The 4x4 debate | | 4x4 - king of the road or gas guzzler? |
To some they are the ultimate in freedom, to others they represent a major threat that could enslave us all. We're talking 4x4s... and the mud-slinging may have only just begun between those who love them and those who think they are just too big for our roads. Inside Out investigates the 4x4 controversy and looks at two very different points of view. Controversial cars It's the car that gets everyone in a heated debate - the 4x4. Users say they're comfortable and safest for their children.
Campaigners say they're endangering other people's children to say nothing of destroying the planet.
We put Vicky Harrison a Greenpeace campaigner and Neil Brownlee who owns three 4x4s in the car together and let them argue it out. Neil Brownlee loves his Land-Rovers. But not everyone's impressed by Neil's passion. Greenpeace campaigner Vicky Harrison thinks people like him are public enemy number one. While Neil spends his weekends having fun in his 4x4s, Vicky spends hers protesting against them. She's been demonstrating at a Land-Rover dealership in Neil's home town of Northampton. Greenpeace has specifically targeted the 4x4 company, accusing it of selling gas-guzzling cars which contribute towards global warming. At the Brownlee household choosing a different car means deciding what Land Rover to drive. They've got a fleet of three - mum's already left for work in hers - so the kids get to choose between the V8 Discovery and the V8 Range Rover - both cars top Greenpeace's climate hit list.
The kids love the cars so much they've even given them names. On the road
Vicky agrees to go for a spin with Neil once the children have been dropped off.
She's concerned about greenhouse gases due to what she says are the high fuel consumption of the vehicles - and safety, particularly children being knocked over by the bumper.
 | | Vicky and Neil agree... to disagree on 4x4s |
Neil disagrees - and reckons by dropping the children on his way to work he isn't making an unnecessary journey. Land Rover didn't want to take part in our report - but they did tell us that 97% of sales of the new Discovery are diesel models which average around 30 miles to the gallon.
Meanwhile Neil and Vicky will never agree. During a heated debate Vicky asks Neil, "don't you care about your children - they're going to inherit the planet". Neil retorts, "They're going to inherit a 4 x 4!" Links relating to this story:The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites |