BBC HomepageWorld ServiceEducation
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK: Scotland
News image
Front Page 
World 
UK 
England 
Northern Ireland 
Scotland 
Wales 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
News image

Sunday, 19 November, 2000, 09:07 GMT
Experts call for Scottish law reform
Courts graphic
The professors have produced their own code
A group of Scotland's leading legal experts are set to call for a "fundamental reform" of Scotland's criminal law system.

Professors from three Scottish universities believe that a new European-style penal code should be introduced by the Scottish Parliament which would spell out major crimes more clearly.

They have prepared their own draft version, which would introduce specific offences of stalking and harassment.

It is also suggested that the rape laws be altered to abolish the rule under which a man can be found not guilty if he unreasonably believed that the victim was consenting.

Jim Wallace
The revised document will go to Jim Wallace
A conference will be held in Edinburgh on Monday to allow leading figures within the criminal justice system to voice their views on the proposals.

The draft document has been produced by law Professors Eric Clive and Sandy McCall Smith from Edinburgh University, Christopher Gane from Aberdeen University and Pamela Ferguson from Dundee University.

Professor Clive will tell the conference that it is still possible for a person to be charged without being told the name of the alleged offence or the law which created the offence.

The law for many crimes is contained within old books and court decisions which are not readily accessible to the public - and often difficult to interpret or contradictory, he will say.

Basic crimes

One of the books still relied on by the courts was first published shortly after the French Revolution and was last updated in the mid-19th Century.

He will say Scotland is unusual because many basic crimes - including murder, rape, theft and assault - depend on judges' statements rather than parliamentary decisions.

Professor Gane will argue that the new code would bring male rape within the category of rape, and would also introduce an offence of stalking.

House-breaker
Theft has the same maximum sentence as murder
It would also mean that an unreasonable belief that the victim had consented to sex would no longer be a defence to a rape charge.

Professor Ferguson will say that the current breach of the peace charge is ill-defined.

This means that any behaviour which annoys, alarms or even embarrasses other people can lead to prosecution.

The new code would narrow the definition while providing specific charges of harassment and stalking.

Professor Smith will tell how the draft code would rationalise the maximum penalties for different offences.

Next step

The existing law has been criticised because no attempt has been made to grade the maximum penalties, which are the same for breach of the peace as they are for rape, and the same for theft as they are for murder.

Those attending the conference will include sheriffs and Crown Office representatives, the Law Society of Scotland, police, victim's groups and the justice department.

Organisers say that the next step will depend on the outcome of the conference.

But their intention is to revise and improve the code in light of the comments made on Monday and submit it to Justice Minister Jim Wallace for his consideration.

News imageSearch BBC News Online
News image
News image
News imageNews image
Advanced search options
News image
Launch console
News image
News image
News imageBBC RADIO NEWS
News image
News image
News imageBBC ONE TV NEWS
News image
News image
News imageWORLD NEWS SUMMARY
News image
News image
News image
News image
News imageNews imageNews imageNews imagePROGRAMMES GUIDE
See also:

02 Oct 00 | Scotland
Rights law 'will cause errors'
27 Sep 00 | Scotland
More fiscals to tackle workload
08 Sep 00 | Scotland
Legal system 'fails victims'
25 Aug 00 | Scotland
Law change for new court
Links to more Scotland stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Scotland stories



News imageNews image