BBC NEWSAmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia PacificArabicSpanishRussianChineseWelsh
BBCiCATEGORIES  TV  RADIO  COMMUNICATE  WHERE I LIVE  INDEX   SEARCH 

BBC NEWS
 You are in:  UK: Scotland
News image
Front Page 
World 
UK 
England 
Northern Ireland 
Scotland 
Wales 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image


Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
Tuesday, 12 March, 2002, 22:35 GMT
Lake deaths Briton 'imprudent'
Brescia court
Lilley had been on trial in Brescia
An Italian judge has explained why an oil engineer was found guilty of multiple manslaughter following a boating tragedy in Italy four years ago.

A father and his two sons from Bedfordshire died in the holiday tragedy on Lake Garda when a boat hired by John Lilley capsized in a freak storm.

Lilley, 47, from Aberdeen, was given a 20 month suspended jail sentence following the verdict by trial judge Francesco Maddalo last December.

In a written explanation, the judge said that Lilley failed to properly inform himself about safety measures and conditions on the lake.

John Lilley
John Lilley: Failed to take safety measures
The judge also added that it had been "...imprudent of Lilley to take the route he had, bearing in mind the wind and waves, and that he should have steered for the nearest shore instead of trying to sail back across the lake to where they had hired the boat from".

Signor Maddalo said that it was this action that had caused the boat to capsize and lead to the tragedy and he added that "..bearing in mind the above conduct it was also imprudent of Lilley not to ensure that those onboard had put on their lifejackets".

The motivations for the sentence were deposited at the court in Brescia, 70 days after the trial ended last December - as is normal under Italian law.

Lilley was found guilty of causing the deaths of headteacher Richard Harris, 50, and his two sons Timothy, 13 and Luke, six, from Renhold in Bedfordshire.

Ultimately responsible

One of the boat owners and four police officers on duty that day were also found guilty failing to carry out an adequate search and there sentences were also suspended.

The three month trial in the Italian city of Brescia followed the tragedy on picturesque Lake Garda where the Lilley and Harris families had met while on holiday in August 1998.

The court heard how Lilley had hired a boat and taken his two children and the Harris family out onto the normally tranquil lake for an afternoon on the water.

As he had used his British driving licence Lilley was deemed under Italian law to be the captain of the boat and therefore held ultimately responsible for the safety of those onboard.

Richard Harris
Richard Harris: Lost with his two sons
The court had heard how shortly after the party had gone onto the lake a storm blew up and turned the lake into a wall of water with wave four metres high.

The party's boat was overturned and Mr Harris and his sons drowned.

The rest of the group, Lilley his two children and Mrs Catherine Harris spent more than 12 hours in the water before they were rescued the following morning.

At first Lilley was hailed a hero but then after a police investigation he was charged and he flew to Brescia to give evidence along with his wife and two children last October.

Lilley is expected to appeal.

See also:

03 Dec 01 | Scotland
Lake deaths Briton found guilty
19 Nov 01 | Scotland
Lake tragedy jail plea
28 Sep 00 | Scotland
No claim over boat tragedy
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Scotland stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Scotland stories



News imageNews image