BBC HomepageWorld ServiceEducation
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK: Scotland
News image
Front Page 
World 
UK 
England 
Northern Ireland 
Scotland 
Wales 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image

Wednesday, 2 May, 2001, 16:18 GMT 17:18 UK
Evidence against tobacco trade
smoking at Scottish parliament
Evidence is being heard at a Glasgow hotel
A 66-year-old man - who has suffered nine heart attacks in 14 years - has been giving evidence against the tobacco industry for use in the event of his death.

Franny Traynor, who has smoked for more than half a century, was also due to be cross examined by lawyers for Imperial Tobacco behind closed doors at a Glasgow Hotel.

He is one of 20 people suing the tobacco industry in the Scottish Courts and earlier this year was asked by the company to give evidence "on commission" in case he dies before his action comes to court.

For up to three days, Mr Traynor will give evidence and face questions by Imperial's counsel, Mike Jones QC and James Wolffe.

Mr Traynor's solicitor, Cameron Fyfe, is dealing with around 140 claims against the tobacco industry, 20 of which have so far had writs lodged in court north of the border.

Cameron Fyfe
Cameron Fyfe is representing Franny Traynor
Mr Fyfe said Mr Traynor, from Milngavie near Glasgow, faced a "daunting" task.

He said: "Imperial Tobacco want to take his evidence just now because they are worried he might not survive the outcome of this case.

"We don't have legal aid so we were unable to represent him today - Imperial, on the other hand, have limitless funds.

"He has shown great courage to go through this himself and to be cross-examined by a top QC.

"It can be bad enough for some of us to confront such figures, but for Mr Traynor, it's a very daunting prospect."

Mr Fyfe saw Mr Traynor a week ago to brief him one last time before his solo submission.

He said the key case was that being brought by Margaret McTear, from Ayrshire, whose husband Alfred died of lung cancer in 1993.

He too gave evidence on commission before his death.

'No-win, no-fee'

Mr Fyfe added: "There has never been a successful case in Europe and the key case for us is the test case of McTear against Imperial Tobacco, which we are about two-thirds of the way through.

"That is on a no-win, no-fee basis and our hope is if we can win that then the other cases will be successfully concluded quite quickly.

"The basic argument we are putting forward is that these clients all began smoking before warnings were put on cigarette packets in 1971 and they had no idea that smoking was injurious to health."

Smoker
Smoking-related illnesses claim 13,500 lives each year in Scotland
Alan Porter, legal manager for Imperial Tobacco, said: "The procedure of preserving evidence in this way is quite normal.

"It can only be carried out with the approval of the court and pursuers often seek this approval themselves."

Mr Traynor on Wednesday described the first three hours of the hearing as "hair-raising stuff".

He said: "It's been pretty hair-raising stuff so far. I've a few days to go and they are going through my whole life."

Despite concerns of becoming tired during the hearing, Mr Traynor said he was bearing up, adding: "I've not been stumped."

He added: "This is very, very important, it's got to be done because my evidence has got to come out and this is only the first stage."

News imageSearch BBC News Online
News image
News image
News imageNews image
Advanced search options
News image
Launch console
News image
News image
News imageBBC RADIO NEWS
News image
News image
News imageBBC ONE TV NEWS
News image
News image
News imageWORLD NEWS SUMMARY
News image
News image
News image
News image
News imageNews imageNews imageNews imagePROGRAMMES GUIDE
See also:

10 Jan 01 | Scotland
MSPs back tobacco adverts ban
12 Dec 00 | Health
Vote on tobacco danger images
06 Dec 00 | Health
Tobacco ad ban back on agenda
14 Jun 00 | Health
Tobacco industry under attack
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Scotland stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Scotland stories



News imageNews image