Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Monday, 23 February, 2004, 15:17 GMT
Inquiry call over 'heroes' e-mail
Nye Bevan
Nye Bevan is the current leader of the poll
A Labour AM is calling for an inquiry into the online ballot to find Wales' greatest hero after it emerged a campaign is under way to prevent Aneurin Bevan winning the poll.

Assembly Culture Committee Member Leighton Andrews said he was "gobsmacked" to learn that Robin Gwyn, Director of Communications at the National Museum, was urging people to vote for Owain Glyndwr to oust the founder of the NHS from the lead.

The National Museum is one of the member organisations of Culturenet Cymru, which is running the poll due to be announced on St David's Day.

Mr Andrews said it called into question the integrity of the ballot - an accusation strongly rebutted by Culturenet Cymru.

It is vitally important that everybody uses their networks of members/contacts/family/friends to get Owain back on top urgently!
Robin Gwyn's e-mail

Mr Andrews added: "I've also heard from people who couldn't vote for Aneurin Bevan earlier in the week because the system wasn't working.

"I can understand why people might want to get their friends to vote for a particular hero. It's not a hanging offence - this whole contest is a bit of fun.

"But if people want to get their friends to vote they should do so from their home e-mails. I'm not actually sure that members of organisations promoting the contest should be voting at all."

Owain Glyndwr
Wales' 15th Century rebel leader, Owain Glyndwr

Mr Gwyn told BBC Wales News Online he had sent e-mails in Welsh from both home and work to a "fairly close-knit group of colleagues, friends and relatives" numbering perhaps 40 or 50.

He said he was expressing a personal opinion, and "certainly not the official view of the National Museums and Galleries of Wales".

He said the competition had been trying to encourage people to access culture online.

"As far as I know, people working for the organisations involving in the consortium were not proscribed from voting."

Mr Gwyn said: "It's a harmless bit of fun." He said the only thing he regretted was if he had caused confusion in relation to the museum.

He said Owain Glyndwr was a "personal hero - a historical figure who did a lot for Wales."

Leighton Andrews AM
Leighton Andrews: E-mail 'calls into question' ballot's integrity

One of his e-mails, in translation, read: "As you can see, Aneurin Bevan is in the lead once again - and only three days to go.

"It is vitally important that everybody uses their networks of members/contacts/family/friends to get Owain back on top urgently!"

Culturenet Cymru said that it has complete faith in the integrity of voting for its "100 Welsh Heroes" project.

Chair of Culturenet Cymru Andrew Green added: "We have taken every technical precaution possible to eliminate bogus email based votes. These votes are controlled by an email/password combination.

"To vote on the website you must register with a valid email address. This address is validated by a password. The email address is the unique identifier for any registered web user. Any particular email address can be registered only once. Registered users are informed, when they vote, that they will be able to vote again in 7 days time. If they try to vote beforehand, the vote is not counted."

The online contest is due to close on 23 February, with the 100-strong list announced on St David's Day, 1 March.

On Friday, Aneurin Bevan, the politician responsible for founding the NHS, was leading the 15th Century rebel leader Owain Glyndwr by 1863 votes to 1727.

Others in the top 10 include singer Tom Jones, politicians Gwynfor Evans and David Lloyd George, actor Richard Burton and poet and playwright Dylan Thomas.

The highest woman on the list is actress Catherine Zeta Jones, currently at number 16.




SEE ALSO:
Hero poll countdown goes on
05 Jan 04  |  Wales
Tom heads Welsh hero poll
29 Nov 03  |  Wales
Rock fans target 'hero' poll
28 Sep 03  |  Wales
Who's your Welsh hero?
09 Sep 03  |  Wales
Search for Wales' top 100
08 Sep 03  |  Wales


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific