Skip to main contentAccess keys help

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated:  Friday, 21 March, 2003, 10:31 GMT
A-level reforms 'have failed'
Exam room
Pupils need to take more vocational courses, according to Ofsted.
Attempts to make students take a broader range of subjects at AS and A-level have largely failed, the education watchdog has claimed.

Under the Curriculum 2000 reforms, sixth-formers were expected to study up to five subjects at AS-level, before focusing on three subjects at A2, the second half of the new-look A-level.

But Ofsted chief inspector David Bell said: "The range of subjects taken has not broadened significantly, and the scope of teaching within subjects has narrowed, as teachers have concentrated on course specifications."

The "underlying weaknesses that Curriculum 2000 was designed to address", still had to be tackled, he added.

'Narrow focus'

However, the Department for Education and Skills said lessons had been learned and the situation was improving.

Ofsted's report follows the judgment by the inquiry into last year's A-level marking scandal, which said A and AS-levels should be split into stand-alone qualifications.

This would effectively mean a return to the pre-2000 set-up.

And in January, a "working group" was set up by Education Secretary Charles Clarke to produce proposals for a Baccalaureate-style replacement for A-levels, bringing the system in line with that of France.

Ofsted inspectors visited 110 state and private schools in England, as well as sixth form and further education colleges during the first two years of Curriculum 2000.

'Learned important lessons'

They found the large number of AS and A-level exams students had to take "led to a narrowing of focus" - the opposite of what the government had intended.

While most lower sixth formers took four subjects instead of the traditional three, it was "common" for them to drop one before they finished the first year.

Ofsted said "very few" schools and colleges required a mix of vocational and academic subjects, while they also had less time for extra-curricular activities such as sport and music.

Sixth formers were also not being told about the range of courses on offer, which included job-related modern apprenticeships.

Action should be taken to encourage students to "mix and match" much more, said Ofsted.

A Department for Education and Skills spokeswoman said: "This report only refers to the situation up until June last year and we have already learned important lessons from the early days of Curriculum 2000.

"Many of the issues raised by Ofsted have already been identified and action has been taken to tackle weaknesses and provide better support to teachers and students.

"The evidence is that these reforms are starting to have an impact. There will be a further review of the Curriculum 2000 reforms by QCA in September."


SEE ALSO:
Call to end 'ludicrous' A-levels
07 Mar 03 |  Education
New drive for exam markers
25 Feb 03 |  Northern Ireland
Call for employers to mark exams
14 Feb 03 |  Education
Exams not assured, watchdog says
30 Jan 03 |  Education
Government exam targets missed
28 Jan 03 |  Education


INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
AmericasAfricaEuropeMiddle EastSouth AsiaAsia Pacific