drafted in for keyboards on three but apart from that it's all down to Fraser, even to the writing of the tunes. In fact, trad.arr doesn't even get a look in, that's how contemporary it is.

Fraser is largely known for pipes, saxophone and whistles. Combine these with keyboards, clarinet, guitar and percussion alongside his clearly diverse influences and compositional skills and a very broad canvas opens up. The numbers that work best are those that are driven by the pipes, whether small, border or highland, and are focused on a tune that has a beginning, middle and end. The opening track Dark Reel is a belter but the following tracks can lose impetus somewhat and head into musical meanderings. Described by one press cutting as "a one-man Moving Hearts", the whistle and work brings clear reminiscences of The Storm and Davy Spillane's Atlantic Bridge. But Moving Hearts were a band with artistic differences, love-hate relationships and band politics. Okay, these bring their own problems but they often also generate the internal combustion necessary to put an edge on the music and Honest Water is too solitary for that edge.

As someone who was blown away by the fire and vim in Fraser's piping with Old Blind Dogs and his tunes like Glen Kabul, I was disappointed but not downhearted by Honest Water. Not his magnus opus but there's more to come from this young Old Dog yet.

Paul Saunders - March 2003

Have you listened to the album? Want to submit a review of your own?
Fill in the form below and tell us what you think. Please mention the album's name.

I refer to the review of Fraser Fyfield's "Honest Water" album submitted by Paul Saunders in March 2003. I just wanted to point out that Graeme Stephen is, in fact a jazz guitarist and not a pianist. The keyboard parts were played by Fraser Fyfield himself. It says this on the album. Thanks.
Calum Macdonald, Aberdeen
Your nameWhere you are from
Your review
Folk & Acoustic
 Mike Harding
 Folk & Acoustic Blog
 Folk Vault
 Festivals
Cambridge 2008
BBC Young Folk Award 2009
BBC Folk Awards 2009
The Virtual Session
Links
 Message Board
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
THE MIKE HARDING SHOW

An impeccable selection of the best in folk, roots and acoustic music.
Mike Harding
MORE FOLK & ACOUSTIC
BBCi Music

Celtic Roots - BBC Scotland

Celtic Heartbeat - BBC Wales

Fraser Fifield's website

Note: The BBC is not responsible for external websites.

ALSO ON BBCi
Catch up on BBC TV and Radio. Watch and listen now.


About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy