Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 9 December, 2003, 07:22 GMT
Vote fraud measures criticised
Ballot box
The report found anti-voting measures had an adverse impact
Measures to combat voting fraud in Northern Ireland have had a negative impact on young people and those in poorer areas, according to a report.

The study published on Tuesday was carried out by the Electoral Commission earlier this year, but its release was delayed until after the assembly election.

The need to register every year was brought in by the Electoral Fraud Act 2002.

In the past, one form was given to every household, but now everyone has to register individually.

The commission said this measure tended to have an adverse impact on disadvantaged, marginalised and hard to reach groups.

'DISADVANTAGED' GROUPS
Young people
Students
Those with learning disabilities
Residents in poorer areas

It meant young people, students, people with learning disabilities and those living in poorer areas were less likely to register, according to the government-appointed watchdog.

The chief electoral officer believes reinstating part of the old system - whereby some names were "carried forward" by one year - could help prevent 150,000 voters dropping off the register.

However, the commission said it was not convinced this would work.

Voting register

The report also called for a review of the special hearings procedure for those who want to be added to the electoral register.

It said the practice was unique to Northern Ireland.

The new system that is in place - and the register published for the last election - is a very sound, a very robust register
Seamus Magee
Electoral Commission

Thousands of people who applied to get their names added to the voting register were asked to attend such hearings.

The commission says less than half of them showed up, suggesting that they were put off by the hearings' "semi-judicial nature".

The head of the Electoral Commission, Seamus Magee, said more than 70% of people surveyed felt the new measures had instilled greater confidence in the democratic process.

"On the other hand, there are some negatives. One of those is that the individual registration has tended to make it more difficult for young people in particular and for people with disabilities to register," he said.

"The challenge that we have is to address those particular issues - to ensure the registration rate, which is currently around 88%, is up as close into the 90s as we can."

Mr Magee said it was important to get the message across that people needed to continue to register on an annual basis.

"The new system that is in place - and the register published for the last election - is a very sound, a very robust register.
Paul Murphy welcomed the commission's report
Paul Murphy welcomed the commission's report

"Albeit, it doesn't contain all those who are eligible to vote in Northern Ireland. To actually carry forward - as was the old system - and inflate the register is not possibly the best way to go.

"We would have a different view than the Chief Electoral Officer on this matter."

Secretary of State Paul Murphy described the report as "an impressive study".

"I note that the commission does not agree with the assertion that 120,000 people were disenfranchised as a result of the new legislation.

"I am also pleased that the report concludes that the 2002 register more accurately reflects those entitled to be registered"'

He added: "I welcome the fact that public confidence has increased as a result of the Act. But we cannot become complacent and there is still work to be done to ensure that all those entitled to vote, take the opportunity to register."

Sinn Fein MP Martin McGuinness said it was "very obvious to anyone involved in the recent election campaign that the current system is deeply flawed".

"It is my intention to meet with the Electoral Commission in the time ahead to discuss the many problems which we encountered during the recent campaign."




WATCH AND LISTEN
BBC NI's Martina Purdy:
"The study was carried out by the government appointed watchdog, the Electoral Commission"


BBC NI's Mark Devenport:
"The need to register every year was brought in by the Electoral Fraud Act 2002"


The Electoral Commission's Seamus Magee:
"More than 70% of people surveyed felt the new measures had instilled greater confidence"




LATEST NEWS
News image
RESULTS SEARCH
To find out the results where you live, enter your full postcode
 
News image
ELECTION GUIDE

KEY PEOPLE PROFILED
 
PARTY MANIFESTOES
 
POLITICAL PARTY LINKS
 
LINKS
 
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific