| You are in: UK: Politics | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Monday, 21 October, 2002, 18:31 GMT 19:31 UK Customs defended over 'booze cruises' ![]() Legitimate traders are hit by bootleg beer sales The government has defended customs officers against the rising tide of complaints about the way they treat cross-Channel shoppers.
The Sun newspaper says Treasury Minister John Healey is about to perform a retreat on the row by issuing new guidelines to Customs. Mr Healey said the guidelines were always under review but stressed the tough task customs officers faced in weeding out smugglers from among honest shoppers. A group of Channel shoppers in July won a landmark case over the way customs officials stopped and searched people bringing tobacco and alcohol into the UK. Shoppers' distress Shoppers have complained of being intimidated by customs staff and having their cars impounded and sold. Solicitor Belinda Paisley told BBC Radio 4's World At One that one man had been reduced to tears by customs officers asking his son to prove he was disabled. The High Court ruled that officials wanting to search cars had to have a specific reason to suspect people were carrying goods meant for resale rather than personal use.
"We feel in particular that there may not be enough distinction made between genuine shoppers and smugglers," Mr Todd the World At One. In a single market, shoppers should be able to import goods for their own use rather than for commercial resale, said Mr Todd. 'No bullying' The EU had still to be reassured over three key concerns, said Mr Todd: how people could prove goods were for their own use; worries about the grounds for checks; and 'disproportionate' penalties. John Healey, the Treasury minister responsible for Customs, said customs officers were not bullies. "Customs have got a tough job in these ports," Mr Healey told BBC Radio 4's PM programme.
Customs officers faced daily abuse and some times assaults as they tried to do their work, said Mr Healey. When the current checks regime was introduced, �1.7bn a year was being lost through bootleg imports, he said. Mr Healey said "99.9%" of shoppers went through Customs without problems and most of those who were stopped were free to continue their journeys. He added: "Sometimes customs officers will overstep the mark, but we have clear complaints procedures in place to deal with that." 'Heavy handed' Earlier, Conservative shadow chancellor Michael Howard said action was needed against smugglers, who cost both legitimate traders and the Treasury much money. But a balance had to be struck between enforcing the law and being heavy handed with innocent shoppers. "It seems increasingly clear from the number of complaints that the government is not getting the balance right," said Mr Howard. The problem could stem from the way the current guidelines were being implemented, suggested the Folkestone MP. But whatever the cause, a better balance had to be struck between tackling smuggling and the rights of shoppers, he added. | See also: 31 Jul 02 | UK 26 Mar 02 | England 31 Jan 02 | England 19 Dec 01 | UK 31 Jul 02 | Business Internet links: The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() | ||
| ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- To BBC Sport>> | To BBC Weather>> | To BBC World Service>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- © MMIII | News Sources | Privacy |