Should I have kids?
In an increasingly scary world, many are beginning to question their procreative impulses. But are they right to?
"To be or not to be” was never your decision. No one alive today is an “exister” by consent - your parents made that call for you. But who can blame them? Animals are hardwired with strong impulses towards their procreative goals, and we humans, by and large, are no different. But for some conscientious people alive today, this most fundamental of biological impulses is butting up against a rational pessimism about the future...
With apocalyptic scenes of natural disasters, rising sea levels and global pandemics causing existential dread and actual suffering, it's understandable that CrowdScience listener Philine Hoven from Austria wrote to us asking for help her make sense of what she sees as the most difficult question she faces - should she have children?
In this episode, presenter Geoff Marsh helps Philine to predict what kind of a world her hypothetical child might inhabit, and explores the impact their existence, or indeed non-existence might have on society and the planet. Plus, we'll explore what ‘antinatalism’- a philosophical stance which argues against procreation, can tell us about the moral landscape of the unborn. With Ms Caroline Hickman, Professor Mike Berners-Lee, Professor Noriko Tsuya and Professor David Benatar.
Presented and produced by Geoff Marsh for BBC World Service
Last on
Clip
![]()
Is it morally acceptable to have children?
Duration: 02:39
Broadcasts
- Fri 22 Oct 202119:32GMTBBC World Service
- Sat 23 Oct 202101:32GMTBBC World Service Europe and the Middle East
- Sun 24 Oct 202101:32GMTBBC World Service East and Southern Africa & West and Central Africa only
- Mon 25 Oct 202103:32GMTBBC World Service Australasia, South Asia & East Asia only
- Mon 25 Oct 202104:32GMTBBC World Service Americas and the Caribbean
- Mon 25 Oct 202108:32GMTBBC World Service
- Mon 25 Oct 202112:32GMTBBC World Service except East and Southern Africa, East Asia, South Asia & West and Central Africa
Podcast
![]()
CrowdScience
Answering your questions about life, Earth and the universe


