Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
News imageNews image
Last Updated: Wednesday, 13 December 2006, 16:59 GMT
Child safety rules 'scare' adults
Professor Kathleen Marshall
Professor Marshall said adults were now afraid to interact with children
Adults are scared of working with youngsters because of strict child protection rules, MSPs were told.

The children's commissioner told Holyrood's education committee that the measures were taking an "absolutely ridiculous" toll on adults.

Professor Kathleen Marshall urged MSPs to address the issue, which she said risks leaving children neglected.

The measures are contained in legislation drawn up in the wake of the Soham murders.

Under the Protection of Vulnerable Groups Bill, a single agency will be formed to support a new vetting and barring scheme.

The scheme aims to ensure that people who should not be around children or vulnerable adults cannot access them through work.

We've become so focused on protecting our children that we risk neglecting them
Professor Marshall

Professor Marshall said: "Whether it's the child protection machinery, whether it's their perception of it, people feel that they can't do things to an absolutely ridiculous extent.

"It can be very inhibiting.

"I know that some people say it's a misconception, but if it is, it's a very pervasive misconception."

The commissioner said a youth worker had told her about a trip from a rural area with two teenagers which had to be cancelled.

"They were told that they couldn't afford it because they would have to have two adult workers to accompany these young people," she said.

"When they were questioned why they needed two, the answer was 'What happens if one of them drops dead?'

"You have to think what the risk is that we're addressing here."

'Backing off'

She added: "People feel the need to cover their backs all the time and it's small play forums, voluntary agencies, saying this has to be addressed.

"People are just backing off from interaction with children and young people."

Other examples cited were of workers who needed a mountaineering certificate to take a group of youngsters up Arthur's Seat, and a lifesaving certificate before being allowed to collect seashells with a group of children.

"As a society, we've become so focused on protecting our children that we risk neglecting them," she said.

"Not only are we increasingly regulating things through disclosure checks and widening them out and out and out and down and down and down, but even once we've got them we still don't trust them.

"We still insist that people are there in hordes and that they're not allowed to be alone with a child and we put all sorts of restrictions on them."


SEE ALSO
Charities criticise safety plans
25 Sep 06 |  Scotland
Child protection shake-up planned
08 Feb 06 |  Scotland
Site set on tackling web prowlers
23 Dec 04 |  Scotland
Child protection law put on hold
22 Dec 04 |  Scotland
Vetting body 'must work faster'
08 Jul 04 |  Scotland
Child protection measures passed
13 Feb 03 |  Scotland
New laws to protect children
09 Sep 02 |  Scotland

RELATED BBC LINKS

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific