Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
News image
Last Updated: Thursday, 16 February 2006, 11:00 GMT
Debate over 'employable' degrees
archway
Some traditional academic subjects showed drops in applicants
Higher Education Minister Bill Rammell has said it is "no bad thing" if students are choosing newer vocational subjects over more traditional ones.

The latest figures on UK university applications show a fall in the number of people wanting to study subjects such as classics, history and music.

Big rises were seen in the numbers opting for nursing, social work, pharmacology and maths.

Overall, there was a 3.4% fall in numbers applying for university.

The figures were released by the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service.

Subjects which show a fall in applications include history (44,267 applications, -7.8%), music (19,367 applications, -11%), and English studies (51,660 applications, - 4.5%).

Those showing increases include nursing (51,677 applications, +15.4%), social work (40,875, +7.4%) and maths (30,707 applications +11.5%).

'Best opportunity'

Minister Bill Rammell said: "What you might describe as subjects which students see as being really non-vocational, like fine art, philosophy, classical studies, have seen big reductions.

"An initial reading of figures suggests to me that there is some evidence that students are choosing subjects they think are more vocationally beneficial.

"If that's what they are doing I don't see that as necessarily being a bad thing," he said.

Asked if there was any merit in students' taking courses in history and philosophy, Mr Rammell said: "Of course there is and if people want to do that I am not going to stop them.

"But if students are making a calculation about which degree is going to get them the best job and the best opportunity in life, I see that as being no bad thing."

'Divide'

Mr Rammell's comments provoked criticism from some academics. Sean Lang, a teacher and honorary secretary of the Historical Association, said the remarks were "very short-sighted".

"It shows a very limited understanding of the very wide application of academic subjects.

"People are always saying we need to get over the academic-vocational divide. What he is doing is entrenching it rather than bridging it."

Philosophy was among the many subjects showing a fall in applications in a year where the overall trend is down.

Employers value the capacity for clear critical analysis gained from studying philosophy
Timothy Williamson, Oxford University

There have been 8,293 applications, a fall of 3.9% on last year.

Timothy Williamson, Wykeham Professor of Logic at Oxford University, said: "Philosophy teaches you how to detect bad arguments, so it's no surprise when politicians aren't keen for it to be studied.

"Employers value the capacity for clear critical analysis gained from studying philosophy."

Mixed picture

Overall, the picture is not a clear one of vocational subjects increasing at the expense of traditional ones. There are many exceptions.

For example, design studies has shown a fall in popularity. There were 33,554 applications, down 10.2% on the same time last year.

Also, electronic and electrical engineering (16,664 applications) was down by 18.6%.

The most popular subject is law, which was also down (80,929 applications, -7.4%).

University courses
Applications by January 15, 2006
SubjectTotalChange
Law by Area 80,929 -7.4%
Pre-clinical Medicine 75,297 0.3%
Psychology 74,151 -6.3%
Management studies 56,005 -0.2%
Nursing 51,677 15.4%
English studies 51,660 -4.5%
Training Teachers 48,374 0.7%
Business studies 46,330 -3.7%
History by Period 44,267 -7.8%
Social Work 40,875 7.4%
Computer Science 40,415 -10.3%
Sports Science 39,961 1.7%
Combs of social studies/bus/law with arts/humanities 38,672 -4.9%
Combs of languages with arts/humanities 37,548 -9.1%
Drama 37,270 -1.1%
Combinations within Business & Admin Studies 36,057 4.7%
Economics 33,651 -2.0%
Design studies 33,554 -10.2%
Anatomy Physiology and Pathology 30,864 -5.7%
Mathematics 30,707 11.5%
Others in Subjects allied to Medicine 28,773 8.8%
Accounting 26,208 -5.7%
Combs of science/engineering with social studies/bus/law 25,489 -5.7%
Combs of science/engineering with arts/humanities/languages 25,279 -3.1%
Pharmacology Toxicology and Pharmacy 24,260 9.6%
Biology 22,050 -6.3%
Politics 21,855 0.0%
Architecture 21,579 0.7%
Mechanical Engineering 20,806 -7.3%
Media studies 20,368 -9.7%
Music 19,367 -11.0%
Chemistry 18,670 5.8%
Sociology 18,613 -5.4%
Cinematics and Photography 18,401 -2.6%
Physical & Terrestrial Geog & Env Sci 18,333 -1.9%
Physics 17,061 2.3%
Combs of soc studies/law with business 16,878 -6.1%
Electronic and Electrical Engineering 16,664 -18.6%
Civil Engineering 16,462 2.2%
Combs of phys/math science with social studies/bus/law 15,993 -1.0%
Combs of arts/humanities 15,892 -4.9%
Academic studies in Education 14,663 16.8%
Combinations within Social Studies 14,583 -5.7%
Human and Social Geography 14,474 -6.5%
Combs of social studies/bus/law with languages 14,085 -6.5%



RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific