Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 18 September, 2003, 11:29 GMT 12:29 UK
Attack on farm worker 'abuse'
Cauliflowers in the field
The report says the government has failed to confront abuses
Britain's supermarkets and the government are under attack for failing to curb abuse in the use of casual labour to supply fruit and vegetables.

Part-time farm workers are being exploited by so-called "gangmasters" who provide casual labour to the agriculture and horticulture industries, say MPs.

Their calls are highlighted by the deaths of three migrant workers in Worcestershire, in July.

They had travelled from Birmingham to pick spring onions and were killed when the van in which they were travelling collided with a train at an unmanned level crossing near Evesham.

The occupants of the van were reported to be working for gangmasters.

One of those who died was 23-year-old Soran Karim, an Iraqi Kurd who came to this country to escape persecution.

He had been living in Stoke-on-Trent with two other Iraqis.

Not allowed to work

One of his friends, Ibrahim Hussain told the BBC he did not know Mr Karim was trying to earn extra cash, possibly because as an asylum seeker he should not have been working.

The facts of the three men's deaths are now being heard in the courts, the van driver has been charged with manslaughter.

The accident happened while members of the environment food and rural affairs select committee were investigating the gangmaster system.

Their report, Gangmasters, published on Thursday, says gangs are often made up of workers from overseas, some of whom are illegal migrants.

Many of these gangs who are picking crops and packing produce operate outside the law, according to a report by the select committee.

It is a disgrace that the government has failed to give priority to the issue of gangmasters
David Lidington,
Shadow environment secretary
MPs are convinced supermarkets' dominance over suppliers have helped create an environment where gangmasters' illegal activity could develop.

But major supermarkets have defended their policies.

Price competition and short timescales for orders put pressure on suppliers - leaving little opportunity or incentive to check the legality of labour sources, claim MPs.

"The enforcement agencies are insufficiently resourced and lack the political backing to make a significant impact on illegal activity within the agriculture and horticulture labour market," the report said.

Abuse cases

The report looked at serious incidents involving foreign workers, including a case from a Citizens Advice Bureau in Cambridgeshire in which workers had been housed in partitioned containers with no water supply.

Their contracts included an agreement to re-pay up to �1,000 if they left within six months.

CAB spokesman Andrew Seagar said the workers they saw were only the "tip of the iceberg".

But consumers were also to blame for demanding low priced fresh produce round-the-clock.

The CAB has called for government and European Union action to inform members of their rights before they arrive in the UK.

Shadow environment secretary David Lidington criticised the government's inaction in dealing with illegal labour suppliers.

"This is a damning report. It is a disgrace that the government has failed to give priority to the issue of gangmasters," he said.

A Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs spokesman said the government recognised the seriousness of the abuse and was working with organisations to devise a code of good practice and accreditation system for labour suppliers.

Code of conduct

But operations director of a farm in Stretham, Cambridgeshire, Kier Petherick, said it was a "popular misconception" all growers used illegal labour to maximise profits.

"They come for two or three days then disappear, and you get new people. It's a constant battle with retraining."

He said teamwork, health and safety for workers and quality for the customer were more important.

"We couldn't function with gang labour," he added.

We are heavily committed to helping our suppliers in the sourcing of temporary labour
Marks and Spencer
One Polish worker on the farm - which sees workers earning �5-6,000 in around 12 weeks - said he had worked there for two seasons and hoped to return next year.

"After a few years I will be able to buy a house in Poland. I have already bought a car from the money I earn here," he told BBC Breakfast.

A spokeswoman for Sainsbury's supermarket said the chain took the issue "extremely seriously", being the first supermarket to address it by working with the Ethical Trading Initiative (ETI) and to introduce a supplier code of conduct.

"We pride ourselves on having a good relationship with our suppliers and regularly visit them to monitor practices," she said.

Marks and Spencer also cited the progress it had made through the ETI and by requiring suppliers to implement the company's Global Sourcing Principles.

"We are heavily committed to helping our suppliers in the sourcing of temporary labour.

"We currently provide suppliers with Guidelines on Best Practice of Employing Staff to help ensure the labour they hire has controls in place with regard social compliance and legality of employment," said a spokeswoman.

It is also calling for a 'White List' of approved employment agencies that comply with stringent guidelines to ensure suppliers only use approved sources.




WATCH AND LISTEN
The BBC's James Coomarasamy
"Few dispute that the problem is growing"



SEE ALSO:
MP wants controls on 'gangmasters'
10 Sep 03  |  Lincolnshire
New foreign recruits for UK farms
27 Nov 02  |  Politics


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific