BBC HomepageWorld ServiceEducation
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK: Scotland
News image
Front Page 
World 
UK 
England 
Northern Ireland 
Scotland 
Wales 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image

Thursday, 26 April, 2001, 16:21 GMT 17:21 UK
Convictions quashed after customs bungle
Court graphic
The court overturned the fraud conviction
The customs service has been criticised by the Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh for the way it handled a major fraud investigation.

A Glasgow couple convicted for tax evasion has been cleared by three judges because customs officers unlawfully executed a warrant to search the family home.

Eight police officers entered the house of Manjit and Jaswinder Singh instead of the four permitted by a sheriff.

The pair were found guilty of evading taxes at their two restaurants - the Amritsar in Bearsden and the Shezan Tandoori in Paisley.

The High Court in Edinburgh
The couple had been convicted of tax evasion
Mr Singh, 43, was jailed for three and a half years and his wife, 44, was ordered to carry out 150 community service.

Their convictions were overturned because customs officers were found to have carried out an unlawful search of the couple's home.

The Court of Criminal Appeal in Edinburgh ruled that items taken during the search were inadmissable as evidence.

Officers had gone beyond their powers and invaded the Singh's right to privacy, the court heard.

Granted special powers

The judges ruled the seizure of documents from the couple's accountant was also illegal.

Lord Cameron said: "As with any other officials who are granted special powers to be exercised in the public interest but which involve interference with an individual's right to privacy, Customs and Excise officers must exercise their powers only within the limits which are granted to them."

"If they do not do so, then they act in excess of those powers and unlawfully," said Lord Cameron, who heard the appeal with Lord Macfadyen and Lord Weir.

Mr and Mrs Singh were originally prosecuted in a trial that lasted more than seven months and began in 1998.

High Court inside
The judges said the officers should have known of the warrant conditions
They had originally been charged with the fraudulent evasion of VAT totalling �167,030, representing suppressed sales at restaurants in Glasgow and Paisley of �1.25m.

They were eventually convicted of committing fraud for an "unknown sum" of VAT through the Amritsar and Shezan Tandoori restaurants in Kirk Road, Bearsden and Glasgow Road, Paisley.

Customs men had carried out observations at the restaurants to build up a picture of the trade carried out.

But the Crown case against the couple, who were sole partners in the businesses, crucially depended on material recovered by officers in a search of the Singh's home and books obtained from their accountant.

Procedures and safeguards

Lord Cameron said they were far from satisfied that it could be said that four extra officers had not taken part in the search.

He said the Singhs would not have known of the terms of the warrant and so could not have objected at the time.

However, said Lord Cameron, said the customs officers should have known of the restrictions.

The appeal judges said that the convictions of the couple must be quashed.

HM Customs and Excise said it has strict procedures and safeguards relating to warrants and officers are aware they have a duty to fully respect the rights of the individual.

News imageSearch BBC News Online
News image
News image
News imageNews image
Advanced search options
News image
Launch console
News image
News image
News imageBBC RADIO NEWS
News image
News image
News imageBBC ONE TV NEWS
News image
News image
News imageWORLD NEWS SUMMARY
News image
News image
News image
News image
News imageNews imageNews imageNews imagePROGRAMMES GUIDE
See also:

27 Nov 00 | Scotland
Customs' black market caution
28 Aug 00 | Scotland
Union fears customs move
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Scotland stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Scotland stories



News imageNews image